Thread: The situation is getting dire

Results 21 to 40 of 63

  1. #21
    Join Date May 2006
    Location Glasgow
    Posts 5,200
    Rep Power 92

    Default

    I'll bite.

    Originally Posted by durhamleft
    Apparently it's democratic to turn up at people's private meetings and ram your views down their throats. tit.
    It was a public meeting. The example you put above if not about the EDL would be the definition of democratic.

    Originally Posted by durhamleft
    Also it's interesting there's 11 guests viewing this. All you EDL titheads.

    How about you fuck off back to your forum. If you want to debate something then sign up and message me but ogling at this isn't going to do much for you.

    If you restrict conversation to PMs then you'll have no bother.
    How about you start sending more PMs instead of constantly attention seeking for your super-secret grand plan of yet another so-called "militant anti-fascist" collective/organisation/group/batallion/lynchmob which "has to be done by PM guys!" yet you seemingly mention at every given opportunity?

    As far as i'm concerned, all you're doing is attracting yet more opposition forces to this site. I wish you wouldn't.
    Coalition of Resistance - Fight Back Against the Cuts!

    "As for the lad "Sam_b", I've been reading this forum for a while and I don't think I've ever seen him contribute anything of any value. Most of the chap's posts seem to be confrontational and snarky digs at other posters. Thankfully, most other contributors do not seem to behave in this manner." - Some Guy
  2. #22
    Join Date Mar 2010
    Posts 120
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    oh, wait wasn't it the SWP that tried to discredit "ANTIFASCIST ACTION"...oh yeah I think it was.
  3. #23
    Join Date May 2006
    Location Glasgow
    Posts 5,200
    Rep Power 92

    Default

    Originally Posted by LebenIstKrieg
    oh, wait wasn't it the SWP that tried to discredit "ANTIFASCIST ACTION"...oh yeah I think it was.
    Good.

    Whats your point? That is, if you do aside from the obvious point of the SWP disagreeing with the tactics of squadism.
    Coalition of Resistance - Fight Back Against the Cuts!

    "As for the lad "Sam_b", I've been reading this forum for a while and I don't think I've ever seen him contribute anything of any value. Most of the chap's posts seem to be confrontational and snarky digs at other posters. Thankfully, most other contributors do not seem to behave in this manner." - Some Guy
  4. #24
    Join Date Jan 2010
    Posts 255
    Rep Power 10

    Default

    Good.

    Whats your point? That is, if you do aside from the obvious point of the SWP disagreeing with the tactics of squadism.
    Although 'the squads' were started out of the SWP to some extent, but I guess the party didn't wanna indulge that sort of millitancy once it started getting bad publicity?

    Sorry thats an honest question, if you feel it went differently, give me your side?
    There's an inner thing in every man,
    Do you know this thing my friend?
    It has withstood the blows of a million years,
    And will do so to the end...

    ...It is 'the undauntable thought', my friend,
    That thought that says 'I'm right!
  5. #25
    Join Date Oct 2008
    Location The frozen peaks...
    Posts 2,113
    Organisation
    Orda Barbarica
    Rep Power 56

    Default

    oh, wait wasn't it the SWP that tried to discredit "ANTIFASCIST ACTION"...oh yeah I think it was.
    Good.

    Whats your point? That is, if you do aside from the obvious point of the SWP disagreeing with the tactics of squadism.

    Pffft, keep the nonsensical infighting to a minimum please. Whilst I strongly disagree with the SWP's positions and tactics that's not the matter at hand here.

    As far as the EDL is concerned, they're a joke, a bunch of casuals getting pissed waving the union jack and achieving fuck all. Eventually they'll get tired of what is essentially a game to most of these buffoons and the whole thing'll collapse. They have no means to consolidate any form of power and most certainly not anything radically different from or worse than capitalism as we know it.

    The core problem here is the failure of the radical left so far to build a successfull counter-power on a class-basis. Only an initiative grounded in class-politics is capable of opposing reactionary movements like the EDL or far right Islamists like Choudry cum suis.

