Log in

View Full Version : Noam Chomsky



cubalibra
17th January 2006, 17:01
NOAM CHOMSKY:

"THERE IS NO WAR ON TERROR"



MIT professor Noam Chomsky is the world's most perceptive intellectual critic of U.S. Foreign policy. Among all political thinkers (including historical figures), none is more insightful than Professor Chomsky, who says in an interview with Geov Parrish from December 2005 on Alternet, posted today at http://www.alternet.org/story/30487/:

"The fact of the matter is that there is no War on Terror...

"It's a minor consideration. So invading Iraq and taking control of the world's energy resources was way more important than the threat of terror. And the same with other things. Take, say, nuclear terror. The American intelligence systems estimate that the likelihood of a "dirty bomb," a dirty nuclear bomb attack in the United States in the next ten years, is about 50 percent. Well, that's pretty high. Are they doing anything about it? Yeah. They're increasing the threat, by increasing nuclear proliferation, by compelling potential adversaries to take very dangerous measures to try to counter rising American threats.

"This is even sometimes discussed. You can find it in the strategic analysis literature. Take, say, the invasion of Iraq again. We're told that they didn't find weapons of mass destruction. Well, that's not exactly correct. They did find weapons of mass destruction, namely, the ones that had been sent to Saddam by the United States, Britain, and others through the 1980s. A lot of them were still there. They were under control of U.N. inspectors and were being dismantled. But many were still there. When the U.S. invaded, the inspectors were kicked out, and Rumsfeld and Cheney didn't tell their troops to guard the sites. So the sites were left unguarded, and they were systematically looted. The U.N. inspectors did continue their work by satellite and they identified over 100 sites that were systematically looted, like, not somebody going in and stealing something, but carefully, systematically looted."

JKP
17th January 2006, 23:55
I like how they pimp Chomsky as if he is some sort of god, while us mere "mortal" leftists have been saying the same shit for centuries.

Additionally, his support for Kerry is repugnant.

Commie Rat
18th January 2006, 01:24
It is the same with Journo's that write award-winning articles about the 2000 election (think Micheal Moore), Americas support of the Taliban during the cold war, the lack of WMD's in Iraq, the tortue and abuse of POW, when we were completly disregarded on the subject year before

bolshevik butcher
18th January 2006, 16:37
A rather uninspiring article although all true, it has all been said here many times before.

jaster
18th January 2006, 20:13
in defense of chomsky, i saw him speak at gonzaga university (spokane washignton, USA) and he is a wondeful poingant speaker.

bolshevik butcher
18th January 2006, 21:30
He's good at criticizing imperialism, I must hand him that. However he has his pseduo intelectual moments and when it comes to writing his own theries he isn't hte best in my view. He's not a marx or lenin.

PRC-UTE
19th January 2006, 01:14
Originally posted by [email protected] 18 2006, 12:11 AM
I like how they pimp Chomsky as if he is some sort of god, while us mere "mortal" leftists have been saying the same shit for centuries.

Additionally, his support for Kerry is repugnant.
You're essentially correct, comrade, but this piece by Chomsky is decent. I think he's a good analyst of bourgeois policy but as you say just useless as an advocate of resistance.

Tormented by Treachery
19th January 2006, 13:38
And anybody who is spreading the word as rapidly and effectively as Chomsky is a friend of mine.

bolshevik butcher
19th January 2006, 15:52
How effective is chomskey. I dont know of anyone thats been drawn to the left by him. Only existing leftists that read his works.

Don't Change Your Name
19th January 2006, 16:18
Originally posted by [email protected] 17 2006, 09:11 PM
I like how they pimp Chomsky as if he is some sort of god, while us mere "mortal" leftists have been saying the same shit for centuries.

Additionally, his support for Kerry is repugnant.
Well, there's an obvious benefit for the "right wing": if Chomsky makes a mistake they'll be able to point it out quickly and discredit "the left" in "most people"'s eyes.

Soheran
19th January 2006, 18:12
Originally posted by Clenched [email protected] 19 2006, 04:08 PM
How effective is chomskey. I dont know of anyone thats been drawn to the left by him. Only existing leftists that read his works.
I was. I know of others.

Well, I wasn't really "drawn to the left" by him, I've always been left-wing, but reading Chomsky is one of the things that made me a radical.

In fact I would go as far as to say that Noam Chomsky is among the most effective of the leftist intellectuals. He is non-dogmatic and extremely intelligent, and it shows in his argumentation.