Charles is banned ....

  1. 4 Leaf Clover - 29th October 2010, 10:06
    Charles Xavier is banned for supposed trolling (mind you in chit-chat section) , but i couldn't see it being a lesser trolling then all other topics in chit-chat. should we do sth like appeal for him to be unbanned or sth
  2. F9
    F9 - 30th October 2010, 17:48
    what you should do is decide who is gonna be the new group "leader".One member stated interest, i have no problem transfering it to him, but it would be more fair to listen from the group in general, cause im sure there are more than one person interest in this.

    ps: pm me with your decision btw, cause i hardly have time reading the forum, not the groups who are hard to found...
  3. 4 Leaf Clover - 30th October 2010, 21:14
    well i think you should consider unbanning charles , and give him infraction instead which is a fair penalty for trolling in chit-chat which is a laid-back discussion forum anyway

    however , i guess vegan-marxist and deconditioned reflex +1 are two marxist-leninists with most influence on forum for this position
  4. Comrade_Stalin
    Comrade_Stalin - 31st October 2010, 15:51
    Charles Xavier is banned for supposed trolling (mind you in chit-chat section) , but i couldn't see it being a lesser trolling then all other topics in chit-chat. should we do sth like appeal for him to be unbanned or sth
    [FONT=Verdana]Sound like they banned him more on the grounds that he was a M-L then for trolling. Hell I may be banned today for no reason at all. He is not the first M-L to be banned on very little grounds. I think that we should all move to the new site he builds for us. [/FONT]

    [FONT=Verdana]http://communist.11.forumer.com/inde...3d013d0557d453[/FONT]

    [FONT=Verdana]There is no one on it right now, but if we all work on it, I think it will be better then revleft.[/FONT]
  5. Marxach-Léinínach
    Marxach-Léinínach - 31st October 2010, 20:13
    Maybe all us anti-revisionists should just all go there. The main forums on this site annoy the piss outta me. Totally infested with closeted anti-communists.
  6. 4 Leaf Clover - 31st October 2010, 22:00
    well let's exclude emotionality. no internet website is worth much trouble , neither is revleft.

    i complain about his unfair ban , and i still think we should ask him be unbanned

    if we want to build and move on new website , we must do it for purpose and with goal.
  7. Nolan - 1st November 2010, 02:52
    Why don't we use this group forum more? I'll be happy to take it if that's ok with everyone.
  8. 4 Leaf Clover - 1st November 2010, 13:33
    it all same , it's not like it matters
  9. Comrade_Stalin
    Comrade_Stalin - 2nd November 2010, 01:30
    Why don't we use this group forum more? I'll be happy to take it if that's ok with everyone.
    I allready asked this question in my post called" Why do we not use this forum more? " ,which you call a group.

    Ok, tell us what we have to do to unbanned Charles? If we can't ,I think that it is time to move to a new fourm. As Marxach-LéinÃ*nach point out,

    Maybe all us anti-revisionists should just all go there. The main forums on this site annoy the piss outta me. Totally infested with closeted anti-communists.
    This is the reason why nothing on here gets done.
  10. Weezer
    Weezer - 2nd November 2010, 05:18
    Maybe all us anti-revisionists should just all go there. The main forums on this site annoy the piss outta me. Totally infested with closeted anti-communists.
  11. Communist
    Communist - 2nd November 2010, 18:18
    infested with closeted anti-communists.
    Yes, and some Marxist-Leninists (lol) who support Obama...
  12. Comrade_Stalin
    Comrade_Stalin - 3rd November 2010, 04:02
    Maybe all us anti-revisionists should just all go there. The main forums on this site annoy the piss outta me. Totally infested with closeted anti-communists.
    The make up the majority of this site.
  13. Lyev
    Lyev - 3rd November 2010, 20:15
    Comrades. Do you want me to take up the leadership role of this group now? I am devoted
  14. Nolan - 3rd November 2010, 22:03
    Comrades. Do you want me to take up the leadership role of this group now? I am devoted
    gtfo cat
  15. Comrade_Stalin
    Comrade_Stalin - 4th November 2010, 01:17
    Well we need this problem to be fixed soon.
  16. Bright Banana Beard
    Bright Banana Beard - 4th November 2010, 06:03
    I am willing to take leadership of this group. Aye or Nay?
  17. Communist
    Communist - 4th November 2010, 18:54
    We should get names of those who want to mod this group, and create a poll. That's really the best way to do this. If anyone who wants to lead this group has any current infractions (not given by me or anyone else in this group) then they should be nominated by another group member and be seconded. Why have any embarrassments lead this important tendency group?
    But of course these are just my suggestions.
  18. 4 Leaf Clover - 5th November 2010, 22:21
    i have an infraction for spamm comment on a topic. i want to be a mod of this group as well , so do i need a back-up. But , i dont have too many posts to be let's say "popular" enough , so if you think i shouldn't do it , let me know. I vote for Vegan Marxist.

