Log in

View Full Version : Animal rights activists and Woodland Wild Boar



James
4th January 2006, 14:51
I would appreciate to hear what people think of this issue which has developed over the past few days.

Basically, 100 boar have escaped from Woodland Wild Boar farm after an animal rights "raid" (assuming this was an actual raid).

Personally i can't see the logic behind this decision to take action. Destroying battery chickens; yes. But setting "free" free range animals? Especially dangerous ones (they come under the 'Dangerous Wild Animals Act 1976 (Modification) Order 1984') which are going to have to be recovered, or shot. One has already been found dead, with its lower jaw having been removed as a "trophy".

I think as it stands 40 have been recovered, and a 100 man hunt, made up of local farmers, has now started to try and catch others. The owner (Alan Dedames) is very skeptical that they will be succsful (he'll eat his hat....). Some have been spotted 30 miles away from the farm. Also, over 90% of the females are pregnant. Dedames now thinks that the area is going to have a natural population for "decades".

I'm not convinced by Dedames pessimisim and predictions (even though he is an expert on them). I really don't see the point behind this animal rights action though. It just seems counter-productive. Indeed, as the dead jawless boar testifies: was it in the best interests of the boar to be released?

Alexknucklehead
4th January 2006, 17:39
I can't see the logic behind any AR actions, and this one seems as stupid and badly thought out as most others.

LuĂ­s Henrique
4th January 2006, 18:07
Originally posted by [email protected] 4 2006, 03:02 PM
was it in the best interests of the boar to be released?
No. Boars have no interests.

Luís Henrique

James
4th January 2006, 20:22
How do you know? You arn't a boar :P

No no no, i was of course using the justification that is used by many animal rights activists. Indeed the name itself, "animal rights", hints at such assumed interests.




To me it just seems like the whole affair has caused stress to many involved, disrupted many people trying to work (i.e. live), and has also seemed to cause more suffering for the boars.

James
5th January 2006, 17:27
"the people who let them out say they are animal liberators, but they will all end up shot dead if we don't recapture them. how can they call that liberty?"

Said yesterday by Dedames.


Seems the hunt got one or two (back to the farm) and thats it. But further hunts are planned.

James
5th January 2006, 18:15
no i was wrong.
One has returned.

James
14th February 2006, 19:35
the news today claimed that it has just happened again to the same farm.

Dooga Aetrus Blackrazor
18th February 2006, 20:07
Has anyone confirmed that an animal rights group is doing this? It sounds more like the work of someone trying to tarnish the image of such groups. Regardless, such beliefs do not reflect all animal rights supporters.

which doctor
18th February 2006, 20:15
Originally posted by Luís Henrique+Jan 4 2006, 01:34 PM--> (Luís Henrique @ Jan 4 2006, 01:34 PM)
[email protected] 4 2006, 03:02 PM
was it in the best interests of the boar to be released?
No. Boars have no interests.

Luís Henrique [/b]
That's what the plantation owners once said about their slaves.

YSR
18th February 2006, 23:18
If it really was animal rights activists, I would...

I dunno, keep my opinion the same, I guess. My opinion of animal rights activists is okay, but I really wish the radical left-wing could disassociate ourselves from them. No offense to any AR people here, but I think part (not all, nowhere near all) of the reason that the vast majority working class is alienated from our thinking is because our closeness with animal rights activists.

somebodywhowantedtoleaveandnotcomeback
19th February 2006, 01:15
Originally posted by [email protected] 4 2006, 09:49 PM
How do you know? You arn't a boar :P
Isn't he, James? Isn't he?

Severian
20th February 2006, 00:18
Also, of course: if the animals do survive, it may be harmful to the local environment. As with the release of North American mink in Britain.

chimx
18th March 2006, 10:01
you can't release animals into inappropriate bioregions. they will just starve to death more often than not. activities like this make me sad. its just an excuse for reactionary assholes (like some in this thread) to needlessly attack those supporting animal lib.