Revolucion Compadre
17th August 2006, 10:46
I was just reading online, and came across some things people have said in other forums, and some things caught my attention.
As a person who is here to learn , i just wanted to share and see what you all made out of it.
1st guy wrote about why communism fails?:
1.) In Communism there is no will to work. Everyone is paid the same, you all share resources, so there is no point in working
2.) You will end up with a bunch of Janitors and no doctors. No one will go to school to be a doctor due to the fact they will be paid the same wage as a janitor. Of course then you ask "Doctors become doctors to help people". They wont want to go to school for 8 years of their life learning to become a doctor when they could have just started as a janitor, making money the entire time, not wasting their life away.
3.) People are infact greedy. Someone will always try and take control. And if this person gains control they will infact abuse the people (Stalin)
4.) People need someone telling them what to do. But in Communism they dont have that. You can deny this fact all you wish. But some people do not have the capacity to do something without being told.
5.) Communism is not even supposed to have a leader in the first place. So in reality there is no plausible goverment. And as the past has shown us, people who have tried Communism, end up with an abusive totalitarian government.
6.) Communism takes away freedom and individualism. And well people willinfact not allow this. Some people are natural born leaders. The people will revolt against the 'Communistic' goverment.
It was once said by John Kennedy "Conformity is the jailer of freedom and the enemy of growth." Communism infact tries to conform you. And that takes away your freedom. This is ont acceptable to people.
7.) Communism's main point is everyone will be equal. But in reality this is untrue. Some people are fine with being famers, helping the community. While others are greedy. They wish to make money for themselves only. Not for the good of the country. This is infact called human nature.
8.) In communism people dont have to work as hard as possible. Everyone is taken care of. If you dont work as hard as the guy next to you, you still get paid the same. You get a free ride, while the guy next to you, worked his butt off for the so called 'good of the community'. While in Caitalism if you dont work, you have no money, and therefor live on the street. This infact creates the motivation needed to work hard.
9.) Communism assumes everyone is nice, good, and smart. Well this is not true. Not everyone is of the same metal and physical capability. In communism the state owns everything. The money is theirs. So basically the smart people in the goverment get rich off of the unsmart people working for the 'good' of the state. It was once said "Power Corrupts" This is exactly what happens in Communism. Those in power abuse it and basically create a facist goverment....
2nd guy wrote something i found interesting but im not sure?:
Most of the stocks in US are presently owned by the workers (roughly 54%). It seems the workers own most of the businesses, without the dictatorship of the proletariat. Something Marx (dumbass hypocrite that he was) never envisioned
As a person who is here to learn , i just wanted to share and see what you all made out of it.
1st guy wrote about why communism fails?:
1.) In Communism there is no will to work. Everyone is paid the same, you all share resources, so there is no point in working
2.) You will end up with a bunch of Janitors and no doctors. No one will go to school to be a doctor due to the fact they will be paid the same wage as a janitor. Of course then you ask "Doctors become doctors to help people". They wont want to go to school for 8 years of their life learning to become a doctor when they could have just started as a janitor, making money the entire time, not wasting their life away.
3.) People are infact greedy. Someone will always try and take control. And if this person gains control they will infact abuse the people (Stalin)
4.) People need someone telling them what to do. But in Communism they dont have that. You can deny this fact all you wish. But some people do not have the capacity to do something without being told.
5.) Communism is not even supposed to have a leader in the first place. So in reality there is no plausible goverment. And as the past has shown us, people who have tried Communism, end up with an abusive totalitarian government.
6.) Communism takes away freedom and individualism. And well people willinfact not allow this. Some people are natural born leaders. The people will revolt against the 'Communistic' goverment.
It was once said by John Kennedy "Conformity is the jailer of freedom and the enemy of growth." Communism infact tries to conform you. And that takes away your freedom. This is ont acceptable to people.
7.) Communism's main point is everyone will be equal. But in reality this is untrue. Some people are fine with being famers, helping the community. While others are greedy. They wish to make money for themselves only. Not for the good of the country. This is infact called human nature.
8.) In communism people dont have to work as hard as possible. Everyone is taken care of. If you dont work as hard as the guy next to you, you still get paid the same. You get a free ride, while the guy next to you, worked his butt off for the so called 'good of the community'. While in Caitalism if you dont work, you have no money, and therefor live on the street. This infact creates the motivation needed to work hard.
9.) Communism assumes everyone is nice, good, and smart. Well this is not true. Not everyone is of the same metal and physical capability. In communism the state owns everything. The money is theirs. So basically the smart people in the goverment get rich off of the unsmart people working for the 'good' of the state. It was once said "Power Corrupts" This is exactly what happens in Communism. Those in power abuse it and basically create a facist goverment....
2nd guy wrote something i found interesting but im not sure?:
Most of the stocks in US are presently owned by the workers (roughly 54%). It seems the workers own most of the businesses, without the dictatorship of the proletariat. Something Marx (dumbass hypocrite that he was) never envisioned