Log in

View Full Version : Immigrant workers convicted of "identity theft"



Severian
1st April 2007, 05:59
From this week's Militant (http://www.themilitant.com/2007/7114/711403.html)
More workers arrested in Swift raids convicted of ‘identity theft’

BY FRANK FORRESTAL AND JOE SWANSON

DES MOINES, Iowa, March 27—On the second day of her trial today, Eloísa Núñez Galeana was found guilty on “identity theft” felony charges. Along with 99 other meat packers, Núñez, who hails from Mexico, was arrested by immigration agents in the Dec. 12, 2006, raid of the Swift plant in nearby Marshalltown, Iowa.

Since her arrest, Núñez has been held in a Des Moines jail. Hired by Swift in 2003, Núñez worked on the cut floor as a trimmer.

Earlier this month, another Swift worker from the Marshalltown plant, Lorena Andrade Rodríguez, was convicted on similar felony charges. The mother of two children, Rodríguez said she used another person’s identity “out of need” to support her family. Andrade is appealing the verdict.

Núñez was the subject of an article headlined, “Illegal Worker, Troubled Citizen and Stolen Name,” which was published on the front page of the March 22 New York Times. The article said that Núñez, and several other female immigrant workers arrested in the raids, are “resolved to fight the charges against them rather than make a deal with prosecutors that would lead to their deportation with no chance of legal return.”

Núñez was defended by Michael Mayer and Michael Said, two immigration attorneys based in Des Moines. Núñez’s three children are now reportedly under the care of her sister, who also works at the Swift plant.

In a related development, eight meat packers from the Swift plant in Cactus, Texas, pleaded guilty March 13 to felony charges stemming from the immigration raid of that plant.

The federal government’s Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) raided six Swift plants nationwide in December, in the largest such raid ever against a single employer.

Of the nearly 300 workers arrested at the Cactus plant, 53 face criminal charges in a federal court in Amarillo, Texas.

One worker, who pleaded guilty to re-entering the United States without proper documentation after being deported, faces a maximum penalty of 20 years in prison and a fine of $250,000.

On March 20, another five Swift workers from the Cactus plant pleaded guilty to felony charges of using false Social Security numbers and fake papers. They face a maximum penalty of five years in prison and a $250,000 fine. On the same day, six other workers pleaded guilty to misdemeanor counts and were each sentenced to 100 days in jail, according to the Associated Press. Cases are still pending against the remaining 34 workers arrested in Cactus.

On February 26, four workers from the Swift plant in Louisville, Kentucky, were sentenced in federal court for using false papers. U.S. District Court Judge John Heyburn, sentenced each worker to five months in federal prison. After serving their sentences, each of the meat packers will be subject to deportation. The Louisville plant was the only Swift slaughterhouse that wasn’t raided in December. In that operation, which took place in October 2006, ICE agents arrested the meat packers while they were at work.

According to the ICE website, of the 1,297 workers arrested in the Swift raids, 649 have “been removed from the United States.” The countries of origin of the deported workers include Chile, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, and Peru.

[end of article]
****

This is a serious new attack - since all of the millions of undocumented workers in this country must use someone else's Social Security number to work. This of course does no harm to the individual whose "identity" is "stolen" - the reverse, they're credited with more earnings by the Social Security Administration!

This is just another weapon for punishing some immigrant workers in an attempt to intimidate the rest. To keep them from demanding rights as immigrants, or organizing as workers.

But these dramatic, large-scale raids have been met by protests - even while the raid was going on, friends and relatives gathered outside one of the plants and attempted to stop a bus from leaving.

Some immigrants' rights groups have been calling for renewed actions on May 1, or April 7 in Los Angeles. (http://www.themilitant.com/2007/7114/711458.html)

Janus
3rd April 2007, 00:04
since all of the millions of undocumented workers in this country must use someone else's Social Security number to work.
I thought they simply used bogus Social Security cards purchased from the black market?

As far as Social Security goes, undocumented workers are bolstering it through payroll taxes and other earnings that total around $300 billion so it seems quite paradoxical that the gov. is cracking down on those who are helping to keep it afloat.

Severian
3rd April 2007, 07:23
Originally posted by [email protected] 02, 2007 05:04 pm

since all of the millions of undocumented workers in this country must use someone else's Social Security number to work.
I thought they simply used bogus Social Security cards purchased from the black market?
Of course. And of course those card must have somebody's number on them. You wouldn't get far with a Social Security Card with an invalid number.


As far as Social Security goes, undocumented workers are bolstering it through payroll taxes and other earnings that total around $300 billion so it seems quite paradoxical that the gov. is cracking down on those who are helping to keep it afloat.

Right. The goal is not to get rid of immigrant workers, of course, but to intimidate them, keep them cheap labor. Felony prosecutions do that better than just shipping someone across the border.

Along the same lines, these recent raids have been unusually big, splashy, and well-publicized.

They may actually be doing fewer deportations than in the past - I know that was the case when a couple years ago compared to pre-2000, but I haven't seen recent stats.

Janus
4th April 2007, 05:22
You wouldn't get far with a Social Security Card with an invalid number.
But they can only be caught for it if the feds actually try to verify it since most employers are complicit in the hiring of undocumented workers. I would think that using a stolen SSN would be riskier since the identity theft victim could be aware and contact the police.

Anyways, what is important is that massive amounts of revenues are generated from those holding stolen or fake SSN and accrued within the Social Security's earning suspense file.

Severian
16th April 2007, 06:44
Originally posted by [email protected] 03, 2007 10:22 pm
Anyways, what is important is that massive amounts of revenues are generated from those holding stolen or fake SSN and accrued within the Social Security's earning suspense file.
Right; quite a change from the myth about immigrants not paying taxes.

BTW, the feds send out a lot of "no match" letters telling employers to fire people for having the wrong social security numbers.