    L'ANTIFASCISME C'EST BIEN, LA REVOLUTION C'EST MIEUX!!
    "Of Man's first disobedience, and the fruit
    Of that forbidden tree..."
    - John Milton -

    "The place of the worst barbarism is that modern forest that makes use of us, this forest of chimneys and bayonets, machines and weapons, of strange inanimate beasts that feed on human flesh"
    - Amadeo Bordiga
  6. The Following User Says Thank You to Ravachol For This Useful Post:


  7. #26
    Join Date May 2006
    Location Glasgow
    Posts 5,200
    Rep Power 92

    Default

    I think you ask a air question, NP.

    Originally Posted by No pasaran
    Although 'the squads' were started out of the SWP to some extent
    I agree.

    but I guess the party didn't wanna indulge that sort of millitancy once it started getting bad publicity?
    I don't think it was about 'bad publicity' in the slightest, we all know that the SWP doesn't get particularly good publicity anyway . For me, 'militant anti-fascism' is often construed as simply physical confrontation. When talking aout 'smashing fascism' we should be meaning to smash the political organs of fascism and defending communities, getting physical where necessary; not the way that AFA have in the past which I personally believe does not have an adequate class basis and tantamounts to alienation of the class (case in point is the screwdriver attacks on a BPP meeting which was reported on this site). I believe the situation got out of hand within the SWP, I think we made some mistakes; but also those who went on to Red Action also did. Strategy and tactic is not something rigid, uniform and absolute - situations change and we learn from our experiences.
    Coalition of Resistance - Fight Back Against the Cuts!

    "As for the lad "Sam_b", I've been reading this forum for a while and I don't think I've ever seen him contribute anything of any value. Most of the chap's posts seem to be confrontational and snarky digs at other posters. Thankfully, most other contributors do not seem to behave in this manner." - Some Guy
  8. The Following User Says Thank You to Sam_b For This Useful Post:


  9. #27
    Join Date May 2006
    Location Glasgow
    Posts 5,200
    Rep Power 92

    Default

    I did mean 'fair' question...some of you may have noticed I often have a problem with the 'f' key on my keyboard.
    Coalition of Resistance - Fight Back Against the Cuts!

    "As for the lad "Sam_b", I've been reading this forum for a while and I don't think I've ever seen him contribute anything of any value. Most of the chap's posts seem to be confrontational and snarky digs at other posters. Thankfully, most other contributors do not seem to behave in this manner." - Some Guy
  10. #28
    Blind faith will destroy us Committed User
    Join Date Feb 2009
    Location The Republic of Yorkshire
    Posts 1,471
    Organisation
    HAL - Huddersfield Anarchist League
    Rep Power 20

    Default

    You live and you learn. Main lesson to learn is not to do meetings that are likely to be targetted by potentially dangerous football hooligans and ultra-nationalists, unless you're confident about your abilities.

    We can sit here all day condemning and sniping at each other. Lets just let the Leeds lot learn from this and for everyone else to just heed it as a warning of what not to do. LIVE AND LEARN!
    ===========
    [FONT=Courier New][/FONT][FONT=Courier New] My blog[/FONT][FONT=Courier New] [/FONT]
    ===========

  11. #29
    Join Date Jul 2008
    Location UK
    Posts 1,214
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    You live and you learn. Main lesson to learn is not to do meetings that are likely to be targetted by potentially dangerous football hooligans and ultra-nationalists, unless you're confident about your abilities.

    We can sit here all day condemning and sniping at each other. Lets just let the Leeds lot learn from this and for everyone else to just heed it as a warning of what not to do. LIVE AND LEARN!
    Bullshit. You don't have to experience it before figuring out that the EDL are likely to gatecrash your meeting that is organising against them- especially when groups have had meetings targeted already. This meeting also spoke of militancy and the, now taken down statement from the Antifascist Coalition, said that the EDL with not 'be tolerated on the streets' anymore, wtf? So they will not be tolerated on the streets but they will be tolerated in a meeting that was supposed to be composed of people wanting to militantly combat them. Why weren't they even calmly ushered out, it's not like there was many- 20-4.

    The attendees where fucking lucky that the EDL didn't pop round mob handed and turned them over. How can people organise against people known to use violence if they do not even try to provide a safespace for a public meeting.

    It's also ridiculous why this is being repeatably wiped from Indymedia aswell.

