Log in

View Full Version : Stoning of Kurdish Woman



Connolly
22nd June 2007, 13:47
Posted by "seabird" at http://theplough.proboards57.com/index.cgi


It is the so-called "honour killing" of 17-year-old Du'a Khalil Aswad by an angry mob of Yezidis on April 7, 2007.


I know this has been out there for a couple of months now, however, I felt it was important to share this poor girl's story with our readers at ICB. This is a different sort of true crime story than what most of us are used to, but it will still break your heart.

Du'a Khalil Aswad, 17, fell in love with a boy. A Muslim boy. A major no-no in the Yezidi religion. The Yezidis are a Kurdish pre-Islamic sect with uniquely different beliefs. They worship the "Peac*** Angel" known as Melek Taus, also commonly referred to as "Satan" by Muslims. The Yezidis still prefer to settle differences amongst themselves with throat slitting and stoning.

Du'a had fallen in love, ran away to marry her love, and intended to convert to Islam. She was subsequently ostracized from her family. Cross-religious relationships are forbidden in Yezidi tradition and dealt with in the most serious manner -- execution. Fearing for her life, Du'a was sequestered into hiding by her boyfriend and a Muslim cleric (some sources say a Yezidi cleric) for several months.

Apparently, Du'a's family convinced her that she was forgiven and welcomed her back to her village. When she arrived, she was horrified to see the raging mob of at least 1,000 men waiting for her. Blood lust in their eyes. Cell phone cameras at the ready. Dozens of large stones. And two large concrete blocks nearby.

Her own family had tricked her.

As with the Ertman/Pena killings, there are several issues that can be discussed in regard to Du'a's death: religious intolerance, religious strictures, male-domination, suppression, and subjugation of women are just a few that come to mind.

But I want to look at something more primordial, more animalistic -- the sadistic nature of a mob of men when deciding to end the life of a young girl.

In the Ertman/Pena murders, six teenage boys violated two teenage girls for nearly an hour. When they were done raping them, they decided to terminate the teenagers. First with a belt around one's throat. A pair of shoelaces around the other's throat. When those did not work, they kicked the girls in the mouth, in the face, in the ribs. They smashed in their faces, all the while, whooping it up and having a grand old time. Afterwards, one of the killers bragged that he had "the blood of a virgin on his underwear."

If you were able to watch the Du'a video, you witnessed how an unruly mob takes on several qualities that may not necessarily be present within an individual. The ability to desecrate another human being rises. The level of taunting increases. The outright brazenness of the mob rises to levels never before seen. The willingness to help gets tossed out the window.

In Dua's murder, several people are wielding cell phones. They look like lighting directors on a film set holding up their light meters to their subject in preparation for the next shoot. These Yezidi men, who claim that Du'a should die based on a thousand-year-old tradition, willingly document her demise with the latest tools of modern technology.

The gruesomeness of the stoning is obvious. The girl is dragged into the town square in a headlock. Police officers stand by and do nothing. The girl is tossed to the ground and kicked repeatedly. Her bright red tracksuit top is an eerie percursor to what she will eventually look like. Dozens of men surround her, taunting her. One man throws a concrete block on her back. Not a single man does anything to stop the punishment. Instead, they all cheer each time a new blow is landed. The poor girl rolls onto her back, her bloody face worn out from exhaustion. She has been tortured for nearly an hour. Her black panty-clad bottom is exposed only to be covered up by one of the murderers. Apparently, physical destruction of a human being is acceptable, black panties are not.

Several of the men (I use the term loosely) gather around D'ua only to repeatedly stomp on her head, her back, her legs. Finally, one psychopath takes a large cinder block, walks up to the spent girl, and tosses it down forcefully upon her head. The life literally drains out of the girl as a large river of blood begans to spill from her broken skull. The roar is unanimous! The crowd loves it! The cell phone Spielbergs step in closer for a better look. They hold their tools of documentation directly into her face. Another man, witnessing her exposed bottom one more time, again covers up the offending body part.

Meanwhile, the blood flows. And flows.

But that is not enough for these men. They must make a statement. They must display their machismo for the world. Besides, the cameras are on. Might as well put on a good show. Another man crushes her skull yet again with another large block of concrete. The crowd cheers. Block to the head, crowd cheers. Repeat ad nauseum.

