Log in

View Full Version : The Wind That Shakes The Barley



Saorsa
1st February 2008, 03:07
Last night I finally got around to watching the Ken Loach film, The Wind That Shakes The Barley. Made in 2006, the film tells the story of two brothers Damien and Teddy O'Donovan, with Damien being the main character. Beiginning in 1920, it traces the hiusrtory of the Irish national liberation struggle against the British occupation, and also the Irish Civil War that follows it, with the two brothers who once fought side by side against the British now finding themselves on opposite sides of the barricades, with one brother supporting the (sell-out) peace treaty that created the Irish Free State within the framework of both the British Empire and the capitalist system, and the other brother vowing to fight on forever until Ireland and it's people are totally free, both from British imperialism and from capitalist exploitation.

The movie is profoundly moving and gripping right until the end, and I can guarantee that it will live with you for a very long time, as well as turning you into a staunch supporter of the Irish liberation struggle (if you aren't already). It's got very good performances from it's actors, and includes Ken Loach's trademark scenes of debate between opposing viewpoints, in this case over both the ratification of the peace treaty with Britain and over a rich merchant who is bankrolling the IRA's treatment of a poor old woman.

It's the first Ken Loach film I've seen, but it's convinced me that I have to get out there and see his others, particularly Land and Freedom (about the Spanish Civil War). If you haven't seen it already, go out and rent or buy a copy of it. You won't be disappointed.

Vanguard1917
1st February 2008, 03:45
It is a very good film - Ken Loach at his best IMO. You definitely need to see Land and Freedom, along with his other films.

Pawn Power
1st February 2008, 04:57
Spectacualr film. Cillian Murphy was marvelous and gorgeous.

jaffe
8th February 2008, 17:21
good movie indeed

Y Chwyldro Comiwnyddol Cymraeg
8th February 2008, 20:20
Yup...fanastic film. I would say that Land and Freedom in slightly better...that may be because I find the SCW slightly more interesting than the Irish. But still a masterpiece of cinema

UnderTheWeepingMoon
8th February 2008, 23:13
Hullo thar, Alastair.

bayano
27th February 2008, 00:39
it was in chicago too briefly, but some local irish activists made bootleg copies and started disseminating them with loach's personal blessing. and some independent marxists were doing the same. ive showed it to as many people as i can, and am continuing with the better quality of the dvd. awesome. yknow, those of us who arent trotskyites tend to talk trash about trots, but we all (anarchists, maoists, independent marxists, others) love loach. evidence that we can and should all get along better, i think

Red October
5th March 2008, 02:50
It's a great movie, I'm considering showing it at a little "Revolutionary Film" night I want to organize. I'll be showing Land and Freedom as well.

Lector Malibu
5th March 2008, 03:31
Glorious film ! I waited for it to come out for a long time and was excited when I could finally rent it. I'd recommend it highly

Angry Young Man
5th March 2008, 18:19
As evidence of why they should take on more marxist teachers, we got to watch it in history:)
Loach always manages to hit a sore nerve. I've seen Kes and Land and Freedom, and they both had incredible endings. Need to watch the rest of The Wind.

EricTheRed
12th March 2008, 05:35
Absolutely stunning movie.