Brosa Luxemburg

"You think a belief in international revolution is a belief that revolution must happen in every country all at the same time"

Well, since the revolution in the USSR failed because it was not international, I would say my definition is more or less correct, if it had spread to another country, would things have been diferent?
And, if it had gone international 5 years after the revulution in Russia, wouldn't the revolution in Russia have stagnated by that point.

"You claim that Putin is a fascist here"

I was using fascist as an insult, what I posted there is not to be taken seriously.

"You lack a basic understanding of terms such as "dictatorship of the proletariat""

I know authoritarian socialists want to use a state to do it.

"lacked a basic understanding of anarchist and leftist history as can be shown in the Authoritarian Socialism thread where, despite the fact every single point you made was completely destroyed and demolished, you also failed to realize that the anarchists in the Ukraine had their own secret police and ran society based on basically military dictatorship lines."

Your proof was speculation, some socialists claim Makhno had 2 secret police forces: the Kontrrazvedka, and ..., strange, they never seem to be able to say the name of the other one.
These are baseless accusations, if you want to discuss this I will open a thread for it.

continues above

"a dog and an alligator are essentially the same because they are both carnivorous animals."

See, you admit there are similarities, however small.

"the comparison of the suppression of the bourgeoisie by a revolutionary society (not necessarily a state) to the Nazi suppression of the Jews was not a good analogy"

OK.

"You have constantly stated that you believe anarchism is not socialist."

No, I have stated it is not a tendency of socialism, since it does not originate from socialism.

"You claim that anarcho-capitalists are genuine anarchists and apart of the anarchist tradition."

I have noticed that most anarchists (including myself) have been trying to convince everyone that anarchism=anarcho communism, but there are more thories of anarchism besides anarcho-communism and anarcho-syndicalism.
I say anarcho-capitalism is a part of anarchist tradition because it originates from anarchist ideals, although it is completely diferent from the other theories of anarchism.

I would label myself as simply a marxist for the time being.

I am not a trotskyist per say, but am interested in some of his ideas. I have self-styled as an anarchist for a long time but my politics have slowly been in transition for quite some time. Frankly I don't know where to label myself on the political spectrum, I don't fit neatly into any tendency. I however have felt myself shifting away from anarchism for a while, although it will always have a place in my political development. I have alot of reading to do, to say the least.

"I wouldn't even bother arguing with him."

Indeed. If you expect me to admit I am wrong in an argument you have got to make a really great point.

"Seriously, left communism is "fascism"?"

No, explained bellow.

"They also claimed that suppressing the bourgeoisie was comparable to the Nazis suppressing the Jews..."

"We", came up with that comparisson because it was a good one to present at the time, to justify that the use of state for opression is a bad thing you need the best example of how it can also opress other minorities (and majorities)

"faulty knowledge of leftist thought"

Please provide 5 examples of my faulty knowledge of leftist thought, note that I never said Left-communism was fascist, you missinterpreted what I meant.

What I said was that if you don't use the terms authoritarian/libertarian it must mean you have a problem with them, so I concluded that maybe the problem is, if you thought you were authoritarian, you would end up having something in common with the fascists.

Never once did I call you a fascist, I did call you authoritarian.