A partial price has been paid in the Ertman/Pena killings. Five of the six boys received the death penalty. The sixth, "Yuni" Medellin, testified against the other five, including his brother, Joe Medellin. Two of the five who received the death penalty had their sentences reduced thanks to a recent ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court that claimed murderers aged 17 and under could not be considered to be adults. Joe Medellin, currently has an appeal before the Supreme Court that argues he did not receive proper representation because he was born in Mexico and never became an American citizen, despite living in Texas for nine of his eighteen years. Peter Cantu awaits his execution. Sean O'Brien was executed last summer.

In Du'a's case, retribution came quick. A busload of Yezidis and others were pulled over by a group of Iraqi Muslims on April 22, 2007 outside of Mosul. Twenty-three Yezidis were forcefully removed from the bus and executed with guns.

Just last month, two of her own family members were arrested in their participation of the so-called "honour killing" of their own flesh and blood.

In each case, the male species comes off more like a pack of wolves than as decent human beings. Hungry, ravenous, vengeful. Together, as a group, men are even more capable of engaging in some of the most depraved and unacceptable behavior ever witnessed.

I don't know the real reason behind such gruesome behaviour. Somehow, I don't believe it will ever stop. Hopefully, drawing attention to events like this will force some people to reasses how they look at and treat women.

We can only hope.




Here's a petition you can sign to help stop the murders of Kurdish women.

http://www.petitiononline.com/kurdish/petition.html

International Campaign against killings and stoning of women in Kurdistan

Intifada
22nd June 2007, 13:55
Even though I couldn't watch more than a minute of the video, that is perhaps the most disgusting thing I have ever seen.

I am at the edge of losing all faith in the human race.

Connolly
22nd June 2007, 14:00
Dont forget to sign the petition!!

Intifada
22nd June 2007, 14:12
I did.

Raúl Duke
22nd June 2007, 14:43
Religion seems more good at creating discord and intolerance among people than actually uniting them.

(I signed the petition...but will it really do anything?)

RedArmyFaction
22nd June 2007, 19:27
I signed the petition. I couldn't even watch the video. I hate things like that. Humans are such bastards

Ander
22nd June 2007, 19:49
...

Holy fucking shit. There are no words to describe how I feel right now.

This was probably the most disturbing thing I have ever seen.

Spirit of Spartacus
22nd June 2007, 20:51
How can anyone do it to a 17-year-old girl?

And worse, how can they do it if she's from their own family? :(

She has a beautiful name.

sexyguy
22nd June 2007, 23:08
Reading the report and your responses, I don’t want to watch the film.
Is their any reason that I should?

Janus
23rd June 2007, 01:50
According to this site concerning her death and the reprisal attack in Mosul.


Yazidis condemned the girl's killing.

"In Yazidism, there is no religious text that calls for stoning. There is nothing that refers to punishing a person with stones, whatever the accusation is. According to Yazidi religious texts, God has chosen human beings over all other creatures. How then could a very young girl be killed with stones?" stated Sheikh Alo Khalf, a prominent Yazidi cleric. He said that stoning is not of the Yazidis' habits but the event was exploited by some extremists.

Meanwhile, the murder was denounced by the Yazidis' spiritual leader, Baba Sheikh Khato, and by the spiritual High Council of the Yazidi religion, led by Meer Tahseen Sa'eed Ali, leader of Yazidis in Iraq and around the world. They insisted that the girl didn't convert to Islam and asked that the criminals be judged.

"The reason for Du'a's murder was not because she wanted to convert to a Muslim as it was interpreted by people, but because she was in love with a Muslim youth," said a relative of Du'aa.

Yazidi leaders voice concern over violence (http://www.kurdishaspect.com/doc050207KD.html)


Is their any reason that I should?
Not really; like the others said it is quite disturbing.

sexyguy
23rd June 2007, 08:55
OK, cheers.

TC
23rd June 2007, 12:24
I'm curious,

after that overly, almost relishing and pornographically detailed description of the film and people's comments concerning the film, what possess someone to watch it?

Moreover, what possess someone to post it on the internet and then post a link to it?


This strikes me as nothing more than a snuff film which the observers and posters are justifying watching and distributing to themselves with the notion that its political in some regard.

Yes of course, stoning women for patriarchal tribal traditions is a political issue, but for someone who doesn't have a perverted semi-sexual interest in it, thats all you need to know, or would care to know.


Frankly i'm less interested in the scenario of this girl getting stoned (which its not like we haven't heard of that kindof stuff before) as i am in people's desire to watch it and describe the film in [i]excruciating detail. The same is true if not even more obvious in the description of the "Ertman/Pena killing" incident.

