Thread: The Rich Earned Their Wealth

Results 21 to 40 of 61

  1. #21
    Join Date Jul 2005
    Posts 6,289
    Rep Power 116

    Default

    the point is that capital is driving the earth, both socially and materially, to the fuckin ground
    Formerly dada

    [URL="https://gemeinwesen.wordpress.com/"species being[/URL] - A magazine of communist polemic
  2. #22
    Join Date Nov 2010
    Location Michigan
    Posts 409
    Organisation
    CWI
    Rep Power 13

    Default

    Next to nothing? You know what the median wage (not the minimum) is in the USA? Take a guess before you hit the link. Sorry, it's from 2006. you can prolly find 2011.

    http://bigthreeauto.procon.org/view....esourceID=2050
    These are averages (means), not medians.

    I think if an entrepreneur can create vast amounts of wealth entirely on his own, without the exploitation of labor he's not only a freak of economics but of nature as well. Right up there with the Flash and Superman.
  3. #23
    Join Date Sep 2011
    Location Louisiana
    Posts 237
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    Right, right... the only way to become wealthy is blue blood, "exploiting" the workers or getting "lucky". I mean, what is it with me? How could I get "lucky" time and time again? How was I lucky enough to make sacrifices and sell everything I owned to raise a little trading capital? Lucky enough to do odd jobs for even more? And then after working my ass off and going hungry just to save $1000, how do I manage to get lucky every single day and maintain a success/failure ratio in my day trading of around 14:3? To generate returns of over 1000% in a few months time? Just luck, definitely... Working hard for something and sticking to it had nothing to do with it...

    @ Bardo: Then I guess I'm an "economic freak" then...
    I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it. - Thomas Jefferson
  4. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to kapitalyst For This Useful Post:


  5. #24
    Join Date Oct 2011
    Location Oakland, CA
    Posts 32
    Organisation
    CPI (M)
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    I was going to say that the rich earned their wealth about as much as a bank robber or a thief, but that isn't really true because robbing a bank can be a lot of work

    Teach them basic human psychology. People will do almost anything for food, starvation is possibly the worst way to die.

    That's a good post.
  6. #25
    Join Date Apr 2002
    Location Northern Europe
    Posts 11,176
    Organisation
    NTL
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    Right, right... the only way to become wealthy is blue blood, "exploiting" the workers or getting "lucky". I mean, what is it with me? How could I get "lucky" time and time again? How was I lucky enough to make sacrifices and sell everything I owned to raise a little trading capital? Lucky enough to do odd jobs for even more? And then after working my ass off and going hungry just to save $1000, how do I manage to get lucky every single day and maintain a success/failure ratio in my day trading of around 14:3? To generate returns of over 1000% in a few months time? Just luck, definitely... Working hard for something and sticking to it had nothing to do with it...
    Don't think anyone said the ONLY way.

    Your not even in the real economy, your not in production or markets, your not actually in real finance (loans and the such), you buy and sell stocks.
  7. #26
    Join Date Jul 2011
    Location Broviet Union
    Posts 653
    Organisation
    Philly Socialists
    Rep Power 19

    Default

    Right, right... the only way to become wealthy is blue blood, "exploiting" the workers or getting "lucky". I mean, what is it with me? How could I get "lucky" time and time again? How was I lucky enough to make sacrifices and sell everything I owned to raise a little trading capital? Lucky enough to do odd jobs for even more? And then after working my ass off and going hungry just to save $1000, how do I manage to get lucky every single day and maintain a success/failure ratio in my day trading of around 14:3? To generate returns of over 1000% in a few months time? Just luck, definitely... Working hard for something and sticking to it had nothing to do with it...

    @ Bardo: Then I guess I'm an "economic freak" then...
    1. You were lucky to have stuff to sell in the first place.

    2. You were lucky enough to have those odd jobs offered to you.

    3. You were lucky that you had enough income that you could save $1000.

    You're not looking at the big picture. Some people work their asses off, go hungry, and only make $2 a day!
    Imagine a boot stamping on a human face forever, saying:

    "I KNOW YOU FEEL UPSET RE STAMPING, BUT THAT'S DIFFERENT FROM STRUCTURAL OPPRESSION"
  8. #27
    Join Date Apr 2002
    Location Northern Europe
    Posts 11,176
    Organisation
    NTL
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    and lucky enough to be born in a country with protected capital markets.
  9. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to RGacky3 For This Useful Post:


  10. #28
    Join Date Sep 2011
    Location Louisiana
    Posts 237
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    Don't think anyone said the ONLY way.

    Your not even in the real economy, your not in production or markets, your not actually in real finance (loans and the such), you buy and sell stocks.
    Your notions of what is "real" are simply false...

    And this is not the only thing I'm working on. It's a vehicle for raising financial capital and generating income until I launch my full-out enterprise and incorporate in 2012.

