Marxism-Leninism

  1. Charles Xavier
    I am wondering comrades if there is opposition to changing the name on the group to Marxism-Leninism. I do not see Marxism-Leninism and anti-revisionism being different in any way. I think the term Anti-Revisionism confuses newer members as several new members confuse the term revisionism with reformism, something we also reject of course. I think there is also confusion that we are adherants to Stalin, which while many of us view Stalin as successful leader of the Soviet Union it does not mean we believe Stalin represented a new level of socialism above what Lenin has already layed out.

    If comrades are against or disagree, let us discuss.
  2. Brother No. 1
    Brother No. 1
    Marxism-Leninism is the correct term but then everyone else will just say "our" Marxism-Leninism is incorrect and wont bring a Workers Democracy and ect ect ect.



    I think the term Anti-Revisionism confuses newer members as several new members confuse the term revisionism with reformism, something we also reject of course.
    If it confuses them then we, the Anti-Revisionists, correct them on the terms. This is a learning site after all.





    I think there is also confusion that we are adherants to Stalin, which while many of us view Stalin as successful leader of the Soviet Union it does not mean we believe Stalin represented a new level of socialism above what Lenin has already layed out
    We could tell them that we dont or the brief aspects of our veiws in the AR group intro. But this comes from the term "Stalinist" and we are always called this by everyother camp. They think Anti-Revisionism =/= Marxism-Leninism we their the same thing. explaing helps alot but this is my oppion only.




    I am wondering comrades if there is opposition to changing the name on the group to Marxism-Leninism.
    I'm all in for it actually. Since Marxism-Leninism is the correct term for Anti-Revisionism.
  3. mykittyhasaboner
    mykittyhasaboner
    How about Anti-Revisionist ML for short? Really, it doesn't matter all too much.

    Marxism-Leninism or Anti-Revisionism will both do fine.
  4. Bright Banana Beard
    Bright Banana Beard
    I have no problem with the label of Marxism-Leninism. It just what it really is.
  5. LeninBalls
    LeninBalls
    I am for changing it to Marxism Leninism.

    Anti Revisionism has too bad of a rep stuck to it.
  6. hugsandmarxism
    I am for changing it to Marxism Leninism.

    Anti Revisionism has too bad of a rep stuck to it.
    I'm for it, but I think what we really ought to do is drop the "Stalinist" user titles if we really want to reach out to newer members. I mean, it's fun to annoy some of these people, but it serves more to turn people away. Stalinist still means "personality cult follower" to alot of people, especially those who are new to leftist politics and/or cling to the current bourgeois propaganda. But idk... whatever works with everybody is fine by me.
  7. Kassad
    Kassad
    I honestly don't agree with the idea. A lot of Trotskyists claim to be upholding Marxism-Leninism. Of course, a lot of their theories and ideologies are incredibly contrary to ours, but the term 'Leninist' is very broad. I think anti-revisionist is a thorough description of our ideology; noting that revisionism is the primary cause for all failed socialist revolutions. I'm not going to water down my message because someone thinks Stalin has a bad stigma attached to him. Plus, the anti-revisionist movement is very influential and relevant today, therefore we should not attempt to distance ourselves from it. We should defend it.

    I would like to keep it, but I'll be fine either way.
  8. LOLseph Stalin
    LOLseph Stalin
    I may be biased as i'm not actually an Anti-Revisionist, but this could possibly cause problems as tendencies such as Trotskyists are technically "Marxist-Leninist" so you may be getting more members that aren't actually Anti-Revisionist, especially if they're beginners who don't fully understand the term.
  9. Brother No. 1
    Brother No. 1
    I may be biased as i'm not actually an Anti-Revisionist, but this could possibly cause problems as tendencies such as Trotskyists are technically "Marxist-Leninist" so you may be getting more members that aren't actually Anti-Revisionist, especially if they're beginners who don't fully understand the term.
    The name may change but we still follow the same path and the descrivtion will still be here. The name is the only thing thats going to change. The Troskyists will argue yes but they always argue with us. its common really.
  10. LOLseph Stalin
    LOLseph Stalin
    Well yes we do argue, but i'm just saying that technically Anti-Revisionists aren't the only "Marxist-Leninists" out there.
  11. Kassad
    Kassad
    InsertNameHere is very on target. I hate telling Trotskyists they're right, but in this case, he is.
  12. Brother No. 1
    Brother No. 1
    InsertNameHere is very on target. I hate telling Trotskyists they're right, but in this case, he is.
    Troskyism is another form on Marxism-Leninism so yes SHE is right.
  13. Kassad
    Kassad
    My mistake. Apologies.
  14. Brother No. 1
    Brother No. 1
    its ok you cant really tell male from fremale on these internet forums.
  15. Charles Xavier
    I disagree, I view trotskyism in contradiction to Leninism. Its false to claim such a legacy. There are several Trotsky's though, there's trotsky the menshevik, there's trotsky the bolshevik, who for a brief period represented a correct approach, and then theres Trotsky the counter-revolutionary.

    I do not see this as watering down our message, we are not saying anything we are not, I think by using the term Marxism-Leninism we are doing the opposite, Marxism-Leninism is a specific ideological trend. My party calls itself Marxist-Leninist.