When you read phrases like:

"Meanwhile, the blood flows. And flows." or "he life literally drains out of the girl as a large river of blood begans to spill from her broken skull."

One almost suspects that the author is getting off on it!.


This is supposed from the "International Campaign against killings and stoning of women in Kurdistan", but really, come on. If the authors really cared about this person as an individual, not as an iconic representation of third world women or, frankly, some kind of snuff film porn star, they wouldn't be distributing a film of her being humiliated and killed as its further degrading to her, or her memory rather. I mean imagine if this happened to a friend or relative or girlfriend, would you want a film, her murders shot, to be distributed along with an overly detailed description of it to be posted around the internet? I don't think so, i think you'd probably want legal action against anyone who did that. In fact in a lot of countries, distributing mobile phone films of murders or serious assaults is itself a crime.

RedArmyFaction
23rd June 2007, 19:56
Originally posted by [email protected] 23, 2007 11:24 am
I'm curious,

after that overly, almost relishing and pornographically detailed description of the film and people's comments concerning the film, what possess someone to watch it?

Moreover, what possess someone to post it on the internet and then post a link to it?


This strikes me as nothing more than a snuff film which the observers and posters are justifying watching and distributing to themselves with the notion that its political in some regard.

Yes of course, stoning women for patriarchal tribal traditions is a political issue, but for someone who doesn't have a perverted semi-sexual interest in it, thats all you need to know, or would care to know.


Frankly i'm less interested in the scenario of this girl getting stoned (which its not like we haven't heard of that kindof stuff before) as i am in people's desire to watch it and describe the film in [i]excruciating detail. The same is true if not even more obvious in the description of the "Ertman/Pena killing" incident.

When you read phrases like:

"Meanwhile, the blood flows. And flows." or "he life literally drains out of the girl as a large river of blood begans to spill from her broken skull."

One almost suspects that the author is getting off on it!.


This is supposed from the "International Campaign against killings and stoning of women in Kurdistan", but really, come on. If the authors really cared about this person as an individual, not as an iconic representation of third world women or, frankly, some kind of snuff film porn star, they wouldn't be distributing a film of her being humiliated and killed as its further degrading to her, or her memory rather. I mean imagine if this happened to a friend or relative or girlfriend, would you want a film, her murders shot, to be distributed along with an overly detailed description of it to be posted around the internet? I don't think so, i think you'd probably want legal action against anyone who did that. In fact in a lot of countries, distributing mobile phone films of murders or serious assaults is itself a crime.
I'm glad you're not running for office. Messed up views or what. Fair enough they are your views but you could be abit more sensitive about something like this. You need to pipe down a little more and have some heart, mate.

Raúl Duke
23rd June 2007, 23:19
I actually didn't think about watching the film when I signed the petition....(and I couldn't have though at the time because of my current slow internet service. (however, if it means anything to you, I'm guilty of reading the post. :mellow: )

la-troy
24th June 2007, 00:20
To Tragic Clown I've heard of number of stoning taking place and truly this is the first time I really feel the impact of such a thing. reading the text was enough for me and i think the more people read it is the more they will want to stop these things. I mean that passage was much more motivating than " In other news a young girl was brutally stoned to death"

Ander
27th June 2007, 21:26
Oh shit, TC caught me!

Ok everyone, I admit that my pants are around my ankles and I am masturbating furiously to this material. Nothing like a broken skull and ocean of blood to turn me the fuck on!

PS: Please stfu and stop being so annoying in future. Thx.

Devrim
27th June 2007, 21:50
I have never heard of this kind of thing among the Yazidi. It seems a little unusual.

23 Yazidi men were taken off a bus, and shot following this event.

Without saying that this is not real (I haven't watched the film, and don't want to, but even if the film is real, it doesn't mean they are who they say they are), it will certainly be used to stir up more sectarian violence.

Devrim

Qwerty Dvorak
28th June 2007, 01:40
Petition signed.

redcannon
28th June 2007, 23:44
i couldn't get more than 30 seconds into this film before my imagination made up the rest. i think i'm gonna be really sick.

what a mad world.

Devrim
29th June 2007, 00:31
Originally posted by The Red Banner
In Du'a's case, retribution came quick. A busload of Yezidis and others were pulled over by a group of Iraqi Muslims on April 22, 2007 outside of Mosul. Twenty-three Yezidis were forcefully removed from the bus and executed with guns.

