Pink Floyd

[Comrade Pointless]

Have your say

[Comrade Pointless]

By the way the Tupac thing isn't nonsense I downloaded a weird track off Kazaa with one of his raps over the top of a pink floyd track... really strange but amusing.

[Ian]

Shut up Cth.... I mean Comrade Pointless...

[atlanticche]

mull vote
i dont know anything about the pink floyd members
but im sure that tupac was not a member

[Dr. Rosenpenis]

Listing Tupac is pretty stupid, if I say so myself.
He overdubbed a song onto Pink Floyd's!
That really doesn't make him a vocalist in Pink Floyd.

[Dr. Rosenpenis]

And besides, Roger Waters wasn't even a lead vocalist!
He was a bassist and composer.
David Gilmour was the lead singer and you didn't even mention him!
And Willy Wilson also wasn't a member.
He toured with them a few times and did some work with the members outside of Pink Floyd.
And he also wasn't a lead vocalist.
He was a drummer.
I believe he did sing, but wasn't a lead singer.

Have you ever heard Pink Floyd?

[Hegemonicretribution]

Sorry to reitterate Victor, but what the fuck? Gilmour was lead, but also by far the best in my oppinion. Listing members would be a better option. I wouldn't ask who Queen's best singer was out of George Michael, John Deacon, Robbie Williams or Dave down at Kareokee...even if they have all done a song, or some work with queen.

Still don't be discouraged, if you liked Tupac's version, get yourself high then listen to DSOTM, Medal, The Wall, Animals etc.. in that order ;) There is hope yet.

[celtopunk]

His name says it all, another "Pointless poll".

[Palmares]

Originally posted by [email protected] 18 2004, 04:58 PM
Shut up Cth.... I mean Comrade Pointless...
Strangely enough it isn't me (Comrade Pointless). It is a friend of mine being a dick. Sorry guys.