    The first thing I'm doing is establishing a financial subsidiary (which will primarily operate a hedge fund) to provide investment services and retirement investment for everyone from institutional investors and millionaires to regular working class families. Then I'm opening the tech/software subsidiary to get the projects I've funded out-of-pocket for the last three years to the market quickly. I also hope I can, some day, launch my own bank and small loans services that doesn't fuck people through stupid policies wrapped in legalese bullshit. I have full confidence that the business plan will be a resounding success -- treating people right makes more money than screwing them out of nickles and dimes.
    I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it. - Thomas Jefferson
  11. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to kapitalyst For This Useful Post:


  12. #29
    Join Date Apr 2002
    Location Northern Europe
    Posts 11,176
    Organisation
    NTL
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    Your notions of what is "real" are simply false...
    Let me put it this way, if every stock trader on earth died tommorow, society would be fine, we'd have some bumps and have to restructure a bit, but we'd be up and running in no time, if every plumber on earth died tommorow we would be in deep shit in a week.

    treating people right makes more money than screwing them out of nickles and dimes.
    Which is why the big banks are the big banks , the one financial institution I am for is credit unions personally.
  13. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to RGacky3 For This Useful Post:


  14. #30
    Join Date Sep 2005
    Posts 1,564
    Rep Power 25

    Default

    The first thing I'm doing is establishing a financial subsidiary (which will primarily operate a hedge fund) to provide investment services and retirement investment for everyone from institutional investors and millionaires to regular working class families. Then I'm opening the tech/software subsidiary to get the projects I've funded out-of-pocket for the last three years to the market quickly. I also hope I can, some day, launch my own bank and small loans services that doesn't fuck people through stupid policies wrapped in legalese bullshit. I have full confidence that the business plan will be a resounding success -- treating people right makes more money than screwing them out of nickles and dimes.
    You will have to screw people eventually, even if just a little, although if you want to be really successful it's going to have to be a lot. The need to accumulate capital is an all consuming need, until it gets to the point where you must accumulate capital in order to survive. Do I think capitalists are evil or greedy? No, they're just bowing down to the law of value.
    But now we must pick up every piece
    Of the life we used to love
    Just to keep ourselves
    At least enough to carry on
  15. #31
    Join Date Sep 2011
    Location Louisiana
    Posts 237
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    1. You were lucky to have stuff to sell in the first place.

    2. You were lucky enough to have those odd jobs offered to you.

    3. You were lucky that you had enough income that you could save $1000.

    You're not looking at the big picture. Some people work their asses off, go hungry, and only make $2 a day!
    1) I worked my ass off doing things like remodeling ratty mobile homes and working in warehouses to buy what very little I had. Then I realized I should sell it (for much less than I paid for it) to raise some startup funds. This is not luck, in any sense of the word.

    2) That's not luck... you're attributing everything to luck, which is absurd. You just don't want to admit people can succeed and that it's not a roll of the dice. Winning the lotto could be called "luck". There's no effort or skill involved other than just spending $1 on a ticket. Painting a picture is not luck... it takes dedication, persistence and much more. Being financially successful is just the same. As long as you continue to think this way you'll always be unhappy with your own material and financial situation.

    3) I really didn't have enough income. I went hungry and would forgo practically everything except what I needed to stay alive. I became severely malnourished and underweight as a result of it. But I survived, and that's what counts.

    Gacky:
    and lucky enough to be born in a country with protected capital markets.
    We've already talked about this Gacky... Yes, being born in a capitalist nation in the west, full of opportunity, was the only stroke of luck I ever had. I sincerely feel sympathy for people who are born in places which never embraced America's founding principles... people born into communist countries, for instance. And I dream of doing something to impact those peoples' lives in a positive way someday, other than just sending money to charities.
    I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it. - Thomas Jefferson
  16. The Following User Says Thank You to kapitalyst For This Useful Post:


  17. #32
    Join Date Sep 2011
    Location Louisiana
    Posts 237
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    Let me put it this way, if every stock trader on earth died tommorow, society would be fine, we'd have some bumps and have to restructure a bit, but we'd be up and running in no time, if every plumber on earth died tommorow we would be in deep shit in a week.
    If that's what you think... No, you'd be totally fucked when you woke up in the morning.

    Actually, if every socialist, communist, "progressive" and "revolutionary" died tomorrow we wouldn't even have any bumps or have to restructure. We would probably just have a big fiesta with balloons and everything!

    Which is why the big banks are the big banks , the one financial institution I am for is credit unions personally.
    Like the teacher's credit union that fucked over my mom and grandmother? Yeah, those guys are great... lol

    You will have to screw people eventually, even if just a little, although if you want to be really successful it's going to have to be a lot. The need to accumulate capital is an all consuming need, until it gets to the point where you must accumulate capital in order to survive. Do I think capitalists are evil or greedy? No, they're just bowing down to the law of value.
    That's not true, and I still wouldn't do it if it was. If I can only enjoy moderate success from treating people right, then so be it. But you're wrong...