    The current list is :

    Red America
    Lyev
    Gran Rojo
    Amon Duul
    and me pending

    anyhow im gonna miss Charles
  19. Wanted Man
    Wanted Man - 6th November 2010, 01:14
    It should be Lyev. He can finally prove the practical use of Trotskyism by leading this group to glory.

    Nah, all the other ones in the list are fine though. Just as long as the next person doesn't make all sorts of wild changes to the group and doesn't moderate it too heavily.

    [FONT=Verdana]Sound like they banned him more on the grounds that he was a M-L then for trolling. Hell I may be banned today for no reason at all. He is not the first M-L to be banned on very little grounds. I think that we should all move to the new site he builds for us. [/FONT]

    [FONT=Verdana]http://communist.11.forumer.com/inde...3d013d0557d453[/FONT]

    [FONT=Verdana]There is no one on it right now, but if we all work on it, I think it will be better then revleft.[/FONT]
    Why start a new forum? Even outside of Revleft, there are plenty of forums to choose from.
  20. Communist
    Communist - 6th November 2010, 11:44
    4 Leaf Clover, I second you.
  21. Communist
    Communist - 6th November 2010, 11:54
    [FONT=Verdana]Sound like they banned him more on the grounds that he was a M-L then for trolling. Hell I may be banned today for no reason at all.[/FONT]
    Seriously, that's not the case. M-L aren't singled out, they aren't warned or infracted any more than any other tendency as far as I can see and as far as anyone has ever (well, since early 2009 anyway) successfully demonstrated. There's a few M-L mods - including Kassad, khad and myself - and even a M-L admin, Rjevan. If Marxist-Leninists weren't accepted, we wouldn't be there.
  22. 4 Leaf Clover - 6th November 2010, 16:58
    well , for transparency , it would be nice to tell other members of the group about the new decission , and to do either of these :

    1. inform everyone about the vote , so they could apply on time as well
    2. fuck democracy , and let one of ML mods take the moderating of this group as well , since they being mods , they already have possibility to edit posts
  23. Communist
    Communist - 7th November 2010, 01:04
    ^
    Many members of this group are inactive or banned. It'd be very difficult to inform everyone else and await responses, most of whom probably could care less, but a good thought...
  24. Comrade_Stalin
    Comrade_Stalin - 7th November 2010, 16:53
    It should be Lyev. He can finally prove the practical use of Trotskyism by leading this group to glory.

    Nah, all the other ones in the list are fine though. Just as long as the next person doesn't make all sorts of wild changes to the group and doesn't moderate it too heavily.



    Why start a new forum? Even outside of Revleft, there are plenty of forums to choose from.
    Do you know of ant pro M-L site out there? There are a lot of closeted anti-communists even here. Before I came here I was on the SovietEmpire site, and I can tell you a story that will make you think that the right wing runs the site.
  25. Comrade_Stalin
    Comrade_Stalin - 7th November 2010, 16:57
    Seriously, that's not the case. M-L aren't singled out, they aren't warned or infracted any more than any other tendency as far as I can see and as far as anyone has ever (well, since early 2009 anyway) successfully demonstrated. There's a few M-L mods - including Kassad, khad and myself - and even a M-L admin, Rjevan. If Marxist-Leninists weren't accepted, we wouldn't be there.
    This is not ture I have seen many communist form the old eastern block banned from this site. Some are only here a day. Most of the time these people how LIVED under communism are told they know nothing about it. All of the time this comes from "communist" that live un the West under capitalism.
  26. Comrade_Stalin
    Comrade_Stalin - 7th November 2010, 17:00
    well , for transparency , it would be nice to tell other members of the group about the new decission , and to do either of these :

    1. inform everyone about the vote , so they could apply on time as well
    2. fuck democracy , and let one of ML mods take the moderating of this group as well , since they being mods , they already have possibility to edit posts
    ^
    Many members of this group are inactive or banned. It'd be very difficult to inform everyone else and await responses, most of whom probably could care less, but a good thought...
    I second this way of thinking, but note no matter which option we take we need to make sure that this person is only a M-L and not a Maoist or a Hoxhaists. We all ready have to few M-L on this site I would hate to see them begin to banned each other.
  27. Volcanicity
    Volcanicity - 7th November 2010, 17:57
    As long as this group is lead by a Marxist-Leninist it does'nt matter who it is, but I agree it need's sorting sooner rather than later.I think a poll is the only way but I would back any serious ML otherwise.
  28. 4 Leaf Clover - 7th November 2010, 18:15
    Well , this group doesn't really need heavy moderating. But we could all help to get it back to life , since we got into discussion about the group. Should we make a poll ultimately or not ?
  29. Volcanicity
    Volcanicity - 7th November 2010, 18:38
    ^Yes why not,as you said it's not heavily moderated so the sooner the better.I think we can all agree on that.
  30. Communist
    Communist - 7th November 2010, 20:08
    This is not true I have seen many communist from the old eastern block banned from this site. Some are only here a day. Most of the time these people how LIVED under communism are told they know nothing about it. All of the time this comes from "communist" that live in the West under capitalism.
    Who? Why were they banned?
    And I'm sure you meant socialism.
12