    Trotskyists do not consider themselves Marxist-Leninists they prefere the term Bolshevik-Leninist.

    If you disagree then the sake of comprisemise we name ourselves,
    Marxism-Leninism (Anti-Revisionism).


    Thoughts?
  16. LeninBalls
    LeninBalls
    Or change it to Stalinism.
  17. Cumannach
    Cumannach
    I don't think it matters that much, but that last one is the best option- although it's quite a mouthful so maybe Marxist-Leninist (AR), but then nobody knows what it stands for...

    I think just Marxist-Leninist on it's own is probably the best for the purposes of this site.

    As far as I can see there's no other groups with that name as of now.
  18. LeninBalls
    LeninBalls
    http://www.revleft.com/vb/hey-left-c...756/index.html This is what I'm talking about

    It gets tiring when everyone equates Anti Revisionism with totalitarianism and oligarchies, it's especially dangerous to newcomers who are undecided on their ideology and then see Anti Revisionism as Stalinism backed up by Trots and HLVS.
  19. Bright Banana Beard
    Bright Banana Beard
    or Marxist-Leninist (Non-Trotskyism)
  20. Kassad
    Kassad
    Don't you see what this is? Anti-Revisionists works perfectly fine, whereas Marxism-Leninism leaves confusion and forces us to elaborate on the title.
  21. Charles Xavier
    I do not want this to be a divisive issue where we take a vote and half of the group is pissed off and leaves because of it.

    The reason I am purposing the change is because I'm getting asked multiple times a week in PMs, "What is anti-revisionism?" "Revisionism is trying to vote in socialism right?" etc etc.
    The problem is that the current name causes a lot of confusion and many comrades here do not even know what Anti-Revisionism is.

    On top of that I think Marxist-Leninist is a more honest name for what we are, from my understanding Anti-Revisionism is a term used by Ex-Maoist parties or Hoxhaist parties. Theres a number of us in here who are not members of Ex-Maoist or Hoxhaist parties, myself included, equally I stand against revisionism though, but we are all Marxist-Leninists.

    William Z. Foster and Tim Buck where members of the Official communist parties in USA and Canada but none will deny their role against revisionism.

    As moderator I have powers to kick out revisionists, trotskyists and other disruptive individuals. And the description could be written in a way informing that we are a group for marxist-leninists not trotskyites, etc. I would like to put this to a vote. But if we vote I want their to be no hard feelings no matter what side you are on. If its going to be divisive there is not sense voting on it.
  22. Andropov
    Andropov
    I think its a brilliant idea to change it to Marxist-Leninist.
    Im all for it.
  23. Wanted Man
    Wanted Man
    Yes, I support this. Marxism-Leninism is the ideology that the international communist movement is based on. Anti-revisionism is important in this, but is a description of what we are against, rather than an ideology of its own. Identifying this group as M-L would align it with the international communist movement itself, and therefore be closer to the real-life situation.

    It's also not true that this would cause confusion with Trotskyism. Trotskyists reject the term "Marxism-Leninism", as it is a tendency that was developed in the Stalin era, and so they see it as a Stalinist distortion. It is possible that Trotskyists who have not studied their own history will not know this and participate, but then it could be explained to them patiently.

    Will it be possible to have a vote on this?
  24. Woland
    Woland
    ^ said it all for me.
  25. Rjevan
    Rjevan
    Though I see that the term might be confusing and might alientate some newbies I agree with Kassad.
    I don't like the idea of changing lables because of some people who are scared off by what describes our attitude very well. The description text of this group should make clear that we are Marxists-Leninists and I think there would still be confusion and we would still be seen (and be presented by others) as "hardcore lunatics", no matter if we change names or not.

    But as I said, I see your points and I would not block renaming if most comrades here think that it would be better for our group/image. So I'm in favour of a vote, too.
  26. Kassad
    Kassad
    Sounds like most people here are totally for it. I say go for it, then. While we're here, does anyone else dislike the main picture for the group? I had a few ideas that I think would look good and would also clear up any misunderstandings of our tendency, which I believe is very necessary with the name change. A few ideas:

    https://trcs.wikispaces.com/file/vie...nGorki1922.jpg


    http://www.marxists.org/subject/stal...no-picture.jpg

    http://www.aetherometry.com/Electron...and_stalin.jpg
  27. LOLseph Stalin
    LOLseph Stalin
    Personally I like the second one Kassad, but it's up to you guys since i'm not actually an AR.
  28. Brother No. 1
    Brother No. 1
    The 2nd one is awsome. It shows what we follow and at the same time shows what we think. Good choice comrade Kassad you seem to chose good pics. I love them all but the 2nd gets me.
  29. Kassad
    Kassad
    Thanks.

    Oh, by the way. Shouldn't we name the group Marxist-Leninists? I mean, there isn't a Trotskyism group, or a Revolutionary Marxism group. It's Trotskyist and Revolutionary Marxists. Our group isn't Anti-Revisionism. Shouldn't we call it Marxist-Leninists?
  30. LOLseph Stalin
    LOLseph Stalin
    It's really up to you guys, but I don't oppose the change.
12