Would you kill...

[Ol' Dirty]

If one of your freinds or family memebrs were against a revolution, and one was coming up, would you kill them?

Personally, I'd just stop talking to them. It's not worth the trouble. But if we were in a battle, or something like that I would.

[Goatse]

Of course not!

Unless they actually fought along with other counter-revolutionaries, but even then maybe not.

[Ol' Dirty]

Right.

[Rockfan]

Na I couldn't aye, but any recationary bastard I didn't know better watch out.

[Ol' Dirty]

I'm glad so many people feel similarly!

You do realize that being reactionary isn't always so bad right? I mean, If the first thing you say when you hear "George Bush" is "FUCK HIM!", that's not so bad. :lol:

Of course, I joke.

Peace.

[Rockfan]

Originally posted by [email protected] 2 2006, 04:14 PM
You do realize that being reactionary isn't always so bad right? I mean, If the first thing you say when you hear "George Bush" is "FUCK HIM!", that's not so bad. :lol:


Ha but it's also what people say when they hear "communist".

[Ol' Dirty]

<_< Good point.

[Global_Justice]

i would kill for the revolution, but only in the extremist circumstance and it was absolutely necassary.

but i wouldn&#39;t kill my family :blink:

[Led Zeppelin]

If one of your freinds or family memebrs were against a revolution, and one was coming up, would you kill them?

Personally, I&#39;d just stop talking to them.

:lol:

This perfectly demonstrates the mentality of western "Communists", "when the shit hits the fan just stop talking to them&#33;".

[Enragé]

I would, but only if i knew for sure they couldnt be convinced to join us, and if it really is necessary. same goes for any other reactionary

"This perfectly demonstrates the mentality of western "Communists", "when the shit hits the fan just stop talking to them&#33;". "

im a western commie

[Led Zeppelin]

When I say "western Communists" I don&#39;t mean all Communists in the west, I mean those who adhere to the ideology of "western Communism", for an example of such a party see the CPUSA.

[Enragé]

ah

wimpy wannabe-ish annoying reactionary semi-parliamentary-communism? :P

[Noah]

My family n relatives are all communist/socialist (except my mum).

I couldn&#39;t shoot my relatives...can&#39;t I just send them to like the Isle of Man and make it a counter-revolutionary prison, then A-bomb it :D. (joke)

[which doctor]

If they shot at me then I&#39;d spray some led their direction.

[Kamerat Voldstad]

Originally posted by Marxism&#045;[email protected] 2 2006, 01:49 PM
This perfectly demonstrates the mentality of western "Communists", "when the shit hits the fan just stop talking to them&#33;".
Oh yeah.

I say: send them to Sibir&#33; And let the reactionary liberalist oppressive bastards try to create something together&#33; Wouldn&#39;t that be interesting?

Anyway.

I would kill whom I have to to defend the people&#39;s liberation and the victory of justice - but if someone is not supporting us or the enemy, he/she/it is a potential ally and a potential foe, therefore we should be selective in our revolutionary killings: depriving someone of their life is a thing done of necessity. I mean, after all they have rights too - as long as they don&#39;t contribute to the oppression of others.

What relations we have to a person should not affect whether or not we kill that person.

[Ol' Dirty]

What about your girl/boyfreind (I know most of you are straight male, but I don&#39;t want to discriminate)?

Again, I&#39;d just break up with them; after all, there are more fish in the sea&#33;

But if the ***** try ta stab me, we playin&#39; diffrent game&#33;

Just joking... :lol:

Or am I? :huh:

Peace

[Ol' Dirty]

I&#39;m going to make a poll out of htis too.

[Led Zeppelin]

What about your girl/boyfreind

Fuck them, they are mostly idiots to begin with anyway (unless of course in the rare circumstance that you have a Communist girl/boyfriend), and yes you&#39;re right; "there&#39;s plenty more fish in the sea".

I realize that this might be "hard" and "not nice" to a person who is "madly in love", but believe me, you&#39;ll get over that crap and start to see clearly and logically again, I know you will choose revolution over "love".

[Enragé]

at the risk of being a sentimental fuck

but the revolution IS love

[Led Zeppelin]

Yes, love for the people as a whole, not the love for one person.

And I was referring to the latter.

[Enragé]

yes but that also means you cannot choose the revolution over love, you cannot choose love over love because both are love, regardless to whom it is aimed. In essence, whatever you do in the name of the love for the people as a whole cannot overshadow the love for one person.

You cannot love the whole if you set aside love for a part of it.

its hard to bring to words what i mean..

[Led Zeppelin]

its hard to bring to words what i mean..

More like impossible, because what you say doesn&#39;t make sense, loving the people as a whole and loving just one person are two different things.

For example; when you love the people as a whole, that is, when you work for the people as a whole you do other things than you do when you love just one person, for that one person you buy stuff, for the people as a whole you get active in the Communist movement.

