Log in

View Full Version : Revolutionary Peasants



Krymz
27th December 2015, 19:23
I was wondering if there was anyone on this forum who grows/grew food as a full time occupation (aka a job). I want to have a discussion about many aspect of the field in relation to revolution and communism.

I have done studies in horticulture production and environment, have worked on many farms and want to start a million agricultural projects of my own, but at the same time I want to join my political ideas to my project, not have them separated. I have many topics I would like to talk about;

(in no particular order)

1- Uniting the "farmers" into a union [of unions?] that can actually do some political pressure/work.

The conservative/reactionary mind set of the majority of farmers (and the majority of them being old). I don't know about your part of the world, but over here in Québec (Canada) we have one big forced union on the farmers. they got some "alright" stuff like quotas of production on certain items like milk and pork (a kind of centralized control of supply and demand). Of course it's a pro capitalism union, but they still have slogans like "Strong and United". I could write a whole booklet on the mater, but I'll leave it at this for an intro to this subject. so in short, how to unite old reactionaries who are the most important work force of our society (when is the last time you heard of living without eating? making food year round is far from a simple feat.)

2- Taking care of people's need versus having to make a profit.

It takes a whole lot of time and energy managing a farm from A to Z (usually around 125% of your time or more), and all this to get somewhere from not enough to pay the bills to having a little safety cushion for new projects or repairs or whatever is needed (kids schooling, winter tires, etc. of course huge corporate farms are excluded here). At the same time, it would be nice to be able to give the food away to those who can't afford it otherwise, and it would be also nice to create a moneyless system that will only flourish the more members it get.

3- Building an "infrastructure for the revolution".

Building on from point 2, farm can create A LOT of stuff, not just food. With the right professionals you can easily have different micro industrial activities (metal/wood work, textile, education, etc) that complement each other. It's also a perfect base for revolutionaries for whatever purpose they see fit (where did the Cubans go train for their revolution? a ranch/farm :cool: ). Farm work build the spirit and the body, and usually builds solidarity and friendship within the large circle of people that it touches.

I don't see how any of all this can work other than having a commune, and a problem with communes is that they usually fall apart not long after they emerge into the world. So enough rambling, what is your relation to the food production, and what are your thoughts on the subjects, and do you have anything to add? thank you!

Os Cangaceiros
28th December 2015, 17:42
I'm not a farmer but I am involved in food production (I'm a fisherman). Ultimately the same primary issue is at play both with fishermen and farmers: people have a lot more direct control over commodity production in these fields and that keeps them from being easily recruited to the kinds of organizational methods that leftists commonly fetishize (such as industrial unions, for example). Although less so in the era of the factory farm (in farming) or the IFQ (in fishing)...these industries have not been immune to the tendency towards centralization.

I don't really see how production quota-setting is a great thing. That's something farmers have done for a long time in response to market fluctuations and it has resulted in a lot of waste at times (the destruction of food during the Great Depression being a common example).

Krymz
29th December 2015, 00:02
although there is indeed waste with quotas, I think it prevents even more waste as it tracks the "consumption" of the products and tries to adjust to it. It's not black and white.

Krymz
29th December 2015, 00:13
I'm not familiar with the fishing industry much. How does it work? Do you have an specific area you can fish in or can you go anywhere (I'm guessing it's not that simple, you still have to find the fish)? can you only fish certain kind of fish by permits and so on (I think it also depends on the boat)?

I can understand how good workers can look badly to unions in agriculture, by the simple fact that it's hard work and they would not want to be paid as much as some lazy workers who makes them work even more to cover for their laziness. But that problem is mostly rooted in the profit motive and the need to perform economically on the market.

So as Lenin said, "what is to be done"?