Log in

View Full Version : Munir Said Thalib



Knight of Cydonia
10th January 2007, 01:17
Munir Said Thalib (December 8, 1965 – September 7, 2004), affectionally known simply as 'Munir', was Indonesia's most famous Human Rights and anti-corruption activist. The founder of the Kontras human rights organisation and laureate of the Right Livelihood Award, Munir was assassinated in 2004 while travelling to Utrecht University to pursue a Master's degree in international law and human rights

Educated in law at Brawijaya University in Malang, East Java, Munir started his career in 1989 as a legal aid officier in the capital of East Java, Surabaya. Soon Munir had become Indonesia's top human rights campaigner and regularly spoke out for justice in the face of intimidation, including death threats. He was an especially vocal critic of Indonesia's military, accusing it of numerous human rights violations in East Timor and the troubled provinces of Papua and Aceh. The 38-year-old activist also accused them of running a criminal network involved in illegal tree logging and drug smuggling.

Munir was poisoned with arsenic on a flight from Jakarta to Amsterdam on September 7, 2004. He was travelling on state-owned airline Garuda Indonesia. It was concluded from Munir's autopsy and witnesses during the trial, had passed away two hours before arrival in Schiphol, Amsterdam. He took the arsenic during his flight transit in Singapore, or sometimes near that time. In Singapore, Pollycarpus Priyanto, the prime suspect in Munir's trial, left the flight and then went back to Indonesia. Originally he departed from Indonesia by dead heading, with a fake document which allowed him to fly with other flight which was not his scheduled flight. Munir began to suffer an acute diarrhea and bouts of vomiting shortly after his flight took off from Singapore to Amsterdam. The cabin crew immediately reported to the pilot in command that a passenger was sick -- a condition which had forced him to go to the restroom several times. Munir was treated by a doctor on board the plane but pronounced dead a short time before the plane landed at Amsterdam’s Schiphol airport.

When the results of the autopsy were released two months later, on November 12, (the Netherlands Forensic Institute) revealed that Munir's body contained a level of Arsenic almost three times that needed to kill a person. This was later confirmed by Indonesian police.

Three suspects - Pollycarpus Priyanto, a former pilot who allegedly gave up his business class seat to Munir during the flight, and two flight attendants. It is alleged that he (Priyanto) placed the Arsenic in Munir's orange juice, upon orders from Garuda's chief executive at that time, Indra Setiawan. Indonesian president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono proclaimed that he will make sure that Munir's killers are brought to justice.

In December 2005 Pollycarpus Priyanto was found guilty of Munir's murder by an Indonesian court and sentenced to fourteen years' imprisonment. Munir's supporters claim that Priyanto was acting on orders and that this was not brought out during the court case.

In October 2006, the Supreme Court quashed the conviction against Pollycarpus Priyanto, citing insufficient evidence

What make me sad is,why does the people that seem know a lot about the bad side of the government in my country, has always been silenced :(

i wonder that any of you comrades ever heard about this.

more about Munir (read=Mooneer):

Indonesian Murder Mistery (http://www.indonesia-house.org/focus/civ-society/2004/11/111604An_Indonesian_murder_mystery.htm)

Kontras (http://www.kontras.org/)

Knight of Cydonia
10th January 2007, 05:26
More about the case:

Munir’s Case in Chronological Order (http://www.kontras.org/munir/Kronologis_Kasus_Munir_eng.pdf)

i just want to know what my RevLeft comrades opinion on this case.

Delirium
10th January 2007, 18:26
I'm aware of indonesia's past history of abuses but i did not know of this in particular. do you have any good articles on the overall revolutionary situation in indonesia? I know there are many ethnic nationalists but are there any leftwing rebellion?

Knight of Cydonia
10th January 2007, 18:30
Originally posted by Delirium [email protected] 11, 2007 01:26 am
I know there are many ethnic nationalists but are there any leftwing rebellion?
yes there are, such as Indonesian communist party which had been banned in 1965, and Partai Rakyat Demokratik (Peoples Democratic Party) that had been banned (maybe) in 1998.

Now the one and last is Kontras (http://www.kontras.org/) which is the one that always been confronted with the government.

Dimentio
12th January 2007, 10:41
As far I'll see it, at least two countries are involved in this case. We could maybe see the Netherlands involved as well, but as Munir was confirmed dead in Singapore, maybe the Singaporean authorities - athough not likely - could be pursued to take up the case again. I do not trust the independence of the Indonesian court system in this case.

