The Communist theories

[Brother No. 1]

Comrades there are some communist ideals and their laws but which one would you support Marxism,Leninism,Stalinism,troskyism,maoism or all of them tell me your thoughts

[Q]

Comrades there are some communist ideals and their laws but which one would you support Marxism,Leninism,Stalinism,troskyism,maoism or all of them tell me your thoughts

Given my sig mine is obvious. But what is the point of your question?

[Brother No. 1]

the point is to see what communist ideal you belive in is that a um problem comrade

[Q]

the point is to see what communist ideal you belive in is that a um problem comrade

No, I just think it rather pointless and besides there a bound to be dozens of threads and polls like this. Do a search?

[Brother No. 1]

ok comrade i'll delete it if you wish

[Q]

Now don't be butthurt :P
Just suggesting you might want to be more specific in your question.

What ideas are you defending? Why are you defending those? How did you came to those conclusions?
:)

[Brother No. 1]

oh Lets see ok heres my new question is should all the communsit ideals including Stalinism be appreiated or only the ones that will work affectively on the people

[Q]

oh Lets see ok heres my new question is should all the communsit ideals including Stalinism be appreiated or only the ones that will work affectively on the people

The basics of Marxism is scientific, so: "that what works, is used, the rest is adapted or put in the trashbin". Stalinism put itself into the trashbin of history really.

[Brother No. 1]

thank you comrade for your answer and your right about Stalism it put itself in the trashbin of human history

[revolution inaction]

Comrades there are some communist ideals and their laws but which one would you support Marxism,Leninism,Stalinism,troskyism,maoism or all of them tell me your thoughts

Marxism is more about analyzing capitalism than a communist ideal.
Maoism is a kind of stalinism, stalinism and troskyism are both kinds of leninism, and I don't see any kind of leninism is communist.
They are definitely not a communist ideal anyway.

[Pogue]

I think vanguardism has proven itself to be a failure.

[Q]

I think vanguardism has proven itself to be a failure.

Yet the vanguard, as the politically most militant and aware layer of the working class, is still a daily fact of life. How can it then be a failure?

[Brother No. 1]

thank you for your thoughts comrades

[Kassad]

I suppose vanguardism, in the sense that it has been assaulted from all sides by western colonialism every time it is attempted, is a failure.

[mikelepore]

oh Lets see ok heres my new question is should all the communsit ideals including Stalinism be appreiated or only the ones that will work affectively on the people

Begin by paying no attention to what "-ism" a system is called, and just ask about each social system you find: does this system have a democratic process in economic life? Does this system accurately measure the choices expressed by the people and then make that the official policy? Do the workers in every workplace freely choose their own managers and supervisors?

[Brother No. 1]

you make a exelent point comrade