War or Peace ?

[RCC]

I know this is a highly controversial question, but in your opinion whats the most effective way to reform a repressive government? Through peaceful methods or violent means?
(I will play devils advocate)

[DoctorWasdarb]

Depends on the material conditions. Some governments can be reformed. Look at the change in position of the Communist Party of Egypt towards Nasser when he started pursuing a more populist line, thanks to the pressure they put on him. Other governments can't be, like Saudi Arabia. It's a repressive monarchy. It won't change without revolution from the masses.

[Jimmie Higgins]

I know this is a highly controversial question, but in your opinion whats the most effective way to reform a repressive government? Through peaceful methods or violent means?
(I will play devils advocate)

The best way for whom in society?

[RCC]

Lets say, better for the general population of the country.

[windy]

Well, I think it goes without saying that peace is better than war. The real question should be "Is a peaceful transformation of society possible?", and on that I unfortunately think not. I think history has shown enough that the ruling class don't give up power with out a fight. I mean these are the people who set up police forces, militaries etc. and use violence to keep their status as the ruling class, so it just seems doubtful to me a peaceful transformation is possible.