Introducing myself...

  1. Grunt
    Grunt
    Hi - I just became a member of this group.

    Why? Because I am a hardcore materialist and
    an analytical positivist in the tradition of
    the great Bertrand Russell.

    Most of the comrades (here on RevLeft as well
    as IRL) take dialectics as granted, part of the
    package, so to speak...

    I strongly suspect that very few of them ever
    read Hegel. Their 'knowledge' comes from secondary
    sources, among them so distinguished people like
    Engels, Lenin, Trotsky...

    I never understood in the first place how it is
    possible to merge materialism with an utterly
    idealistic philosophy.
  2. Rosa Lichtenstein
    Rosa Lichtenstein
    Hi, Grunt! And welcome!

    In fact, it is probably the case that a minority of comrades here at RevLeft are dialecticians -- certainly few of the anarchists are, and they form a large proportion of the membership. The dialectics group, for instance, has less than 30 members!

    That group was set up because the dialecticians were sick of having their asses kicked by us anti-mystics in the Philosophy section (and elsewhere), so they limped off into their safe little cabal to intone prayers at one another. The anti-dialectics group was founded in order to counter some of the things they said -- since we are not allowed to join their esoteric coven.

    However, they have done little other than discuss what they are going to discuss, so there has been precious little for us to comment upon!

    By the way, what is IRL?

    If there are dialecticians there, I need to nip over and give them a hard time.
  3. Grunt
    Grunt
    Hi, Grunt! And welcome!
    Thanks!

    In fact, it is probably the case that a minority of comrades here at RevLeft are dialecticians -- certainly few of the anarchists are, and they form a large proportion of the membership.
    As to the anarchists: I am 100% sure you are right.
    As to the rest: Well they all seem to talk the lingo - so I
    must assume they are.

    The dialectics group, for instance, has less than 30 members!
    Because it's so obvious to them and an integral part of
    Marxism/Leninism - they don't feel the need to gather in
    a faction - since they are accepted as 'real' Marxist-Leninists...

    ...since we are not allowed to join their esoteric coven.
    ...and I wouldn't want to either. Not for all the tea in china.

    By the way, what is IRL?
    IRL= In Real Life

    If there are dialecticians there, I need to nip over and give them a hard
    time.
    Yes they claim to be (in our party that is) - yet the vast majority
    has even read less than I have...(go figure...)
  4. Rosa Lichtenstein
    Rosa Lichtenstein
    So, do you have a link for IRL?
  5. Grunt
    Grunt
    So, do you have a link for IRL?
    Of course. (sorry for the late reply...):

    http://www.socialistiskapartiet.se/

  6. Rosa Lichtenstein
    Rosa Lichtenstein
    Thanks, but as it is in Swedish (am I right?), I can't contribute.
  7. Grunt
    Grunt
    Thanks, but as it is in Swedish (am I right?), I can't contribute.
    Yeah - sorry! I don't believe we will have an english
    version of our site in the near future.

    Anyway: The Headline/Logo says:

    The Socialist Party. The Swedish part of the 4th International.
  8. Rosa Lichtenstein
    Rosa Lichtenstein
    Ok. Thanks!
  9. Black Sheep
    Hi, ok i joined- though i am not an anti-dialectician, because frankly i do not know enough about DM.
    But since criticism is crucial to testing your knowledge and the info you recieve, here i am.