Knight of Cydonia
12th January 2007, 11:02
Originally posted by [email protected] 12, 2007 05:41 pm
As far I'll see it, at least two countries are involved in this case. We could maybe see the Netherlands involved as well, but as Munir was confirmed dead in Singapore, maybe the Singaporean authorities - athough not likely - could be pursued to take up the case again. I do not trust the independence of the Indonesian court system in this case.
i think the Singapore had nothing to do with this...hm..probably.
but i want to certain that Munir's not confirmed dead in Singapore, but the doctor said that Munir's time of death is when the plane still in the air.

Dimentio
12th January 2007, 11:04
Originally posted by knight of cydonia+January 12, 2007 11:02 am--> (knight of cydonia @ January 12, 2007 11:02 am)
[email protected] 12, 2007 05:41 pm
As far I'll see it, at least two countries are involved in this case. We could maybe see the Netherlands involved as well, but as Munir was confirmed dead in Singapore, maybe the Singaporean authorities - athough not likely - could be pursued to take up the case again. I do not trust the independence of the Indonesian court system in this case.
i think the Singapore had nothing to do with this...hm..probably.
but i want to certain that Munir's not confirmed dead in Singapore, but the doctor said that Munir's time of death is when the plane still in the air. [/b]
No, but since he died in Singapore, one option could be to hold the trial there, even though it may not be formally correct [is an Indonesian airplane a part of Indonesian territory or not is the question].

Brownfist
14th January 2007, 19:01
Knight of Cydonia, apa kabar? I used to live in Indonesia (6 years) and was actually involved peripherally in the anti-Suharto movement. I actually gained a lot of my political consciousness in Indonesia and was very heavily involved in the Indonesia punk scene. I like many have been very disappointed that the lives that were lost in 1998 for a free democratic Indonesia never came to fruition. This was especially due to the fact that there was not a real left consolidation at the time as both the PRD, PRK and Marxism in general was illegal. Also, I think that a lot of the Indonesian workers and students still believed that their problems could and would be addressed through democratic means and the leaders that many looked upoto was Megawati Sokarno-Putri and Amien Rais. There are several communist groupings in Indonesia now, particularly within the Trotskyist left. However, from what I understand they remin very marginal. Also, I believe that there is an anti-revisionist formation in Indonesia called Revindo which has strong ties to the CPP. What is needed in Indonesia is a return to the debate that was prematurely closed in 1998 and reformasi and revolusi.

Knight of Cydonia
14th January 2007, 21:26
Knight of Cydonia, apa kabar?

kabar baik.... :P (nice to see someone speak Indonesian here)


well, it is, a lot of Indonesian workers and students think that their problems or the indonesian problem is on the democratic system,but they were never protest properly. for exmple, for this Munir's injustice murder case...there is and there have been some action or protest, but no one in the government want to listen properly on what they're demand, i can't understand why.

And for that 1998 reformasi, it's totally failed...and i think what Indonesia needs for now is Revolution in every aspect.


There are several communist groupings in Indonesia now, particularly within the Trotskyist left.

i wonder why that i've never heard about them.

Brownfist
15th January 2007, 08:02
I completely agree. The reformasi movement was a complete failure and now we need revolusi. My friends died in Trisakti for movement that was sold out. Sure we got rid of Suharto but the system remained the same. All that happened was Gus Dur and Megawati took over and tried to restore the people's faith in the system. Today the groups that are of Trot background are tiny. Also, we need to remember that in Indonesia it is still illegal to be a communist of any stripe. What is needed in Indonesia is a serious summation of the failures of 1965, D.N. Aidit and Tan Malaka and co. and then the reformation of the PKI with a strong anti-revisionist basis. It needs to connect with the CPP in Philippines and other parties in South-Asia.

Knight of Cydonia
15th January 2007, 09:08
Originally posted by [email protected] 15, 2007 03:02 pm
I completely agree. The reformasi movement was a complete failure and now we need revolusi. My friends died in Trisakti for movement that was sold out. Sure we got rid of Suharto but the system remained the same. All that happened was Gus Dur and Megawati took over and tried to restore the people's faith in the system. Today the groups that are of Trot background are tiny. Also, we need to remember that in Indonesia it is still illegal to be a communist of any stripe. What is needed in Indonesia is a serious summation of the failures of 1965, D.N. Aidit and Tan Malaka and co. and then the reformation of the PKI with a strong anti-revisionist basis. It needs to connect with the CPP in Philippines and other parties in South-Asia.
yeah,indeed what's Indonesia need is Revolution.oh and about that Trisakti case, it's kind of similar to with Munir's case...it remain unsolved and full of injustice.and it seem no further action from the government concerning the Trisakti Tragedy.