Executive decisions have to be done by a source of authority. If the people or person executing policies have no authority, there is no policy because people won't listen
"Lower level assembly"...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Executive decisions have to be done by a source...Executive decisions have to be done by a source of authority. If the people or person executing policies have no authority, there is no policy because people won't listen
"Lower level assembly"...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
We're not talking about 10,000 were talking about...We're not talking about 10,000 were talking about 7 billion people
Basically they coordinate activities that producers authorized them to coordinate, and by applying for a job and initially...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Think if you weren't dumber then a blithering...Think if you weren't dumber then a blithering idiot like myself, you would have been able to comprehend my point in relations to economics
Replies 538
Views 11,627
If they have no decision making power then what's...If they have no decision making power then what's the point of even appointing them in he first place? As soon as a council is created it shows people have a different role in the relation to means...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
They would be representing of all people. However...They would be representing of all people. However they would still be in a different class due to the fact that they are a "different means to production" according Marx definition of class.
This...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
But if it's managed that means it's not...But if it's managed that means it's not socialized production because not everyone plays a same role in production
Replies 538
Views 11,627
But then management would take on a different...But then management would take on a different role in the production process allocating for a division of labor
Replies 538
Views 11,627
I guess communists jest tend to enjoy...I guess communists jest tend to enjoy contradicting themselves
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Proving my point, the council is held at a higher...Proving my point, the council is held at a higher social standard over the actual production process which then creates a group of people effectively controlling the process of production which is...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Who does the planning?Who does the planning?
Replies 538
Views 11,627
I thought you were done posting on here?I thought you were done posting on here?
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Good question dodge, change subject tactic.
...Good question dodge, change subject tactic.
Does the good go from factory and get delivered to every persons doorstep yes or no
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Which is obviously evident, and i hold your...Which is obviously evident, and i hold your opinions above any other person in this forum, However
1) Economists planning the inherent value of labor time to consumption needs either does not...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
To each persons doorstep?To each persons doorstep?
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Well i'm glad a dog knows more about economic...Well i'm glad a dog knows more about economic theory then yourself, i guess I blame that one on capitalism
Replies 538
Views 11,627
But if it belongs to the disposer, and there's no...But if it belongs to the disposer, and there's no money then what makes him dispose it? If it belongs to the disposer then it divides labor because his role in the production process is different...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
HAHAHAHA im actually happy you came back into the...HAHAHAHA im actually happy you came back into the conversation because you make me laugh
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Yes, its already socialized in capitalism because...Yes, its already socialized in capitalism because it directly results of the society's willingness to obtain the product that is to be disposed, but im talking about in a communist society how do you...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
"The role of communist militants is not to make..."The role of communist militants is not to make pre-defined plans for how a future society is administered. Our role is to organise against capitalism. Establishing a communist society is the role of...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
So then if you don't remove direct ownership of...So then if you don't remove direct ownership of goods how do you socialize the disposal process of goods, which is a huge important part of the production process
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Im here to address my own concerns on why...Im here to address my own concerns on why socialism is a more efficient practice then capitalism. If you cant explain it to me efficiently then you should just not respond
Replies 538
Views 11,627
Its addressed as "well figure it out when the...Its addressed as "well figure it out when the problem arrives"
This is a form of new political and economic thought, this is suppose to replace the system we have and your solution is its not your...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
You have not given me one thorough response to...You have not given me one thorough response to how we can possibly socialize government and socialize production at the same time, the answers you give are not proving any form of sense. What so...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
But the people in that new thread will only look...But the people in that new thread will only look at it with an already predisposed belief to not questioning Marxism, hence people might propose suggestions to the governing plan but people wont...
Replies 538
Views 11,627
What would be even better is if someone who...What would be even better is if someone who believes full heartedly in a giant revolution killing millions of people could understand fully what they are fighting for.
The problem with Marxism is...