    The real question that needs to be answered is what were the organisers thinking? I also wonder if any coppers were in attendance.
  12. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to nuisance For This Useful Post:


  13. #30
    Join Date Mar 2010
    Posts 4
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    agree with the above , letting the edl into a meeting supposedly to discuss how you're going to smash them is pathetic.......a victory aginst one of us is a victory against us all..The EDL are laughing there fat arses off about this ,sort your selves out Leeds AFED , you've made us look like right royal mugs
  14. #31
    Join Date Jan 2010
    Posts 255
    Rep Power 10

    Default

    Not to slate the well meaning Yorkshire 'commrades' (uggh I hate using that word... but I am using it out of respect here) but it does amazes me that security had not been better thought out? Maybe consult some people about stewarding for future meetings?
    Last edited by No pasarán; 6th July 2010 at 12:49.
    There's an inner thing in every man,
    Do you know this thing my friend?
    It has withstood the blows of a million years,
    And will do so to the end...

    ...It is 'the undauntable thought', my friend,
    That thought that says 'I'm right!
  15. #32
    Join Date Jun 2010
    Location Post-revolutionary Europe
    Posts 30
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    You may be getting me confused with someone else on the EDL forum, I didn't ask you to communicate by PM. I'll go into detail more about your post tomorrow (it's getting late for me). But do you understand Islam, have you read the Qur'an, do you realise that Islam is a total belief system, not a religion and do you see the problems in other European countries where the Muslim population is higher than it is here?
    We've heard it all before - neonazis going on about Judaism in much the same way as your group EDL now go about demonising Islam.
    Judaism is a total belief system. Christianity is a total belief system. So what if they are belief systems?

    Your group EDL advocates a proto-fascist street-response against all Muslims in Britain. That's one of the issues. We'll come to the others later.

    As for your Kahanist JDL USA friends whom EDL reached out to as early as September 2009, they are a proscribed terrorist group in both USA and Israel, so EDL's involvement with them leaves EDL wide open to just claims that EDL associates with a known terrorist group that has been proscribed in ISRAEL, rendering all EDL claims that EDL supports Israel invalid.

    EDL now supports some real hardline religious wingnuts who support a single-state, continuation of settlement building and this is contradiction to the recent motion at the Zionist Congress, who voted for a two-state solution and a full settlement-building freeze.

    SO much for being generally ZIONIST. The claim to be pro-Israel and pro-Zionist are false. The people you aligned with are against a two-state solution and pro-continued settlement expansion.

    EDL willingly sought out and linked itself to hardline religious right-wing extremists. The same type of extremists that EDL leaders say they're against.
    This renders the claim that EDL are against extremists invalid.

    Other important issues beside the issue of EDL cosying up to rightwing religious extremists and a proscribed terrorist organisation are the blatent lie that EDL is a single-issue organisation.

    It is most defnitely not a single-issue organisation, and we should discuss the EDL's claim to be a single-issue group as openly as possible, so that EDL members can read what we write.
    Last edited by Luther Blissett; 7th July 2010 at 14:51.
  16. #33
    Join Date Jun 2010
    Location Post-revolutionary Europe
    Posts 30
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    Here are Charles Martel or Charles the Hammer's and Snowy Nesbit's reports:
    Charles the Hammer
    Jul 3 2010, 07:01 PM Post #1
    britishulsteralliance .co .uk
    Posts:2,306Group:Senior MembersMember#3,653Joined:Oct 4, 2009

    Just back from challenging the 'Anti-fascist Action Coalition' meeting (already discussed on these forums)

    I would like to put a brief account (full account will be posted latter) of the EDLs actions of the days events across before the reds/anarchists do so but with their usual lies.

    Myself and 4 others including Snowy (agreed to me mentioning his name) went to the location of the meeting, pressed the buzzer on the door and let the caretaker of the building know we were there for the anti-EDL meeting (there was a hand written note on the door saying the meeting was there) we were let into the building and went upstairs to the meeting.

    We were expecting a group of black-bloc hardcore militant street fighting anarchists but was met with the usual UAF type mongs apart from one individual (more about him in the full report)

    Snowy started off by trying to blagg the cretins by saying we were anti-fascists from Wakefield, but it didn't take long for them to realises who we were due to our superior hygeine.

    Snowy then tried to educate the wasters about the errors of their ways but it soon became a reality that the brave class warriors were not up for a discussion as a big lad (we believe he was from Norway) decided to stand up and try to walk out. Snowy and myself talked him round by saying we were there for a democratic debate and not for violence, but he seemed to think we were there for violence as he was shaking like a leaf.

