Log in

View Full Version : On Unity with Progressive Religious Forces



Andrei Kuznetsov
23rd August 2005, 10:25
RELIGION AND UNITY-STRUGGLE-UNITY WITH PROGRESSIVE RELIGIOUS FORCES
by Bob Avakian, Chairman of the Revolutionary Communist Party, USA

Revolution #012, August 21, 2005, posted at http://revcom.us/

EDITORS' NOTE: This is part of a series of excerpts on various subjects--drawn from conversations and discussions, as well as more formal talks, by Bob Avakian--which we will be running in this newspaper over the next period of time. This has been edited for publication.

Within the fight against the juggernaut--the rolling monster of war and repression, driven forward by the Bush regime--and including the growing "fascistization" (growing repression of an essentially fascist nature and even developments toward outright fascist rule) there is the whole question of the battle around morality: against traditional morality and Christian Fascism, around the question of homosexuality, around the question of women and in particular abortion, around the question of separation of church and state, and so on. We need to play a much greater role in the ideological and also in the political battle around this, in the battle around public opinion and in important political struggles in these spheres.

We need to be intervening in and carrying out a process of unity-struggle-unity with a great diversity of people around this whole realm of morality and values. As part of this, we need to increase exponentially and in multiplying ways our work with religious forces. We need to be working with them in general anyway, but we also need to work with them specifically in terms of maximizing their role in, first of all really coming to grips with, and second of all battling against Christian Fascism. One of the interesting things that happened after a talk I gave on religion ("Christianity and Society--The Old Testament, The New Testament, Christian Fascism, Social Change and Revolution," available in audio at bobavakian.net) was that, after this talk, one of these progressive religious people made the comment: "I kind of get this point on unity-struggle-unity, because it's working on me." [laughter]

There was also an interesting exchange where I was talking with another important and influential progressive clergyman who does work in the prisons. At one point, I asked him, "What is it you do there?" And he explained that what he is trying to do, in basic terms, is to get people to move from things like Pentecostalism and similar fundamentalist versions of Christianity to a more thinking Christianity. So I asked: "How are you doing?" [laughter]He answered: "I'm making some progress, I see some results." So I said, "Well, that's good."

Now, that is probably not the response you would expect from a stereotypical dogmatic communist. But the point is, yes, I have had, and hopefully will continue to have, some good discussion and struggle with people like this about a communist as opposed to a religious worldview--and, in talks I have given, which some of these progressive religious people have heard, I have hammered at the religious scriptures and put forward atheism quite boldly and strongly--but I am very interested in the question of how, from their own viewpoint, progressive religious people like this can wage and contribute to the overall struggle against the Christian Fascists. We have a role to play, including through struggle waged in a good way, to help and enable these people to maximize their own positive aspect and their contributions to the overall struggle. Yes, we should struggle with them ideologically, but most of them are not going to be won to communism, certainly not in an immediate framework, so we need to continue to have dialogue with them, we have to learn from them--there are important things we can learn from them--and at the same time we have to try to enable them to play the most positive role they can play in the struggle.

These progressive clergy and other progressive religious people need to have meetings with other people like themselves, they need to "go on the road," they need to engage this question of fascism, particularly Christian Fascism--they need to challenge it, they need to attack it--they need to recognize, first of all, what a grave danger it is posing to society and to everything that they stand for, as well as the future of humanity in the largest sense. We need to be working--uniting and struggling--in a good way with these people. If we can apply the correct method and approach to this, and unite with and help unleash other forces on the basis of applying this method and approach, then (if you'll pardon the expression) it will be possible to "achieve miracles" in transforming the political terrain and the political terms of things, with regard to the fascist, and specifically the Christian Fascist, danger in particular, and more generally in terms of the whole direction of society (and ultimately the world overall).



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This article is posted in English and Spanish on Revolution Online
http://revcom.us
Write: Box 3486, Merchandise Mart, Chicago, IL 60654
Phone: 773-227-4066 Fax: 773-227-4497

redstar2000
23rd August 2005, 16:39
Originally posted by Avakian
As part of this, we need to increase exponentially and in multiplying ways our work with religious forces. We need to be working with them in general anyway, but we also need to work with them specifically in terms of maximizing their role in, first of all really coming to grips with, and second of all battling against Christian Fascism.

