Rosa:
Refer to the other thread. That's my last response for now. 'Till we argue again...:D
Replies 506
Views 23,812
Rosa:
Refer to the other thread. That's my...Rosa:
Refer to the other thread. That's my last response for now. 'Till we argue again...:D
Replies 117
Views 6,784
Okay, I will make this response as brief and...Okay, I will make this response as brief and concise as possible since I have urgent things to attend and will have to cut my “vacation” short.
Rosa:
Replies 506
Views 23,812
Rosa:
I guess, my "vacation" for a few...Rosa:
I guess, my "vacation" for a few days will be both exciting and boring. Exciting because I will reunite with old friends :cool: and boring because I will have this childish arguments of...
Replies 117
Views 6,784
Rosa:
It is only you're insistence that...Rosa:
It is only you're insistence that Hegel agrees with Engels and Lenin on every point, which is not necessarily correct. Marx, Engels and Lenin did not agree with Hegel on every point.
...
Replies 117
Views 6,784
Rosa:
Hegel does not own dialectics....Rosa:
Hegel does not own dialectics. Whether the idea of "dialectics" came from him or not is not relevant. What is relevant is, if his idea is the same as the Dialectical Materialism espoused...
Replies 117
Views 6,784
Rosa:
Das Kapital is one example of...Rosa:
Das Kapital is one example of Dialectical Materialism applied to Historical Materialism. :)
Replies 3
Views 840
Stancel:
Sir, This is what I can only say,...Stancel:
Sir, This is what I can only say, and I'll quote it from the Communist Manifesto:
Replies 506
Views 23,812
Because I need something that is not interesting...Because I need something that is not interesting so that I don't get tired thinking. The revolution is quite hard. So I need to relax... :D
Replies 117
Views 6,784
Oh, there you go. A rather fast reply. :D
...Oh, there you go. A rather fast reply. :D
Hegel is not a materialist. His ideas are as absurd as yours. So I will not include him in my response, I will not even defend him. As for Plekhanov, he...
Replies 506
Views 23,812
Which is good... Since nothing is interesting...Which is good... Since nothing is interesting about your posts...
Replies 117
Views 6,784
Oh, really? :tt2:
Well, you're idea of...Oh, really? :tt2:
Well, you're idea of dialectical materialism is absurd, just as you're "philosophy" is absurd.
Just where exactly (and who said) that "and they also change into those...
Replies 506
Views 23,812
i'm back...:cool:i'm back...:cool:
Replies 0
Views 242
Further strengthen the Communist Party of the...Further strengthen the Communist Party of the Philippines to lead the people's democratic revolution
Central Committee
Communist Party of the Philippines
December 26, 2006
Introduction...
Replies 4
Views 463
I don't know what you mean by progressing, but in...I don't know what you mean by progressing, but in my view, the third world countries weren't progressing. In fact, they are more and more becoming tied to or being extended by the Imperialist...
Replies 24
Views 674
MLS
First of all, are you really a Chairman of...MLS
First of all, are you really a Chairman of a Communist Party? Just curious to know... Another thing, what is PAB? Pardon me for my ignorance on this matter.
Now on to your essay. I agree...
Replies 87
Views 3,233
angus_mor:
I'm not surprised to know that...angus_mor:
I'm not surprised to know that many don't like Rosa's attitude. It is quite natural to hate such an arrogant person.
As to my "immature reasoning", maybe it is immature, or...
Replies 87
Views 3,233
Rosa:
Well, it is evident that you don't...Rosa:
Well, it is evident that you don't want a debate. Even with your responses to other comrades suggest that you really don't want a debate. All you want is for the fellows to agree with...
Replies 87
Views 3,233
Rosa:
Fine. If you think it that way, I am...Rosa:
Fine. If you think it that way, I am not going to argue that. Not that I agree with you, but it seems you don't want to clarify your arguments to me. So I'll take what you said to the...
Replies 87
Views 3,233
Rosa:
Well, I don't care whose line of...Rosa:
Well, I don't care whose line of thought it came from. My point is the line of thought not the one who made it.
I wonder when do you make a good argument instead of just...
Replies 87
Views 3,233
When Karl Marx said, "my dialectics is not only...When Karl Marx said, "my dialectics is not only different from that of Hegel's. In fact, it is its direct opposite." he certainly means that dialectics, per se, is not metaphysical, not idealist....
Replies 506
Views 25,475
Rosa:
You didn't say this?
I asked you...Rosa:
You didn't say this?
I asked you to explain it.
Replies 506
Views 25,475
RedHerman:
If that is the case (just read...RedHerman:
If that is the case (just read her essay and accept her explanation without questioning) then we should as well stop discussing here and RevLeft shoud have made these discussion...
Replies 506
Views 25,475
Rosa:
That's it. Now you are explaining....Rosa:
That's it. Now you are explaining. That's good. :D
Well yes, the words "spirit" and "idea" are missing in your statement. So, what about? Besides those words, what are your other proofs...
Replies 18
Views 620
It's quite the same as the role played by the...It's quite the same as the role played by the middle class in history. They act according to their interests. The middle class, in general, will go where the tide is. If the revolutionary movement is...
Replies 506
Views 25,475
Rosa:
As you said, I made a comparison. Just...Rosa:
As you said, I made a comparison. Just that, a comparison. So here it is again:
I stated that they are almost the same. The words, as you had written them, were almost the same as that...