    It ended up with the reds/anarchists realising that we within the EDL will challenge them wherever they challenge us, anywhere, anytime and any place.

    Sorry the report is so short but I will go more into what was said during the spat latter as I have to go out very soon, just wanted to get the our side of the story across before the reds/anarchist come out with "EDL rapist, jew, cat and hampster killers threaten little bo peep with candy floss and machine guns" type sh1te.
    Charles the Hammer
    Jul 4 2010, 09:32 AM Post #95
    Posts:2,306Group:Senior MembersMember#3,653Joined:Oct 4, 2009

    We got to Leeds just before 1pm to a pub not far from the antis meeting place, within minuets there seemed to be police all over the place with CCTV vans etc, not to sure if they were looking for EDL or not.

    I think from now on pubs should not be used for meeting places as the OB know we always meet in pubs, but I'll leave talking tactics off a public forum. (Commies take note)

    We then went to the antis meeting place pressed the buzzer and blagged our way in, why the caretaker let us in so easily I do not know. If it was an EDL meeting we would have told the CT to inform us of any guests so we could down to check them out etc, the lefties are about as professional as the Italian army.

    All 5 of us went upstairs to the meeting and was met with the site of around 10 (maybe more) class warriors including a few girls, Snowy tried to blag that we were class warriors from Wakefield, but they knew who we were from the start. We then started to ask how they decided to stop us in Bradford, they didn't have much to say about that really so they started going on about how we should be protesting against the conservative goverment and their cuts, whilst failing to realise it was the Labour goverment who fcuked things up in the first place.

    It was at this point that a big fcuker we believe from Norway decided to stand up and try and walk out the room until Snowy and myself talked him out of it, he was shaking like a leaf and I mean shaking. We told him to sit down as nothing was going to happen, that class warrior decided he'd had enough of coming face to face with the real working class.

    It was at this point that one of our lads asked one of the class warriors (lad in black T-shirt) if he had a problem, but me and Snowy calmed the situation. The debate then went between Snowy and the alpha male of the class warriors group, this prick was about as working class as Boris Johnson but he did have the same accent as Boris, when we asked about his social background the old trot said he worked in the Sheffield steel industry and now works in the university sector.

    Snowy told Mr university that his dad was a shop steward who had brought him up to vote and support labour to which Snowy did until the first iraq war as Snowy believed it to be an illegal war, cue silence from the class warriors.

    Mr University then went on to say we have nazis and fascists amongst our ranks and we agreed we have a few, but Snowy also stated we are weeding them out and will continue to do so. (to the reds reading this We oppose all forms of extremism of any kind) I then said they have animal rights nutters who did people grannys up on their side and other lunatic extremists and so what are they going to do about them? Cue silence again.

    Snowy continued to educate the great unwashed class warriors about various things and some of them you could see were coming round to the fact we were not nazis etc, Snowy said to them stop believing the sh1te they read on the leftie websites about the EDL and start using their own brains for once.

    Just as we were about to leave the lad in the black T-shirt stood up and opend his bag and pulled out what we though was a black glove and put it in his pocket, so I stepped back and made sure the fire extinguisher I spotted earlier was still there as I though this Micheal Jackson impersonator might need putting out. I take my hat off to this cretin as he seemed the only one there who didn't seemed phased by any of us.

    We said our goodbyes and Snowy tried to shake Mr universitys hand, Mr university delined the offer. I then said 'see you in Bradford then' and gave them a really big cheesy grin in only the way I can.

    We left the building elvis style satisfied that we had got through to a few of the soap dodgers and I believe this is a result in itself.

    There was a lot more

    I'll ask Snowy to put his side across on here about his conversation with Mr university etc as he was our main speaker.

    NOW TO ALL THE REDS FROM REVLEFT ON HERE AND THE REST.

    We could have destroyed your meeting yesterday in a heartbeat, the lad in the black T-shirt seemed the only one who was 'up for it' but we didn't.

    There were girls present and student types and we have our morals, I doubt you have or would have done the the same.


    We will oppose you everywhere, any place and anytime and by any means necessary. You are nothing and always will be, you go on about 'controlling the streets' but you control nothing, we 'control the streets' and we do it without smashing up McDonallds.