What Avakian never seems to consider about this issue is why Christians would ever be opposed to Christian fascism in a serious way at all!

All prominent (and many not so prominent) Christians would materially benefit from Christian fascism. Sure, there'd be a denominational squabble over the loot...that's just "part of the game".

But only a few liberal Christian academics would stand to actually lose anything...and even they could repent and probably be re-admitted to the "elect".

Muslims and Wiccans, etc. would get the shaft, of course, and even Jews might see the revival of "quota systems" in some contexts. (In the Christian fascist paradigm, all Jews are "supposed" to return to Israel -- and the Christians might well apply some forceful persuasion in that direction.)

But all in all, I don't understand where Avakian thinks these "progressive Christians" are going to come from...or why they won't cave in to the Christian fascists at the first serious challenge.

Can you imagine any "liberal Christian" getting up in public and saying in a firm tone of voice, "The Christian fascists are not only anti-Christian but they deserve to burn in Hell!"???


Now, that is probably not the response you would expect from a stereotypical dogmatic communist.

No...but I'd expect it from someone who was trying to suck up to Christianity.


I am very interested in the question of how, from their own viewpoint, progressive religious people like this can wage and contribute to the overall struggle against the Christian Fascists.

Try telling them that the Christian fascists will cut into their market share.


These progressive clergy and other progressive religious people need to have meetings with other people like themselves, they need to "go on the road," they need to engage this question of fascism, particularly Christian Fascism--they need to challenge it, they need to attack it--they need to recognize, first of all, what a grave danger it is posing to society and to everything that they stand for, as well as the future of humanity in the largest sense.

Why do you think they don't do that now?

First of all, they don't think that Christian fascism poses any real threat to their place in society.

Secondly, the "future of humanity" is "in God's hands".

So why should they "go on the road" to fight it?

It's not really in their interests to make Christianity "look bad"...it looks bad enough as it is. One-third of the adult population of the U.S. is "unchurched"...not a member of any organized religious group.

If anyone needs to be organized to fight Christian fascism, there's your potential constituency!

Trying to locate and mobilize Christians to fight against Christian fascism is like looking for German anti-semites in 1930 who just detested the Nazis. They existed...but only in insignificant numbers.

http://www.websmileys.com/sm/cool/223.gif

Clarksist
24th August 2005, 01:18
against traditional morality and Christian Fascism, around the question of homosexuality, around the question of women and in particular abortion, around the question of separation of church and state, and so on. We need to play a much greater role in the ideological and also in the political battle around this, in the battle around public opinion and in important political struggles in these spheres.


What "good" Christian would not believe in what the Bible says? That is the point of the Bible for Christians. They need it to decipher that homosexuality is bad, that women aren't equal, and that a theocracy is good.


And he explained that what he is trying to do, in basic terms, is to get people to move from things like Pentecostalism and similar fundamentalist versions of Christianity to a more thinking Christianity.


Good luck. :lol:

Again, the reasons Christian's follow the Bible is because that is what "God says to do".

If you seriously think that you will burn in hell for ALL of eternity, why wouldn't you do everything you possibly could to prevent that? Sadly, one of those things is following what the Bible says.

Thinking Christianity does not exist.


Yes, we should struggle with them ideologically, but most of them are not going to be won to communism, certainly not in an immediate framework, so we need to continue to have dialogue with them, we have to learn from them--there are important things we can learn from them--and at the same time we have to try to enable them to play the most positive role they can play in the struggle.


Wait, Bob says that even though we don't agree with Christians, we have no chance of converting them, and the only thing we may do is learn more about there beliefs: yet we should try to snuggle fuck them?

I don't understand.

Red Powers
24th August 2005, 03:52
Gonna be a Baptist preacher

Ain't gonna have to work no more

-- Son House


1st part of a joke:

What do a Baptist preacher and the Chairman of a MLM party have in common?