Tab Content
All
Ismail
Friends
Photos
No Recent Activity

581

  1. View Conversation
    Comrade I'd really like to know where you're getting the idea that when the Soviet Union invaded Poland, the Polish state has already collapsed. Every trustworthy source in Russian and English I've read claims the contrary. From what I understand this myth originates from Molotov's statement in 1939, where he also claimed that the war with the Germans was began by the Polish government....

    I'm also confused as to how 200,000-400,000 Polish prisoners of war got themselves caught by the Red Army...if there was no Polish State that they served, did they just accidentally wander off into Soviet internment? Did someone fail to inform them of the non-existence of Poland?
  2. View Conversation
    Comrade, I once read(from, I believe, the Great Soviet Encyclopedia) that Gulag inmates were paid. Is that true?
  3. Omsk
    View Conversation
    Hello comrade!

    All the best.
  4. View Conversation
    Sorry.

    It's more that i'm just not that interested in individuals; 'marxist' analyses based on the simplistic ideas of whether one person is 'more right-wing' than another don't really get us anywhere.

    Moreover, the very notion of right and left is:

    a) contested - many Socialists don't even identify as 'left', since as we all know, the left-right scale is a bourgeois construct from France, and
    b) highly subjective. To me, Marxism-Leninism is on the right-wing of the Socialist ideologies, since it has proved to be highly transitional and doesn't generally call for the immediate abolition of money or the state. You'll dis-agree (just to pre-empt, i'm not really interested in that discussion!), which will just prove the point that it's impossible to assert objective truth here

    There is also the issue that peoples' political views are fluid. It is often difficult to call people 'left' or 'right', since in different periods, peoples' views change, for many reasons.
  5. View Conversation
    Comrade, you haven't been on Soviet-Empire in a while, although you've never quite been an active user. I request you make more appearances, if given the time.

    Do you know where I can find Svetlana Alliluyeva's autobiography online?
  6. Ismail
    "Neglect of mod duties."
  7. Hey, how come you're not a mod anymore?
  8. Volcanicity
    View Conversation
    Is the book "Family in the People's Republic of Albania" available online anywhere?

    Sorry but I can't remember who it's by.
  9. View Conversation
    I was reading a book about Albania today. It brought up the Corfu incident between Albania and GB, but it didn't go into detail. Could you explain what happened and how Hoxha handled it?
  10. Comrade #138672
    View Conversation
    So even though they were going in the right direction, they had still some problems to face that weren't related to communism. To a Stalinist those executions were necessary to suppress the bourgeoisie, it seems.
Showing Visitor Messages 211 to 220 of 581
... 12202122232432 ...

About Ismail

Basic Information

Interests
Modern history
Gender
Male
Gender
Male

* h0m0revolutionary: "neo-liberalism can deliver healthy children, it can educate them, it can feed them, it can clothe them and leave them fully contented."
* rooster: "Supporting [anti-imperialism] is reactionary. How is any nation supposed to stand up [to] the might of the US anyway?"
* nizan: "Fuck your education is empowerment bullshit, education is alienation, nothing more. You indulge in a dying prestige for a role in a bureaucratic spectacle deserving of nothing beyond contempt."
* Alexios: "To the Board Administration: Ismail [...] needs to be eliminated from this forum."

Statistics

Total Posts
Total Posts
4,669
Posts Per Day
0.75
Total Messages
581
Most Recent Message
5th September 2016 16:45
235
General Information
12th June 2018 07:37
14th May 2007
Referrals
13
Home Page
http://eregime.org/index.php

10 Friends

  1. David Warner

    David Warner

    Dialectical Materialist

  2. Grenzer

    Grenzer

    Senior Revolutionary

  3. Laika

    Laika

    Junior Revolutionary

  4. MethodMania

    MethodMania

    Junior Revolutionary

  5. milk

    milk

    is good for you

  6. Prairie Fire

    Prairie Fire

    I'm back, baby.

  7. Preussen

    Preussen

    Junior Revolutionary

  8. Red Commissar

    Red Commissar

    Senior Revolutionary

  9. Robespierre Richard

    Robespierre Richard

    Always Hardline.

  10. Wonton Carter

    Wonton Carter

    Leninist

Showing Friends 1 to 10 of 10