    You're all weak and pathetic wasters who have no place in society.
    Originally Posted by Snowy
    Yesterday, 6:43 PM post #165
    Rooftop Legend & EDL Transport Organiser
    Posts:194Group:Senior MembersMember#3,857Joined:Oct 8, 2009

    You have to laugh at them, Charles and I may be close but not that close we are the same person.

    Working class lmao the guy chairing the meeting was only working class in his dreams tbh most of the lefties if not all of them looked like they came from a much better back ground then I ever did. Thats the problem in this country the liberial left thinking they represent the working class man, when they have no clue what we want or what our fears are. How do uni students understand the struggles of growing up with none or little money when daddy pays for everything, having hand me down clothes, mum butchering your hair cos she couldn't afford to take you barbers, Dad working all day, doing jobs on a night and a weekend just so he can provide for his family. No luxuries, no foreign holidays (except when I was in my teens when they both cashed in their life assurance to send us aboard to visit family), no fancy car etc he worked hard for us but we hardly ever saw him as kids and to this day we are still quite distant. Especially now a days cos he can't see what his so called working class party has done to this country and Mr University had the cheek to blame the current Tory government, how can they actually believe and say the state of the country is down to someone thats been in power about 2 months, when we all know who fcuk us and this country over big time.

    Charles have covered most of it very well but I will try to recall the full convo to the best of my knowledge.

    Snowy "hi we are antifascists from Wakefield and want to know how we are going to bash the Fascists?"

    Silence worried faces everywhere

    Snowy "Come on what were the success's at Newcastle, how do you intend to stop the EDL?"

    Mr Uni " Who are you again"

    I decide to take a seat as one of them got up to stand near the door
    Snowy "You know who we are, how do you intend to stop us?" (whoops force of habbit find it so hard to talk about EDL as third person)

    Silence

    Snowy "You know who we are, we are EDL and want to know how you intend to stop us?"

    Mr Uni "can you leave please"

    Snowy "no and shut up, you stated on your website that you want to militantly fight the EDL and we want to know how you intend to do that, militantly fight not debate so you are thinking of using violence, we could quite easily brought 50 lads today and just smashed you"

    Big norweign lad tries to leave to have a cig

    Snowy "where the fcuk you think you are going, no one leaves here you'll only phone ob" Charles blocks his path and tells him to stay put, he just stand there shaking don't know why as we have not at anytime threatened anyone

    I then picked up an labour leaflet about milliband

    Mr Uni "what you doing with that"

    Snowy "having a look thanks and how are you working class then"

    Mr Uni " I worked 20 years in steel industry (I put my house on it that it wasn't on the shop floor)"

    Snowy "what do you do now"

    Mr Uni "I work in the university sector"

    Snowy " that explains it all, I was brought up by a shop steward and taught that labour was a working class party voted for them in 97 and then Tony Blair lied to us and took us to an illegal war never voted for them since"

    Silence with the odd nod of aggrement

    Mr Uni "what about the loss of jobs and this Tory government
    Snowy "we are a single issue group and labour fcuked this country"

    Mr Uni "can you leave you are just a bunch of racists, Tommy has been outed as being a member of the BNP"

    Snowy "firstly if that is him it actually says former member, well I'm a former crackhead burglar but as you can see I ain't anymore"

    Mr Uni "can you leave please we are having a meeting, how would you like it if i came to one of yours"

    Charles "shut up sit down he's talking" lol

    Snowy " Not a problem we have one wednesday I'll pick you up at top of M606 and take you with me and you can speak to our lads as we believe in free speech thats why we've come for a debate"

    Mr Uni " Its ok just tell me where it is I'll make my own way"

    Snowy laughs "yes course you will more like phone ob to stop it"
    At this point I decided to ignore Mr Uni completely as it was like talking to a brick wall, so I just addressed the others

    Snowy "So you all want to over throw the government and make this country into a communist state"

    Various "we don't want that"

