Tab Content
All
Ismail
Friends
Photos
No Recent Activity

581

  1. View Conversation
    I've really read only a few dozen pages of Hoxha available on the internet, though the text you linked me to is pretty interesting. My impression of him seems to be that he was a pretty clever guy whose mind was hijacked by Stalinist garbage.

    Anyways, this Grenzer character has put me on his ignore list and is claiming on your profile that I said something about a "vast anarchist conspiracy that killed "hundreds of Bolsheviks" before the October Revolution"...which is a complete falsehood, I'm not a crackpot. He has spread this fabrication against me in other places also. I don't know the origin of it but perhaps he has misunderstood me when I mentioned the assassination campaigns of SRs and Anarchists aimed at Bolsheviks that took place after the Bolshevik Revolution and radicalized the Bolsheviks, contributing to the "Red Terror" and the enlargement of the Cheka...perhaps you could mention this to him as I don't like being falsely accused of stuff like that.
  2. View Conversation
    The fight of the National Liberatio an Movement, lead by Enver Hoxha, against German and Italian fascists was indeed heroic and noble fight. Especially since the Albanians liberated their country without any help from the Red Army and hardly any help from the Yugoslavs. A fight against fascist dogs is always a good fight. Tito too lead anti-fascist partisans, and I know you Hoxhaists don't like Tito very much(neither do I, but for different reasons). I consider myself a Communist, so do you...I think that justifying one-man dictatorships on the basis of leading struggles against fascism is beneath us. If the Dictatorship of the Proletariat is just another name for the Dictatorship of the Party elite, then what the hell are we doing calling ourselves Communists?

    To be continued:
  3. View Conversation
    He was a Stalinist apologist that wrote volumes about how great Stalin was. I don't know about you, but I think people that defend genocidal maniacs and mass-murderers like Hitler, Stalin, Pol Pot, Mao, Milosevic, Amin, Suharto, Bush and others, are either ignorant, idiots, psychopaths or insane...Hoxha was a pretty bright fellow so I guess he was either ignorant or insane. You pick. But again, not as bad as other Stalinist rulers

    Bokassa, by the way, ruled as Emperor for about 3 years(and barely more than a decade as head of state in general). Enver Hoxha ruled as King for over 40.
  4. View Conversation
    I know all about the beards thing, but I have never heard of the banana ban and since Hoxha was a insane I assumed it's true. Good to know he at least didn't ban bananas.
  5. NorwegianCommunist
    View Conversation
    Thank you so much for that PDF file you sent me about Albania!
    There are still many things I wonder about as I read, maybe I put them here and you can answar them if you want to or have the time =)
  6. Grenzer
    View Conversation
    That was a good read. There is a lot there that is agreeable whether one is a Marxist-Leninist or not. Most Trotskyist and Anarchist(the anarcho-syndicalists) organizations have an incorrect position on unions. Hoxha's observation on the nature of officers and the comparison to union bosses was astute. His charge that "Like the bourgeoisie, the "leftists" see the army as an "impregnable fortress" and never even raise the task of disintegrating, demoralizing, and destroying it." is very true. Most self described revolutionary organizations have a very defeatist view in this regard. In addition, his insistence that a revolutionary organization must make full use of both legal and illegal methods is something I agree with a lot, and that most organizations today refuse to do.
  7. Grenzer
    View Conversation
    Isn't the IMT supported by Trotsky's grandson or something? I haven't read that chapter, but I will do so right now. Shouldn't take too long to get done.
  8. Grenzer
    View Conversation
    The people who make the argument that Hoxha was insane are no different from the people who make the claim that the objective of Soviet collectivization was genocide.. complete opportunists.
  9. Grenzer
    View Conversation
    I had assumed that the rationale behind the banning of beards had something to do with Islam, in which case it's not really that illogical(though I wouldn't personally endorse such a move). The banana thing confused me.

    I put Borz on my ignore list after his claim of a vast anarchist conspiracy that killed "hundreds of Bolsheviks" before the October Revolution even occurred. His hysterical claims and outright fabrications aren't worth the time I would spend dealing with them. Interestingly enough, there does seem to be at least one Menshevik on this board in it's classical context. The user TrotskistMarx has argued that the material basis for socialism does not yet exist and that those who refuse to unconditionally support Hugo Chavez and Cristina Kirchner are ultra-leftists.
  10. Grenzer
    View Conversation
    I just took a look over at the Kasama Project website, and it's sickening.

    Although their rhetoric is much milder, they seem to be in essence no different than the ultra nationalist opportunists that make up the "Maoist-Third-Worldist" "movement." The impression I get is that they are completely divorced from Leninism in everything but rhetoric, and are much closer to fascism than anything else.
Showing Visitor Messages 421 to 430 of 581
... 33414243444553 ...

About Ismail

Basic Information

Interests
Modern history
Gender
Male
Gender
Male

* h0m0revolutionary: "neo-liberalism can deliver healthy children, it can educate them, it can feed them, it can clothe them and leave them fully contented."
* rooster: "Supporting [anti-imperialism] is reactionary. How is any nation supposed to stand up [to] the might of the US anyway?"
* nizan: "Fuck your education is empowerment bullshit, education is alienation, nothing more. You indulge in a dying prestige for a role in a bureaucratic spectacle deserving of nothing beyond contempt."
* Alexios: "To the Board Administration: Ismail [...] needs to be eliminated from this forum."

Statistics

Total Posts
Total Posts
4,669
Posts Per Day
0.75
Total Messages
581
Most Recent Message
5th September 2016 16:45
235
General Information
12th June 2018 07:37
14th May 2007
Referrals
13
Home Page
http://eregime.org/index.php

10 Friends

  1. David Warner

    David Warner

    Dialectical Materialist

  2. Grenzer

    Grenzer

    Senior Revolutionary

  3. Laika

    Laika

    Junior Revolutionary

  4. MethodMania

    MethodMania

    Junior Revolutionary

  5. milk

    milk

    is good for you

  6. Prairie Fire

    Prairie Fire

    I'm back, baby.

  7. Preussen

    Preussen

    Junior Revolutionary

  8. Red Commissar

    Red Commissar

    Senior Revolutionary

  9. Robespierre Richard

    Robespierre Richard

    Always Hardline.

  10. Wonton Carter

    Wonton Carter

    Leninist

Showing Friends 1 to 10 of 10