DarkAngel
26th February 2005, 23:27
NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - It may not be the chocolate and pizza that threatens many teenage girls' complexion. Milk -- skim milk, in particular -- may be the more likely culprit in teenage acne, new study findings suggest.
"The message is that milk is a biological fluid, the consumption of which may have effects on consumers beyond its nutrient contents," study author Dr. Clement A. Adebamowo, of Harvard University told Reuters Health.
This does not mean teenage girls, or boys for that matter, should stop drinking milk. "Milk is a traditional part of the diet in most homes," Adebamowo said. "Moderate consumption of any type of milk is recommended."
Adebamowo's study is one of the latest to revisit the hypothesis that certain foods may increase the risk of acne during the teen years.
"For almost four decades, the question of an association between diet and acne has remained unanswered. Despite strong folkloric information, the medical community has concluded in the absence of compelling evidence that there is no association," Adebamowo said.
"This study provides evidence that the folks (outside the medical community) may not have been mistaken all along."
To determine whether milk or other dairy products is associated with acne outbreaks, Adebamowo and his team analyzed survey responses from 47,335 women involved in the ongoing national Nurses Health Study II.
The women were asked about their diet in high school, particularly the frequency with which they consumed dairy foods and whether they usually drank whole milk, powdered milk, low-fat milk or skim/nonfat milk. They were also asked whether they had ever been diagnosed with "severe teenage acne."
Although most (61 percent) of the women drank whole milk as teenagers, 20 percent drank low-fat milk, 7 percent drank skim milk and 2 percent drank powdered milk.
Those who reported drinking more than three servings of any type of milk each day were 22 percent more likely to report having had severe acne than those who drank only one or fewer servings per week, the researchers report in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.
Women who consumed two or more daily servings of skim milk, in particular, were 44 percent more likely to say that a physician had diagnosed them with severe acne during their teen years than those who drank one or fewer servings per week.
While whole milk and low-fat milk were not found to be as greatly associated with teenage acne, other dairy products, such as instant breakfast drinks, sherbet, cream cheese and cottage cheese were associated with acne. Women who ate one or more servings of such products per day as teenagers were up to 63 percent more likely to say they had severe acne during their teen years, the report indicates.
Contrary to what some might think, chocolate candy and soda were not associated with teenage acne. Those who regularly consumed French fries and pizza also did not appear to be more likely to report having had teenage acne.
Since skim milk was more greatly associated with a history of teenage acne than whole milk, the acne was probably not due to the milk's fat content, the researchers speculate. They hypothesize that the association may instead be caused by the hormones in milk.
Despite the findings, Adebamowo suggests that "readers should await further studies."
In the meantime, teens should continue to drink moderate amounts of milk, even if they wish to avoid skim milk based on the current findings. "Certainly soy milk or rice milk might be an appropriate choice for health-conscious teens," Adebamowo said.
SOURCE: Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, February 2005.
__________________________________________________ ___________
Anybody else hear about this?
"The message is that milk is a biological fluid, the consumption of which may have effects on consumers beyond its nutrient contents," study author Dr. Clement A. Adebamowo, of Harvard University told Reuters Health.
This does not mean teenage girls, or boys for that matter, should stop drinking milk. "Milk is a traditional part of the diet in most homes," Adebamowo said. "Moderate consumption of any type of milk is recommended."
Adebamowo's study is one of the latest to revisit the hypothesis that certain foods may increase the risk of acne during the teen years.
"For almost four decades, the question of an association between diet and acne has remained unanswered. Despite strong folkloric information, the medical community has concluded in the absence of compelling evidence that there is no association," Adebamowo said.
"This study provides evidence that the folks (outside the medical community) may not have been mistaken all along."
To determine whether milk or other dairy products is associated with acne outbreaks, Adebamowo and his team analyzed survey responses from 47,335 women involved in the ongoing national Nurses Health Study II.
The women were asked about their diet in high school, particularly the frequency with which they consumed dairy foods and whether they usually drank whole milk, powdered milk, low-fat milk or skim/nonfat milk. They were also asked whether they had ever been diagnosed with "severe teenage acne."
Although most (61 percent) of the women drank whole milk as teenagers, 20 percent drank low-fat milk, 7 percent drank skim milk and 2 percent drank powdered milk.
Those who reported drinking more than three servings of any type of milk each day were 22 percent more likely to report having had severe acne than those who drank only one or fewer servings per week, the researchers report in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.
Women who consumed two or more daily servings of skim milk, in particular, were 44 percent more likely to say that a physician had diagnosed them with severe acne during their teen years than those who drank one or fewer servings per week.
While whole milk and low-fat milk were not found to be as greatly associated with teenage acne, other dairy products, such as instant breakfast drinks, sherbet, cream cheese and cottage cheese were associated with acne. Women who ate one or more servings of such products per day as teenagers were up to 63 percent more likely to say they had severe acne during their teen years, the report indicates.
Contrary to what some might think, chocolate candy and soda were not associated with teenage acne. Those who regularly consumed French fries and pizza also did not appear to be more likely to report having had teenage acne.
Since skim milk was more greatly associated with a history of teenage acne than whole milk, the acne was probably not due to the milk's fat content, the researchers speculate. They hypothesize that the association may instead be caused by the hormones in milk.
Despite the findings, Adebamowo suggests that "readers should await further studies."
In the meantime, teens should continue to drink moderate amounts of milk, even if they wish to avoid skim milk based on the current findings. "Certainly soy milk or rice milk might be an appropriate choice for health-conscious teens," Adebamowo said.
SOURCE: Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, February 2005.
__________________________________________________ ___________
Anybody else hear about this?