    Snowy "Of course not but some of the left do, I would be stupid to say you all do yet you all believe the propoganda that we are all racists, yes we have racists who attach themselves to us but we are weeding them out and will continue to do so. If you examine the BBC staff list you would find racists there the same with most big organisations. If it turned out EDL was a racist organisation then I and thousands of others would leave, not just because they trust me for what I have done but also cos its what they believe in, if you don't believe me go on to exposing racism on facebook and ask Darcy Jones if she thinks Snowy is a racist, one of my best mates in EDL has a mixed race partner and kids, the lad that has gone outside has a mixed race family so how can they be racist, I don't care what colour someone is, I just want to live in a free country. Please don't listen to the propoganda open you minds and see whats going on we have to stop the extremists no matter which side they are from, I have never been a football hooligan I'm just a working class lad that is worried about the future of this country I don't want to live under sharia law"

    Mr Uni "it will never happen"

    he was now irrelevant so I just ignore him

    Snowy "All I ask is you look at this with an open mind and not believe all the propoganda, have we been aggressive or attacked you in any way no, we could of easily just waited outside and attack you when you left but we only want to debate with you"

    Has I said at the start I have remembered this too the best of my knowledge, I may have the odd word wrong and missed bits out. Basically I chaired their meeting for a good 10/15 mins and those that know me once I start its hard to get a word in edge ways lol I will say some of them did have the decency to listen. I offered my hand to Mr Uni and Ten men but both declined, I also only took one photo while in there of Ten men as he seems the sort that will be trying to use violence against our supporters.

    I did also notice that one of our brothers had sat amongst them at the other side of the room and had been involved in a convo with them what was said I don't know but at no time did any of them seem threaten by his presence in fact they seem to listen to what we had to say which Mr Uni didn't like at all. For the record the most attractive female in the room was of mixed race hardly the thoughts of a nazi racist. We left as we arrived in a orderly fashion thanking them for they time.

    If that is the sum of people they can gather together as a coalition of antifascists we really don't have anything to worry about.

    For the lefties reading this no matter what you do we will always be a thorn in your side and I will do whatever is necessary to stop you brain washing the youth of this country and you my have the uni's of this country due to the fact you use fascist style methods ie only allowing one point of view put to the students but when they leave and have lived in the rat race then the majority will realise the lies they have been fed and drop you like a bad habbit. You are also going to see a shift in the future as the next generations leave school cos EDL is already spreading to the youth and they are our future not yours.

    Socialism is something most people grow out of EDL is for life, fighting a losing battle is pointless and we all know you will stand side by side with radical Islam rather then admit you are wrong well you have been warned if they get their way and introduce the Sharia into British law do you really think you will be treated better than the rest of us. Wake up before its too late they are the real fascists and tbh your point blank refusal to listen to anything but your propoganda makes you no different from the fascists you say you are against.
    Regards Snowy
    NO SURRENDER
  17. #34
    Blind faith will destroy us Committed User
    Join Date Feb 2009
    Location The Republic of Yorkshire
    Posts 1,471
    Organisation
    HAL - Huddersfield Anarchist League
    Rep Power 20

    Default

    Hmm. Well, credit where it's due I'm suppose. They do seem to have been trying to be diplomatic. Can't fault them on that.

    Seeing as though the focus of the meeting was militant anti-fascism, then making it public was very silly and this should never have happened. Fortuantly, these guys seem to be some of the nicer lot who, just like the rest of us, just want some pretty damn basic stuff like food, a home, medical care, education for thier kids and the like. As they quite rightly point out, if they'd wanted to have caused trouble, they could have easily and gotton away with it.

    That bieng said, I'm wondering whether there could have been an attempt to talk to these guys. I mean, after all, we're all after the same sort of thing - a comfortable life. The only difference really is in strategy. They think that they're going to get that stuff by attacking some imaginary terrorists, while we believe that workers united will get what we all want. Obviously, you can't have it both ways because attacking muslims divides the workers, which prevents unification.

    Then again, I'm sat here saying this and I wasn't there and I imagine that the AF guys were a bit shaken up for whatever reason. Maybe we should try diplomacy?
    ===========
    [FONT=Courier New][/FONT][FONT=Courier New] My blog[/FONT][FONT=Courier New] [/FONT]
    ===========

  18. #35
    Join Date Jul 2008
    Location UK
    Posts 1,214
    Rep Power 0

    Default

    Hmm. Well, credit where it's due I'm suppose. They do seem to have been trying to be diplomatic. Can't fault them on that.

