Log in

View Full Version : Yale sacks Rebel Professor



Free Palestine
27th October 2005, 01:07
http://www.guardian.co.uk/usa/story/0,12271,1599828,00.html


Protests at Yale over sacking of rebel professor

Jamie Wilson in Washington
Tuesday October 25, 2005
The Guardian

An anarchist anthropology professor described as one of the brightest minds in his field has become a cause célèbre for student union activists at Yale after the university decided not to renew his contract.

The treatment of David Graeber, who belongs to the Industrial Workers of the World union and has been arrested during anti-globalisation protests, has sparked a letter-writing campaign from professors around the world, while more than 4,000 people have signed an online petition accusing the Ivy League university of letting politics influence the hiring of staff.

"It's extremely odd that one of the most brilliant anthropologists is being excluded from the department at Yale in such an extraordinary fashion," Maurice Bloch, an anthropologist at the London School of Economics who wrote to Yale, told Associated Press.

Yale has refused to explain why the anthropology department did not renew his contract. Mr Graeber told AP that during a six-year review he was given a short-term contract after colleagues expressed concerns about his late turning in of grades and coming late to class.

Mr Graeber, 44, who wears combat trousers to class and lives in the same New York City cooperative where he grew up, said his problems at Yale began after he took a year's sabbatical in 2001. While on leave he joined anarchist groups and attended anti-war and anti-globalisation protests.

His high regard for himself and disdain for colleagues may also have contributed, he said: "I'm both more productive intellectually than they are and I'm having more fun. It must drive them crazy," he told AP.

Amusing Scrotum
27th October 2005, 01:13
while more than 4,000 people have signed an online petition accusing the Ivy League university of letting politics influence the hiring of staff.


Does anyone know where we can find this petition?

which doctor
27th October 2005, 01:18
I wish my teachers were anarchist and wore combat trouseres to school.

Tekun
27th October 2005, 01:23
Originally posted by Fist of [email protected] 27 2005, 01:02 AM
I wish my teachers were anarchist and wore combat trouseres to school.
x2

Intelligence is a threat to the status quo, thats why they fired him
Im not surprised seeing how the majority of Yale's income comes from the pockets of the elite and tha politicians

barret
27th October 2005, 05:33
In a way Yale does have a point, what if they had some radical right ring hard-core christian (which would probably never happen, especially in biological related science fields) telling all of the students the great wonderful things that come from murder and exploitation? But firing him is a little harsh, it seems more plausible for them to put him on probation, so that the next time he uses politics in class, he would get some sort of punishment.

bolshevik butcher
27th October 2005, 16:29
He's not a racist though, he's not discriminatory, so whats the problem. In that case it would be acceptable to sack someone because they were a libreal or a conservative.

Yeh i wish my teachers were a bit more like that as well.

barret
27th October 2005, 19:48
Originally posted by Clenched [email protected] 27 2005, 12:13 PM
He's not a racist though, he's not discriminatory, so whats the problem. In that case it would be acceptable to sack someone because they were a libreal or a conservative.

Yeh i wish my teachers were a bit more like that as well.
It wasn't because he was an anarchist, it was because he throughly displayed it in his classes. Almost every school has an agreement saying the a professor or teacher can't voice his political, religious and other views in class.

Free Palestine
27th October 2005, 19:58
Where in the article does it say he did those things?

Ownthink
27th October 2005, 20:03
Originally posted by barret+Oct 27 2005, 03:32 PM--> (barret @ Oct 27 2005, 03:32 PM)
Clenched [email protected] 27 2005, 12:13 PM
He's not a racist though, he's not discriminatory, so whats the problem. In that case it would be acceptable to sack someone because they were a libreal or a conservative.

Yeh i wish my teachers were a bit more like that as well.
It wasn't because he was an anarchist, it was because he throughly displayed it in his classes. Almost every school has an agreement saying the a professor or teacher can't voice his political, religious and other views in class. [/b]
This is a fucking joke.


It is impossible to teach essentially Politics without your own slant. In my History book, it is Pro America and Pro Imperialist, it also labels everyone who valiantly opposes America and its interests as a "terrorist".

I'm betting it would be different if I was the teacher.

bolshevik butcher
27th October 2005, 20:43
I bet if he was eno-con no aciton would be taken.

barret
27th October 2005, 23:54
Originally posted by [email protected] 27 2005, 03:47 PM

This is a fucking joke.


It is impossible to teach essentially Politics without your own slant. In my History book, it is Pro America and Pro Imperialist, it also labels everyone who valiantly opposes America and its interests as a "terrorist".

I'm betting it would be different if I was the teacher.
First off, he did not teach politics, he taught anthropology, thus his political views should have not been displayed,unless he dealth with social anthropology, but thats more focused on cultures.

Also being biased politically is subjective, besides some obvious biases such as Fox News and CNN, there are some that are refutable such as the New York Times. It is considered to be a left- biased paper, but I bet if you ask any liberal they would disagree.

Free Palestine
28th October 2005, 01:23
Barret, once again: Where in the article does it say he was proselytizing about his views in class?

Tekun
28th October 2005, 09:24
This is almost the same type of sht that they're doing to Ward Churchill over in Colorado

If ya don't know about him:
Ward Churchill (http://www.kersplebedeb.com/mystuff/s11/churchill.html)

barret
28th October 2005, 22:49
Originally posted by Free [email protected] 27 2005, 09:07 PM
Barret, once again: Where in the article does it say he was proselytizing about his views in class?
I was writing in reguards to this :

iQUOTE (Clenched Fist @ Oct 27 2005, 12:13 PM)
He's not a racist though, he's not discriminatory, so whats the problem. In that case it would be acceptable to sack someone because they were a libreal or a conservative.

Yeh i wish my teachers were a bit more like that as well.

It wasn't because he was an anarchist, it was because he throughly displayed it in his classes. Almost every school has an agreement saying the a professor or teacher can't voice his political, religious and other views in class.

The article did say that he dress in the certain fashion.

Then I was arguing about the political teachings :


This is a fucking joke.


It is impossible to teach essentially Politics without your own slant. In my History book, it is Pro America and Pro Imperialist, it also labels everyone who valiantly opposes America and its interests as a "terrorist".

I'm betting it would be different if I was the teacher.

Free Palestine
28th October 2005, 23:31
I may be wrong, but the article made a point to mention he was only vocal about his beliefs while on leave. I don't think he preached his views in class.