Log in

View Full Version : By way of introduction



Nachie
23rd September 2005, 15:52
To all participants in this forum,

I am a Brazilian citizen of American residence, travelling around the country with variable frequency and hopefully making trips back to Brazil and Venezuela for the WSF later this year and early in the next. My nome de guerre is Nachie, which is an affectionate shorthand for "Anachronist".

I first became a communist in 2000 after reading Orwell's masterpiece, Homage to Catalonia. The issue was of incredible interest to me because my great grandfather had fought in the Spanish revolution as an anarchist. I promptly became involved with the Communist Party USA, simply because of an ignorance at what the available options were. Through the CP I learned a lot about union organizing and grassroots solidarity, (the party at this point runs almost entirely on the mutual aid of its working-class membership) but my theoretical self-education continued to come primarily out of Trotskyist literature.

Between 2001 and 2002 I became more and more exposed to anarchist and anti-Leninist writing, in particular Ron Tabor's masterpiece "A Look at Leninism". I had simply never seen these opinions before and faced with them, I could not deny their validity. Through a series of coincidental meetings over the Internet I picked up a capable number of "tutors" who were very willing to take me through the paces of what an actual Marxist analysis would look like when unchained by Leninist totalitarianism. My understanding of communism deepened immensely and without this change in ideology I never would have been able to get as much done as I have.

In 2002 I founded with a Montana anarchist the Red & Anarchist Action Network (RAAN) - http://www.redanarchist.org which continues to be the channel for my radical activity. In a personal capacity I have worked construction and volunteer food preparation for a number of community centers and homeless advocacy groups around the East Coast. Through exasperation at the sheer size of the problem I gave up dialoguing with Leninists several years ago, and have had several confrontations with them ever since. Although as a communist I operate outside the anarchist and anarchopunk circles, through RAAN I have attained many allies there and together we have embarked on a number of projects, usually geared towards sustainable (or even temporary) solutions to living in capitalism. This would include food scams, housing scams, and most importantly for the network's survival, mutual aid. We are committed to organizing for action and make moves whenever the possibility presents itself, as in the case of relief for Hurricane Katrina, but primarily we are involved in a fight to sustain ourselves and then extend that opportunity to our comrades, so that then a greater number of us can organize fulltime.

I don't have the time or patience for the kind of discussions on this forum, as I've been involved in such things for nearly five years now and - as reflected in the principles of RAAN - have not been convinced of the utility of dialoguing with Leninist communities. Nevertheless I see this place as a great resource and hopefully I'll be stopping by more often and maybe sticking my thoughts in here or there...

OleMarxco
23rd September 2005, 17:53
Finally, another Anarchist. We need to lay fire on those Leninist's. Although I am not purely Anarchist - I am Communist/Anarchist (Nothing against Trotskyist's internationality, but don't forget they're still Lenin-inspired!), although I know and consider it's a same thang, people have for some reason differed it (It's just presented as different) I choose to combine it. But I'll not get in a discussion - I'll visit your site. And I bought "The Capital" today..grudginly. Well, I have to make up for that with a few coin-stealin' from Corporation's again, don't I? :marx:

Suggestion for you to visit;
A Rather Dubious but Interestin' Site (http://www.CrimethInc.com)

Non-Sectarian Bastard!
23rd September 2005, 18:30
He man welcome. It's nice to have an active comrade around.

Nachie
23rd September 2005, 18:37
Hey man,

Thanks for the link. We've been dealing with CrimethInc. (insofar as it could be described as a body to be dealt with) ever since their humble beginnings. I was inspired by "Days of War..." but really offput by the individualist implications of "Evasion". I have yet to read the new one "Recipes..." but I have high hopes for it. Members of RAAN participated in the big distros of "Fighting for Our Lives" several years back, as I'm pretty sure did everyone else...

My concern with CrimethInc. is that it bases itself far too heavily on the punk/hardcore scene and this brings about many problems and limitations, few of which - to their credit - they've not at least acknowledged. As a propaganda body they're startlingly effective though, even if only in redistributing other people's ideas. The problem this brings up is that people see it as an end unto itself, and then absorb themselves in this idealized community without any actual structures for action. This is primarily what we're trying to counter in RAAN, though we still base plenty of our tradition on the CrimethInc.'ers, travel culture, dumpster-diving, etc.

The other thing that really puts me off about CrimethInc. (as a Marxist) is that they're so obsessively anti-communist. As tends to be the case with anarchist groups, this is hammered in consistently in their literature but usually isn't represented in the more nuanced views of their individual "membership". Particularly ironic is that CrimethInc. is essentially just a rehash/punk update of the Situationist International, which was one of the most theoretically cohesive Marxist groups in history. In fact the entirety of anarchism is in a bit of a catch-22 over this, since they inevitably wish to claim the SI's legacy but have to quietly avoid the fact that they were a bunch of commies.

Good luck with Capital, but be careful since it's an incredibly dense thing and most people give up well before finishing it. If you insist on soldiering on, try taking notes from time to time in order to explain to yourself what you think Marx is saying, and be prepared to read paragraphs and even individual sentences multiple times just to figure them out.

A couple vital texts that might be easier to get through:

+ Beasts of Burden: Capitalism - Animals - Communism (http://www.geocities.com/CapitolHill/Lobby/3909/beasts/index.html)
+ Eclipse and Re-Emergence of the Communist Movement (http://www.geocities.com/CapitolHill/Lobby/3909/etoc.html)
+ An Interview with Harry Cleaver (http://www.geocities.com/CapitolHill/3843/cleaver.html)

"Eclipse and Re-Emergence" in particular might just be the best book I've ever read, certainly about communism. Also see Guy Debord's Society of the Spectacle (http://www.nothingness.org/SI/debord.html), the invaluable piece of communist litany (often called the "Capital" of the XX century) for a look into the inspirations behind CrimethInc. as well as the book/movie "Fight Club".

Happy hunting!

Oh, and PS: I've started a thread about the group I'm involved with HERE (http://www.revolutionaryleft.com/index.php?showtopic=40727) for anyone who's interested. We never ever ask for money and we never ever ask you to sign up for some sort of "membership", we're just interested in making people talk about the practical issues of anti-authoritarian organization/action.

OleMarxco
24th September 2005, 09:31
Oh yeah, and a few smashing of burgerouise windows, yah? :P That seems alot. Hardly I ever get such a trough-out answer. Oh well, good luck - and renember, Prole.Info (http://www.Prole.Info) is up again ;)

(Of course CrimethInc. is very "punky", but they can be changed from within. They must not forget, that there's a difference between "Communist" and Communist, because the latter is just as an Anarchist, only presented otherwise...and that they take a more invidual-look than a worker-look. But it's all the same. I've no problem with the book, it's just thick, which could be an advantage if someone disagrees with it. Bong'em in're head...SMOCK! I read quite loosely, picking up which trails I can grasp)