    Seeing as though the focus of the meeting was militant anti-fascism, then making it public was very silly and this should never have happened. Fortuantly, these guys seem to be some of the nicer lot who, just like the rest of us, just want some pretty damn basic stuff like food, a home, medical care, education for thier kids and the like. As they quite rightly point out, if they'd wanted to have caused trouble, they could have easily and gotton away with it.

    That bieng said, I'm wondering whether there could have been an attempt to talk to these guys. I mean, after all, we're all after the same sort of thing - a comfortable life. The only difference really is in strategy. They think that they're going to get that stuff by attacking some imaginary terrorists, while we believe that workers united will get what we all want. Obviously, you can't have it both ways because attacking muslims divides the workers, which prevents unification.

    Then again, I'm sat here saying this and I wasn't there and I imagine that the AF guys were a bit shaken up for whatever reason. Maybe we should try diplomacy?
    Yeah, not letting people leave a venue sounds like a completely passive act.
    HAI, LETS TALK U GUYZ, NOW!
  19. #36
    Join Date Apr 2008
    Posts 690
    Rep Power 11

    Default

    basic idea:

    1. show up to there gigs and show them that they are not going to have free rule
    2. talk to community people (sympathetic mayors/Muslims/anyone) try to get the people of that community to understand the EDL are thugs and that a peaceful community wont let violent thugs into the area
    3. pass around fliers and anti-fa music samplers to anyone who might want one
    4. get those south african horns and drown them out with noise

    these are basic ideas that can be used in general and have been mentioned on this forum plenty of times, and none of them are violent which is a preferable in my opinion
  20. #37
    Join Date May 2009
    Location United Kingdom
    Posts 126
    Organisation
    Socialist Party
    Rep Power 10

    Default

    I'm confused.. they let them stay at the meeting and nothing resorted to violence?
    Still waiting on another EDL/WDL March in Wales, chasing 100 of them off into the distance and then they claim we're cowards?
    Retreat is not an option.
    http://justanotherantifa.wordpress.com/ - An anti-fascist, anti-government blog.
  21. #38
    Officially vetoed by the BA™ Committed User
    Join Date Oct 2005
    Posts 6,652
    Rep Power 66

    Default

    "The situation is getting dire" because a bunch of people attended a (publicly advertised?) meeting and its organisers did not know how to deal with it? Hmm...

    Stuff like this:

    Bullshit. You don't have to experience it before figuring out that the EDL are likely to gatecrash your meeting that is organising against them- especially when groups have had meetings targeted already. This meeting also spoke of militancy and the, now taken down statement from the Antifascist Coalition, said that the EDL with not 'be tolerated on the streets' anymore, wtf? So they will not be tolerated on the streets but they will be tolerated in a meeting that was supposed to be composed of people wanting to militantly combat them. Why weren't they even calmly ushered out, it's not like there was many- 20-4.

    The attendees where fucking lucky that the EDL didn't pop round mob handed and turned them over. How can people organise against people known to use violence if they do not even try to provide a safespace for a public meeting.

    It's also ridiculous why this is being repeatably wiped from Indymedia aswell.

    The real question that needs to be answered is what were the organisers thinking? I also wonder if any coppers were in attendance.
    Surely this is down to inexperience of some sort? From the outside, I get the impression that some folks are playing a game without understanding the stakes. They've seen some videos from Germany or Italy or whatever, and now they also want to be "Antifa hooligans" who are going to "smash the Nazis in the streets", with treehouse meetings to prepare it, posturing on the internet about who has the biggest penis, etc.

    This thread is a pretty funny example, with all the call-outs by durhamleft and stuff like that. Ooh look at me, I'm preparing a militant anti-fascist force, BUT please PM me because teh internets aren't safe!!! I'd say there's a lot of confusion and inexperience in general.

    EDIT: I see that in the "Similar Threads" list, there is a link to the "Dire Straits appreciation thread". It is completely off-topic, but kind of cool. Dire Straits can never be appreciated enough.
    Last edited by Wanted Man; 11th July 2010 at 09:23.
    What's the matter Lagerboy, afraid you might taste something?
  22. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Wanted Man For This Useful Post:


  23. #39
    Join Date Jan 2010
    Posts 255
    Rep Power 10

    Default

    I don't posture on the internet cos I don't need to. It's a great place for discusion but not for action. Plus a lot of people are very good at talkin up their millitancy but don't understand the reality of actually acting out on it.

