Guardia Rossa
12th February 2015, 21:49
Stalinist comrades, can you explain me some points of your theory?
1: How is possible the people to support a dictatorship, alienated from power, both politically and economically, how it is possible for them to grow intelectually, without free speech, how stalinism will provide the people with actual reasons to keep with the socialism going, instead of just bring back another sistem (like they did)?
2: Do you know that Lenin was against Stalin, that actual Leninists should support democracy and internationalism? Why do you then keep supporting dictatorships and chauvinism like the CCCP under Stalin or China under Mao (even with islamic/fascist/monarchist argumentation lines)?
Most importantly
3: Why do you think that things Stalin (apparently) considered as a need in XX century as still today the best solution to things today? Ain't socialism about interpretating what is needed in the NOW, and not copying what someone said almost 100 years ago as the right thing to do at the time?
Obs: Im not follower of any line, i'm heterodox, closer to titoism or old good leninist leninism, but I dont think stalinism can suceed in causing more then trouble for us socialists.
I am not hostile to stalinism.
I wish these points of mine to be explained under a stalinist point of view, as I don't know many.
1: How is possible the people to support a dictatorship, alienated from power, both politically and economically, how it is possible for them to grow intelectually, without free speech, how stalinism will provide the people with actual reasons to keep with the socialism going, instead of just bring back another sistem (like they did)?
2: Do you know that Lenin was against Stalin, that actual Leninists should support democracy and internationalism? Why do you then keep supporting dictatorships and chauvinism like the CCCP under Stalin or China under Mao (even with islamic/fascist/monarchist argumentation lines)?
Most importantly
3: Why do you think that things Stalin (apparently) considered as a need in XX century as still today the best solution to things today? Ain't socialism about interpretating what is needed in the NOW, and not copying what someone said almost 100 years ago as the right thing to do at the time?
Obs: Im not follower of any line, i'm heterodox, closer to titoism or old good leninist leninism, but I dont think stalinism can suceed in causing more then trouble for us socialists.
I am not hostile to stalinism.
I wish these points of mine to be explained under a stalinist point of view, as I don't know many.