No Recent Activity

42

  1. View Conversation
    http://www.revleft.com/vb/workers-co...12#post1918312

    Go back and edit this, paragraph breaks please, or no rep points for you
  2. ComradeMan
    View Conversation
    If you make an accusation you should be able to back it up? Why won't you? Or is it perhaps that you can't? Now, please enlighten me as to why you felt justified in flaming my profile and accusing me of being a Zionist dipshit?
  3. ComradeMan
    View Conversation
    Report for me what? You post inflammatory comments on profiles and refuse to explain why? You have nothing to corroborate your accusations and then you cry victim?
  4. ComradeMan
    View Conversation
    Which posts--- could you indicate which posts advocate Zionism?
  5. ComradeMan
    View Conversation
    Why did you call me a Zionist dipshit without any provocation on my profile? I am still waiting for an answer from you.
  6. View Conversation
    Sorry, I didn't know it was a secret.
  7. Ele'ill
    View Conversation
    What's with your posts on Barry Lyndons visitor message section?

    Why did Barry Lyndon request a self-ban around the same time?
  8. View Conversation
    I'm a little surprised to see you posting in my guest-book even though you know that you're in my ignore-list. It is strange that you seek attention so badly, Bob. I don't debate much on China etc. But when anyone talks shit about South Asia, I bash him until he either stops or shamelessly starts dodging questions, just like you. I am reading your post and answering you this one last time, if you continue to spam my guestbook anymore, I will report you.
  9. View Conversation
    I guess Trotsky himself was a 'Stalinist' by your ridiculous definition then lol. I am neither a Trotskyist nor a Stalinist, I instead study and respect that contributions of all the major revolutionary traditions. You, by contrast, believe that the only way that the working class can be liberated is by engaging in a literal re-enactment of the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution, and writing long pompous polemics explaining why.
    Enjoy your irrelevancy and sectarianism.
  10. penguinfoot
    Prove that the revolution was carried out by the working class (whether alone or in alliance with some other class force) in any meaningful sense. Prove how the revolution was led by the peasantry when the struggles of the poor peasants were restrained by the CPC leadership (as detailed in my post in the thread, which you haven't responded to) and show how the idea of a revolution being led by the peasantry can be reconciled with Trotsky's detailed analysis of why the peasantry cannot be an independent political actor - that is, his claim that "historical experience shows that the peasantry are absolutely incapable of taking up an independent political role".
Showing Visitor Messages 11 to 20 of 42
1234 ...

About penguinfoot

Basic Information

Don’t be sad when the sun goes down
You’ll wake up and i'm not around
I’ve got to go oh oh oh
We’ll still have the summer after all

"...this revolution is necessary, therefore, not only because the ruling class cannot be overthrown in any other way, but also because the class overthrowing it can only in a revolution succeed in ridding itself of all the muck of ages and become fitted to found society anew" - The German Ideology

Statistics

Total Posts
Total Posts
244
Posts Per Day
0.05
Total Messages
42
Most Recent Message
24th May 2012 17:08
18
General Information
11th September 2010
Referrals
0

5 Friends

  1. Crux

    Crux

    Let the dead bury the dead.

  2. Muzk

    Muzk

    Banned

  3. Queercommie Girl

    Queercommie Girl

    proletarian anti-imperialist

  4. Rakhmetov

    Rakhmetov

    Banned

  5. RED DAVE

    RED DAVE

    Banned

Showing Friends 1 to 5 of 5