    I recently had a mate tell me the best way to deal with the EDL was molotov cocktails... right... he also couldn't comprehend what the EDL are (they ARE NOT FASCISTS but loyalists/patriots/nationalists- still not a good thing, but not as bad as they could become). Admitably he was drunk at the time.

    While we should not compromise or back down to the EDL we should try and engage them in debate if given the chance, try and make them realise all the lies goverment proganda and the media has fed them. However if we are gonna have a public meeting to discuss them, it should be done with proper (experinced stewarding) and as a broad front (ie not just anarchists).
    There's an inner thing in every man,
    Do you know this thing my friend?
    It has withstood the blows of a million years,
    And will do so to the end...

    ...It is 'the undauntable thought', my friend,
    That thought that says 'I'm right!
  24. #40
    Join Date Mar 2009
    Posts 586
    Rep Power 12

    Default

    AF Leeds and their side of the story.

    Report on the Antifascist Coalition Meeting on the 3rd of July 2010

    On Sat the 3rd Leeds Anarchist Federation called a meeting for an Antifascist Coalition in Leeds with the intention of discussing the EDL and ideas for how to respond to their plans to march in Bradford in August. The people attending the meeting were aware of the EDL’s intention to attack the meeting but decided to go ahead with it anyway. Preparations were made for this possibility with the intention to try to de-escalate first, as a fight in the Swarthmore Center was in no way what we wanted, and we were prepared for other eventualities should a de-escalation fail. However, this predicted attack never materialised.
    What did happen was that 5 unknown people arrived. The door was locked and so they rang the buzzer and waited. They claimed to be antifascists wanting to go to the antifascist meeting. When they came in one of them told us they were antifascists from Wakefield and asked us what we were going to do about the EDL. Two of them stood nervously in the doorway and the others sat down, one of them went and sat quietly at the other end of the room from his friends. We asked why they wanted to confront the EDL and they said because some of them are racist. We tried to question them further about this but it seemed that the guy doing most of the talking didn’t feel he was doing a very convincing job. He said “You know who we are, don’t you?”, so we asked who and he said they were the EDL. At this point, a number of people in the meeting stood up and positioned themselves more conveniently, so this man started insisting they didn’t want a fight and they were just here to explain that they weren’t racist. He insisted repeatedly that he was just here to talk and made numerous defensive bids for acceptance (“don’t tar us all with the same brush”, etc). They seemed to be more concerned about PR than anything else but the brief exchange we had with him was predictably ridiculous and it wasn’t the time or the place to discuss what he wanted so we asked them to leave and after a few repetitions of “But just let me finish…”, they did.
    Despite being less of an attack and at most a mild inconvenience, it is in the interest of this man, called Snowy, to exaggerate this incident and his role in it as much as possible. Since the rooftop protests in Dudley he’s been trying to rise higher in the ranks of the EDL and is obviously hoping that he and his faction will gain more credibility if he makes it in and out of an antifascist meeting unscathed (no matter how this was accomplished). Snowy’s political ambitions are pretty transparent and his attempts to make his strange behaviour look impressive are equally transparent.
    The politics of the EDL feed into an agenda that poses a threat to the unity of the working class and has to be confronted. All over the world the bosses and politicians are using the recession to attack the working class using the nationalist rhetoric that “we’re all in this together”, while the EDL serve to focus concerns away from these attacks onto immigrants and foreign culture, simultaneously encouraging the white working class to identify with the white ruling class in an act of pseudo-rebellion that only serves to undermine their own interests. Although the EDL is not a fascist organisation, their presence on the streets of Bradford will only serve to strengthen the division of the working class according to tribalist principles of ethnicity and culture. Having said this, testosterone laden politics that responds with merely street violence fails to adequately address the situation. Our response has to be in accordance with our political aims.
    Anarchist Federation Leeds

    http://yorks-afed.org/2010/07/report...-of-july-2010/
    Excuse my spellign
  25. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Steve_j For This Useful Post:


Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 9th April 2010, 21:00
  2. Dire Straits appreciation thread
    By Led Zeppelin in forum Cultural
    Replies: 14
    Last Post: 30th January 2010, 00:06
  3. Stocks bomb as dire warnings shake markets
    By Led Zeppelin in forum Newswire
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 24th October 2008, 15:09
  4. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 14th April 2008, 08:23

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

Tags for this Thread