    What will pose the biggest challenge to me, if I do indeed try to start a bank, will be the crony system, an anti-business regulatory environment, political obstacles and the nature of a fiat monetary system. But I'm not thinking those things are going to last much longer, and they can still be overcome.
    I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it. - Thomas Jefferson
  18. #33
    Join Date Sep 2011
    Location Arctic
    Posts 67
    Rep Power 7

    Default

    I agree with you kapitalyst, everybody that are rich have worked hard for it, and every poor man is lazy. All the african gold miners that work 16 hours every day for a dollar and a half are lazy.
  19. #34
    Join Date Sep 2005
    Posts 1,564
    Rep Power 25

    Default

    That's not true, and I still wouldn't do it if it was. If I can only enjoy moderate success from treating people right, then so be it. But you're wrong...

    What will pose the biggest challenge to me, if I do indeed try to start a bank, will be the crony system, an anti-business regulatory environment, political obstacles and the nature of a fiat monetary system. But I'm not thinking those things are going to last much longer, and they can still be overcome.
    You will be running a bank, not a charity, and sometimes that requires not being a nice guy. You must accumulate and expand your capital, otherwise you risk losing it all. More than likely if you do become successful you will rationalize away the people who fail to pay their loans or their mortgages as lazy or unwise, while paying into charity as a penance.

    But that's if you do become successful.
    But now we must pick up every piece
    Of the life we used to love
    Just to keep ourselves
    At least enough to carry on
  20. #35
    Join Date Apr 2002
    Location Northern Europe
    Posts 11,176
    Organisation
    NTL
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    We've already talked about this Gacky... Yes, being born in a capitalist nation in the west, full of opportunity, was the only stroke of luck I ever had. I sincerely feel sympathy for people who are born in places which never embraced America's founding principles... people born into communist countries, for instance. And I dream of doing something to impact those peoples' lives in a positive way someday, other than just sending money to charities.
    What you mean to say is you were born into a country that came out of WW2 untouched and thus had a huge market to build, and a country with a government that protects capital markets, and corporations, i.e. big daddy government making sure you capitalists can make a profit. And Also born into a country that extracted wealth for decades from third world countries who had no say on the matter. THATS what this is about.

    These rags to riches story have no place in a discussion about economics, its irrelivant, maybe its relevant to being an annoying douch at a dinner party, but its irrelivent to the bigger picture.
  21. The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to RGacky3 For This Useful Post:


  22. #36
    Join Date Apr 2002
    Location Northern Europe
    Posts 11,176
    Organisation
    NTL
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    Like the teacher's credit union that fucked over my mom and grandmother? Yeah, those guys are great... lol
    Because your mother and grandmother are the economy, get it straight, NO ONE GIVES A SHIT ABOUT YOUR PERSONAL STORIES, we are looking at the big picture, we are looking at economics here, not your family.

    If that's what you think... No, you'd be totally fucked when you woke up in the morning.
    Really? How, we'd be fine, society does'nt need traders, never have, they don't produce anything.

    Your not making any arguments here, your pointless.

    Actually, if every socialist, communist, "progressive" and "revolutionary" died tomorrow we wouldn't even have any bumps or have to restructure. We would probably just have a big fiesta with balloons and everything!
    Good argument.
  23. #37
    Join Date Sep 2011
    Location Louisiana
    Posts 237
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    I agree with you kapitalyst, everybody that are rich have worked hard for it, and every poor man is lazy. All the african gold miners that work 16 hours every day for a dollar and a half are lazy.
    Always must it be some example about Africa or another third world country where the people have suffered from dictators, disease, wars and the likes?... when that's not who/what we're talking about? Nobody is calling those people lazy. And they may be uneducated and ignorant, but they're not stupid.

    How many people here are actually doing anything to help them?
    La Comédie Noire:
    You will be running a bank, not a charity, and sometimes that requires not being a nice guy. You must accumulate and expand your capital, otherwise you risk losing it all. More than likely if you do become successful you will rationalize away the people who fail to pay their loans or their mortgages as lazy or unwise, while paying into charity as a penance.
    So if you borrow money from me and say "fuck that guy" and stop paying, we should just toss out the terms of the loan and you get off scott free? That doesn't make sense...

    When a loan is made from party A to party B, there are terms in place that each must uphold. It depends on what the agreement is. There's no need to rationalize anything beyond that.