The above was just an example of course, but you get the point.

[Comrade Yastrebkov]

Originally posted by [email protected] 2 2006, 01:20 AM
If one of your freinds or family memebrs were against a revolution, and one was coming up, would you kill them?

Personally, I&#39;d just stop talking to them. It&#39;s not worth the trouble. But if we were in a battle, or something like that I would.
What a weird question&#33; :blink: You could have phrased that in a more mature manner. "Unless we were in a battle or something then I would". Wtf man?&#33;

[Tekun]

If it came down to it, if they were shooting at me, hell yeah I would

If my fam joined the counter revolutionary ranks, I would refuse to acknowledge them as my fam, despite being blood related
And my family would become the poor, the peasants, the workers, the discriminated, and the colonized...
My brothers and sisters would be the comrades fighting alongside

Good thing my immediate family has a leftist ideology

[VictoryOverWar]

unlike most of the posters in this thread i work toward change for my family.

[Tekun]

Originally posted by [email protected] 7 2006, 03:25 AM
unlike most of the posters in this thread i work toward change for my family.
I wonder how u would be able to accomplish this while they&#39;re shooting at u, or "ratting" u out to the bourgoisie authorities, bro?

[Storming Heaven]

Woa, now the shit really hits the fan&#33;


unlike most of the posters in this thread i work toward change for my family.

An excellent way of looking at it&#33;


I wonder how u would be able to accomplish this while they&#39;re shooting at u, or "ratting" u out to the bourgoisie authorities, bro?

As in any situation, I&#39;d use force to defend myself if necessary. Personally, I don&#39;t think I could kill my family (with the exception of immediate self-defence), but if they refused to accept the revolution, I don&#39;t know if I could protect them from it, but I might warn them of it&#39;s coming.

[Ol' Dirty]

If it were my girlfreind, I wouldn&#39;t worry about it too much. I tend to hang out with pretty radical people anyway. And if she disagreed with me, I&#39;d simply talk to her about it, telling her that Communism is the political theory that all wealth should be shared amongst the group, and that capitalism is basicaly the theory that people should keep the money they earn and use it for themselves.

[Ownthink]

I wouldn&#39;t hesitate to kill an armed enemy of the Revolution, reguardless of their "status" in my life. They are killing to hurt or stop your views, so why not kill to end theirs.

[Aurora]

I totally agree with Ownthink :ph34r:

[Ol' Dirty]

Originally posted by [email protected] 7 2006, 07:59 PM
I wouldn&#39;t hesitate to kill an armed enemy of the Revolution, reguardless of their "status" in my life. They are killing to hurt or stop your views, so why not kill to end theirs.
There is no such thing as "the" revolution. There have been, and will be, many revolutions.

[drain.you]

Never really thought about it but imagine if the press got a hold of this thread
&#39;Brainwashed Internet Users say they would kill their own family for the greater good of Communism&#39; lol.
Saying that, I wouldn&#39;t just open fire on my relatives for being against the revolution. If a revolution came, I would tell them to leave. If they shot at me or my comrades then I would have to retaliate.

[Iroquois Xavier]

If needs be then yes i would kill. but only if my life was in 100% danger.if it was a nazi then of course i would&#33; I hate Nazis. Viva La Revolucion&#33;

[cccpcommie]

uncle paulie? oh hes done..lol :D

[Glasgow]

I think the real question is who is willing to give there life for the pepole.

[Red Flag Rising]

Hell yes, I&#39;d do it without even having to think about it.

You&#39;re either a revolutionary or you&#39;re not.

[Fidel Follower]

NOAH you better be joking, i LIKE the isle of man...lol.
Keep it red, and when i mean read i mean the red blood of the capies&#33; Yeah down with the anti-revolutionaries, we could not talk to ALL the anti-revolutionaries that will show em&#33; Of course im joking, but capies need a good seeing to&#33; :hammer:

[Niemand]

I see everyone as my family and because I see everyone that way I will always talk to them first, I would try to make them realize how we think and try to turn them to our cause. However if they shot at me or any other of my brothers or sisters then I would undoubtedly shoot them down.

It&#39;s an entirely different situation if the Proletariat is in power already and the Cappies are simply speaking their minds, if that is the case then we should let them speak their minds and let the people know what their ideology says. It will not bring people to Capitalism because if people know what Capitalism, Socialism, and Communism are they (this is assuming they are sane and intelligent) they will always side with Socialism and Communism.

[Vladislav]

If someone said "Stupid fucking useles communist pig" I&#39;d spit in their face and shoot them. If it was a family member I would just shoot them in the leg and leave them.
For communism to work there must be human sacrifice. If a revolution ever happens(and I hope it will) then many lives will be lost from both sides, but no matter how many close friends you have lost, remember you are fighting for a good cause.