I just read through this whole post. This is sick. Are you really suggesting that if Yazidis kill a woman (which I am a little dubious about anyway), it is then ok to pull 23 random Yazidi off a bus, and shoot them?

Devrim

Connolly
29th June 2007, 00:49
I just read through this whole post. This is sick. Are you really suggesting that if Yazidis kill a woman (which I am a little dubious about anyway), it is then ok to pull 23 random Yazidi off a bus, and shoot them?

Im afraid I didnt write that article.

Here's a follow-up news story:



Arrests after Iraqi girl's stoning
Al Jazeera.net
UPDATED ON:
SUNDAY, MAY 20, 2007
12:55 MECCA TIME, 9:55 GMT


Aswad's killing was captured by members of the crowd on their mobile phones


Iraqi authorities are reported to have arrested four people in connection with the death by stoning of a Kurdish teenager, which was filmed and posted on the internet.

Two of those arrested in Nineveh province, in northern Iraq are said to be members of the girl's immediate family, said reports on Saturday.

Du'a Khalil Aswad, who was 17-years-old, was stoned to death on April 7, allegedly by members of her family during an "honour killing", according to local officials.

She was dragged half-naked into the street where a crowd gathered and a number of people filmed her death on mobile phones.

Footage of Aswad's death was later posted on the internet, where the videos showed what appeared to be uniformed members of a security force among the crowd.

Ancient beliefs

Authorities have said Aswad was attacked and killed because members of her community believed she had run off to marry a Sunni Muslim man.

Aswad was a member of the Yazidi sect, a religious group, incorporating a number of ancient beliefs that does not allow marriage outside the faith.

"They [the crowd] brutally killed a young Yazidi girl in pursuit of out-of-date tribal rites," the AFP news agency quoted Tahsin Saeed Ali, the Yazidi religious leader known as the emir of the Yazidis in Iraq as saying.

The Kurdish Regional Government later condemned the killing and called for Aswad's killers to be brought to justice.

CNN and the Malaysia Sun reported the arrests, with CNN quoting local officials as saying they were looking for four more suspects, including one of Aswad's cousins.

Amnesty International, the human rights group, said it welcomed the Kurdish government's condmenation of the killing.

A spokesmen said Amnesty had requested "concrete measures to protect all those at risk of becoming victims of 'honour crimes".

Source: Al Jazeera

Devrim
29th June 2007, 01:03
From Wiki, my emphasis:

Originally posted by Wiki
Du'a Khalil Aswad (c. 1989/1990 – c. April 7, 2007) was a 17 year old Iraqi Yazidi girl who was stoned to death in an honor killing.[1] It is believed that she was killed around April 7, 2007, but the incident did not come to light until video of the stoning, apparently recorded on a mobile phone, appeared on the Internet.
Motive
Some reports say she was murdered by Yazidi men, some of them her relatives, for having converted to Islam to marry a Sunni Arab boy.[1][3] It is disputed whether or not she actually converted to Islam; some reports say the Sunni boyfriend has denied that she converted.[1] Other sources instead indicate that Du’a Khalil Aswad was killed in punishment for being absent from her home one night.[4]

Asylum and return
Some news agencies reported that Aswad was being sheltered by a Yazidi tribal leader in Bashika in fear of her life until her family persuaded her that she had been forgiven and could return home.[4] Other reports indicate that she was instead given asylum by a local Muslim Sheikh.[2] It is not know whether the same member of her family that convinced her to return home were responsible for her death. It is not clear from the video whether Du’a Khalil Aswad was ambushed while returning to her home, or if the mob stormed her home and dragged her into the street. Estimates of the number of attackers range from one thousand[2] to two thousand[5] men.

Obviously someone has been brutally murdered here. The reports of what happened seem very unclear. To talk about 'retribution' against members of the Yazidi community, seems to me to suggest that the Yazidi community as a whole is guilty. I don't question the motives of the original poster, but I get the feeling that there may be more to this thatn meets the eye, and justifying massacres could well be a part of it.

Devrim

Neutrino
29th June 2007, 01:45
I remember hearing about this before. I saw the video - it's the most disgusting thing I think I've ever watched. :angry:

Petition signed.

Devrim
15th August 2007, 07:15
In the light of the recent massacre in Iraq, these events assume a little more interest: http://www.guardian.co.uk/Iraq/Story/0,,2149068,00.html
Two months ago I wrote:

Originally posted by Devrim
I get the feeling that there may be more to this thatn meets the eye, and justifying massacres could well be a part of it.
Devrim