How is Communi$m fundumentally flawed?

[I love Kylie]

It is no secret that communi$t regimes the world over have been in recent years collapsing like dominos his is no secret and I beleive that any communi$t regime will necessarily the toppled by their own people. I would like to see a capitalist people that has ever overthrown capitalism lol.

This is a fact you people must realise if there is to be any potential for discourse between one another and between captialists and communi$ts on this forum.

[BurnTheOliveTree]

But communism is necessarily popular, or there's no revolution. :huh:

And, as an aside, name a communist regime.

-Alex

[RaiseYourVoice]

It is no secret that communi$t regimes the world over have been in recent years collapsing like dominos
can you please.... read like 1-2 other opposing ideology posts before you beginn talking shit that has been discussed 150million times?


his is no secret and I beleive that any communi$t regime will necessarily the toppled by their own people.
luckily you dont even know what communism is so this is no critisism to anyone here


I would like to see a capitalist people that has ever overthrown capitalism lol.
ya since we all know communism appears out of nowhere and than gets overthrown by their own people... that gives a new view on history


This is a fact you people must realise if there is to be any potential for discourse between one another and between captialists and communi$ts on this forum.
you mean communists must realize that they are wrong to be converted by you?
thanks for enlightening us all we will immidiatly convert to capitalists and start exploiting our fellow workers

[RevSouth]

Wow, have you even read around the forums? Soviet Russia was state-capitalist more so than true communism. Other than the USSR and its satellite states, what countries are you talking about? Communism, or anarchism for that matter, should not take hold of one country, it needs to be all around the world. It seems to me as if as soon as a "Communist country" begins to trade with the cappies, it is corrupted. This goes back to the fact you need a worldwide revolution. While "communist countries" have been toppled by their people, I see it more as a byproduct of capitalist lies than of people's longing to be wage-slaves again. They think of America as a land of milk and honey. Truth is alot of people don't make it in capitalism. The United States has about 15% of its people living below the poverty line, which isn't something they broadcast over voice of America. After the collapse of the USSR, life expectancies rapidly dropped from eighty to fifty years.

Never heard of capitalist government being toppled, eh? How about Czarist Russia? Monarchist Spain became shaky when Anarchism took hold of its people. China? Cuba? Vietnam? Many third world countries governments have become radically leftist because of a revolution or radical reform. And god knows how many more would be if not from US interference.

[Forward Union]

We have to ask ourselves why they are unstable and fail to survive. And the answer is because they are a Paradox. Communism means a stateless, Classless society, with no hierarchy, national boundaries or money. So a communist Regime, or to put it differently, a stateless state, is a paradox, much like a square circle.

If such a thing existed, it would nullify the logic of reality.

[The Sloth]

Originally posted by I love [email protected] 12 2006, 02:47 PM
It is no secret that communi$t regimes the world over have been in recent years collapsing like dominos his is no secret and I beleive that any communi$t regime will necessarily the toppled by their own people. I would like to see a capitalist people that has ever overthrown capitalism lol.

This is a fact you people must realise if there is to be any potential for discourse between one another and between captialists and communi$ts on this forum.
there is no such thing as a communist regime.

it's either communism, or a regime. not both.

[red team]

Define regime.

If you think that at this point in history we can do without some sort of coordination of resources for large social projects and infrastructure, you're quite mistaken.

Administration for that sort of thing is still quite necessary. It will be a different kind of administration relying less on coercion and psychological threats to leave a person without the means to purchase goods necessary to satisfy physiological needs, but a "regime" nevertheless.

[Dr. Rosenpenis]

Originally posted by I love [email protected] 12 2006, 09:47 AM
It is no secret that communi$t regimes the world over have been in recent years collapsing like dominos his is no secret and I beleive that any communi$t regime will necessarily the toppled by their own people. I would like to see a capitalist people that has ever overthrown capitalism lol.

This is a fact you people must realise if there is to be any potential for discourse between one another and between captialists and communi$ts on this forum.
Realizing this user has been banned, I will reply to some points he made.
To begin with... advanced countries, capitalist or socialist, are seldom overthrown popularly. But there have been a few occurences. The overthrowal of Salazar in Portugal is the only one that comes to mind right now.

Most "communist regimes" have already been toppled... and it wasn't by "their own people".
In fact, I can't recall a single one that was.

I can't understand the rest of this user's post because his prose is sloppy and lacking in proper grammar.