    I'm not exactly going to give you a lecture on my business plan, but you seem to have misunderstood what I'm talking about. For starters, most poor people who are out there working hard have no credit options other than BS credit cards, pawn shops and payday loans. You ought to look up what the payday loan industry does to people (for a good laugh, look up "Western Sky Financial")... it's basically legal loan sharking. If you get a credit card, it's full of hidden fees and legal trickery, and most people don't even realize their interest rates are at the whim of the creditor. And pawn shops just aren't a good enough creditor, and require collateral. Furthermore, simply having a checking account is very expensive when you're operating on a slim budget -- been there, done that. They do everything they can (even if it means reordering transactions) to rack up overdraft fees. And those are typically $25 - $35! Yes, you overdraft by just $6 and you get charged $35. You then buy a pack of gum for 25-cents with your debit card, and you just bought the world's most expensive pack of Big Red. This is simply bullshit... One of the reasons I hate my own bank (Capital One) and deal almost strictly with my brokers (all of whom treat me wonderfully). Yes, the banking industry sucks and needs fresh competition to clean their clocks.

    Imagine a bank that offered simple and straightforward checking services... and instead of the overdraft fee scheme, a built-in line of credit at a low rate. Imagine small/payday loans at low, fixed rates that undercut all competition to a huge degree -- rates that don't fuck over the debtor and no fees. If you've ever struggled to run a checking account or desperately needed to borrow a couple hundred bucks, you'll know exactly what a godsend this would be for millions. And imagine a lender that approached larger loans in a very straightforward, transparent fashion unlike the rest of the industry, and offered superior rates and policies. It would be a mass exodus... and a harsh wake up call for the banking industry.
    But that's if you do become successful.

    I don't know for sure that I'll actually try to open a bank. But it's something I'd love to do. The industry has begun to stink something awful in recent decades... no surprise after being in bed with Uncle Sam for years and never having a bath. It's about time for a new kid to come on the block and school them. And it's about time there are some reasonable options out there for consumers, instead of just "would you like to be fucked fast or slow?" Of course, the government will probably hate this, and label it "predatory pricing" to protect their babies. So not sure what sort of obstructions the state will throw my way...
    I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it. - Thomas Jefferson
  24. The Following User Says Thank You to kapitalyst For This Useful Post:


  25. #38
    Join Date Sep 2011
    Location Louisiana
    Posts 237
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    Because your mother and grandmother are the economy, get it straight, NO ONE GIVES A SHIT ABOUT YOUR PERSONAL STORIES, we are looking at the big picture, we are looking at economics here, not your family.
    It's not some isolated incident, Mr. I-LIKE-TO-TYPE-IN-ALL-CAPS-TO-REPRESENT-YELLING...

    Really? How, we'd be fine, society does'nt need traders, never have, they don't produce anything.

    Your not making any arguments here, your pointless.



    Good argument.[/QUOTE]
    I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it. - Thomas Jefferson
  26. #39
    Join Date Nov 2007
    Location Home on the range
    Posts 2,941
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    These are averages (means), not medians.
    Thanks for the correction. The point is that you guys make it sound like the capitalist pays workers only what he has to pay and no more. Clearly he does not, not in the USA anyway. The reason he pays John Doe $17.50 or whatever instead of the $7.50 minimum or whatever is that he knows John Does might leave either to work for himself or for another company. That's not a very good example of slavery.

    Does the employer benefit from the arrangement? Sure. But he brings things to the table too: goodwill, business experience, and capital that he has accumulated from his own work or borrowed from family, friends or the bank.

    I actually think goodwill is the most important. It's an intangible, but some guys got it, and some don't.
  27. #40
    Join Date May 2011
    Location Netherlands
    Posts 4,478
    Rep Power 106

    Default

    IMO simply saying that "labor creates value, rich people got rich by stealing it" isn't the best way to argue against libertarians. Hit them where it hurts and illustrate how the wealthy and corporations in general have succeeded because of how interlocked they are with the state. Trust me, there's a TON of info available on this subject.
    Then they will argue "well, but I'm against corporatism, so you are not criticizing [free market] capitalism".

    Like you said, most wealth of the rich is inherited. In Robin Hahne's The ABCs of Political Economy I recalling reading it was almost or more than 80%. Even if we assume that the "self-made man" "earned" his wealth fairly, he is the exception to the rule.

Similar Threads

  1. Warren Buffet earned a $357 million profit on BofA
    By Dunk in forum News & Ongoing Struggles
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 1st September 2011, 04:26
  2. Hauling Cans and Bottles Through New York City for a Hard-Earned Extra Penny
    By Nothing Human Is Alien in forum News & Ongoing Struggles
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 27th July 2011, 13:42
  3. How would Communism persaude the rich to give up their wealth?
    By tradeunionsupporter in forum OI Learning
    Replies: 66
    Last Post: 28th April 2010, 05:06
  4. [anarkismo.net] Wisdom earned the hard way
    By RSS News in forum Newswire
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 6th April 2010, 15:10
  5. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 24th May 2008, 03:10

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

Tags for this Thread