Holocaust survivors struggling to make ends meet in Israel

[bricolage]

Despite the horrors of a childhood in the shadow of the Holocaust, Ros Dayan survived to build a life she could be proud of in the new Jewish state of Israel.

She trained as a nurse, she sang in a choir that toured the world. She learnt Hebrew, though she never lost her central European accent. She paid her taxes and eventually bought the tiny house in Jaffa that she had rented at a subsidised rate for years. She even learned to live with the pain of three broken vertebrae, the result of an assault by a Nazi soldier.

But, now, in the last years of her life, Ros is ashamed. One of the 198,000 Holocaust survivors still alive in Israel, she is also one of the growing proportion who cannot make ends meet, who struggle with insufficient funds on a daily basis.

Wiping a single tear with a shaking hand, she says: "For the first time, I don't have enough money for food or clothes. I used to have pride, now I am ashamed."

As Israel commemorates Holocaust Day on Thursday, Ros resents those who mourn the six million Jews that died without considering the penury of some of those still living. "On Holocaust Day, they make a parade, those who do not know what a Holocaust is, what hunger is. The people who suffered in the Holocaust are left behind, hungry."

According to studies, around a quarter of Holocaust survivors in Israel live below the poverty line, struggling to pay for food, heating, housing, medication and care.

As survivors get older – almost 90% are over 75 – their resources diminish as their needs grow. Many are widowed, and a high proportion of those receiving assistance are childless. As well as basic living needs, most face expensive bills for medication, and around 20,000 need 24-hour care.

"A lot of survivors face big medical bills, and life in Israel is very expensive generally," says Deborah Garel of the Jaffa Institute, which distributes bi-monthly food parcels to Holocaust survivors. "Holocaust survivors going hungry in Israel? This is not right. After being hungry in the ghetto, they shouldn't be hungry in the Jewish state."

The government is doing its best, says Garel, but many survivors do not know what their rights or entitlements are, and many are incapable or do not have the mental energy to go through necessary bureaucratic hurdles to obtain benefits.

This week, the government announced an increase in funds for the needs of survivors from 206m shekels (£34.2m) a year to 225m. It points out that, despite the overall declining numbers of people who lived through WW2, more people are being defined as Holocaust survivors according to criteria set by the government and are therefore eligible for funding.

Garel says more Israelis and Jews in other countries should contribute from their pockets for the care of survivors. "It's the responsibility of every Jew to give to the few that are remaining. If everyone made a small annual donation, it would make a big difference."

After Ros and her family were driven from their comfortable middle-class home in Sofia, they spent the rest of the war in extreme fear and hunger. "I never felt like a child, I never had a childhood," she recalls. "We lived on 300g of bread a day. Potatoes were a luxury food."

But the family were spared the death camps, and after the war they made their way by boat to the place that would soon become Israel. They landed in Haifa with few possessions and no money or valuables.

After a rocky and lonely beginning, Ros married and built a new life. Now a childless widow, she was recently forced to hire a full-time, live-in carer – a necessary expense which she simply cannot afford. She is bitter about her circumstances.

"I love this country, but I don't feel Jewish here. I came here to feel Jewish. Every Holocaust day I'm sad for what we lost, and I'm sad I didn't end up in a country that loves me," she says.

The problem of impoverished Holocaust survivors is acute but not long-term. Twelve thousand survivors in Israel died over the past year, and the current rate is one death an hour.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012...e-money-israel

[RedSonRising]

Very sad news. Perfect example of how Israel's propaganda and thematic cultural emphasis is nothing more than part of the agenda to serve those benefiting from the economic and military functions of the state.

[Misanthrope]

Poor Israelis... but sincerely, this piece really does nothing in terms of thought progression. The international proletariat is suffering under capitalism regardless of race, religion or past. The article is really nothing more than a red herring to the ongoing atrocities committed in Palestine.

Yes, we get it. The Holocaust was a tremendous tragedy but humans have not learned from it. Which is why there are 'holocausts' being committed right beneath the very nose of the world. Countless, endless.. Where is the media attention there? The portrayal of the holocaust in contemporary media and academia has failed at preventing genocide, which is the exigency or so we're told.

[Sinister Cultural Marxist]

Poor Israelis... but sincerely, this piece really does nothing in terms of thought progression. The international proletariat is suffering under capitalism regardless of race, religion or past. The article is really nothing more than a red herring to the ongoing atrocities committed in Palestine.

Um, not really, it's an example of how Israel, which constantly uses the holocaust to justify its existence, does not do this for substantive reasons but for propaganda purposes to make Israelis, Jews and others in the world afraid that the same thing will happen if the Israeli state de-militarizes. To be a red herring, it needs to be designed to distract from the Palestinian issues, but quite frankly nothing like that is happening here. The suffering of the Palestinians is not mutually exclusive with the suffering of Israeli holocaust victims. You are missing the bigger picture, which is that the suffering of both of these groups have a common source on a deeper level.

Yes, we get it. The Holocaust was a tremendous tragedy but humans have not learned from it. Which is why there are 'holocausts' being committed right beneath the very nose of the world. Countless, endless.. Where is the media attention there? The portrayal of the holocaust in contemporary media and academia has failed at preventing genocide, which is the exigency or so we're told.

I don't see why this fact means that we should ignore the fact that survivors of this holocaust cannot even live their last days of retirement in comfort, at the same time Bibi Netenyahu is trying to start a war presumably to "prevent the next holocaust". It shows that the rhetoric of their government is empty and based on hypocrisy.

You are wrong about media coverage and academia during the holocaust-it suffered from the same phenomenon of a lack of media or academic attention at the time. In that respect, the holocaust is no different from all the other genocides that go ignored while they are actually occurring. Also, it was a unique genocide in history insofar as the Nazis actually tried to industrialize it, and it ended up leaving more victims in total than any other genocide of the 20th century.