and i agree with you to have total newbs go full contact is stupid but after a a few months at the very most they should be sparring. their is a reason why BJJ, Judo, Boxing, Kyokushin, Muay Thai are vastly more proficient in combat than say Shotokan, Tai Chi, Various Gung Fu. it is because they start their students training with resisting opponents they may also do compliant drills to learn motions but they test them out in sparring regularly so they know they work when the the other guy is trying to choke throw or smash you...