Log in

View Full Version : Encounters in the Panopticon



Doctor Hilarius
8th May 2014, 01:45
So today I witnessed something at work that I felt highlighted some of the challenges that the left faces today.

A young woman walked around my place of employment listening to music rather loudly and dancing. This display of non-normative behavior (which even made me feel uncomfortable) drew stares of derision and condemnation.

As she went to leave, she took a couple drags from an electronic cigarette. Later, other employees claimed that she was "crazy" and "smoking crack".

A couple cops on their lunch break happened to walk in right after she left, and the management waived them down and showed them surveillance footage of the dancing women, which they watched for what must have been 30 minutes.

This experience taught me a lesson in what a "revolution" is, an eruption of subjective revolutionary will against the normalizing gaze. In many ways, this is how one can break from ideology; a seemingly "insane" action that is unpredicted by neoclassical economic models, acts that violate all so called "rational choice" models of human behavior.

A human being moving their limbs and hips in a certain way can summon police, and charges of insanity and drug use. Her actions defied interpretation by the grid of intelligibility that norms impose onto our everyday lives.

Unfortunately, it seems like the domain of "rational behavior" is narrowing. Now police are summoned when somebody dances.

Reminds me of the French revolutionary Anatole Atlas when he interrupts Lacan during a lecture in France. (on youtube as "Excerpt from Lacan Parle (1972).mp")

Ele'ill
8th May 2014, 01:56
the surprise of riot! social rupture!

MarcusJuniusBrutus
8th May 2014, 03:09
We are not robots, yet present day social norms demand that we act like robots. Usually, self-surveillance checks non-conforming behavior, but when it doesn't, others get alarmed. We get pigeon-holed by social memes, terms like "unprofessional," "unlady-like," "unmanly," "eccentric," or even "crazy."

Doctor Hilarius
8th May 2014, 03:44
We are not robots, yet present day social norms demand that we act like robots. Usually, self-surveillance checks non-conforming behavior, but when it doesn't, others get alarmed. We get pigeon-holed by social memes, terms like "unprofessional," "unlady-like," "unmanly," "eccentric," or even "crazy."

The interesting thing was that the "dancing woman" will probably not change her dancing, but everyone who witnessed it shared disapproving glances, snide remarks and a mutually re-enforcing disapproval of her actions.

This is another one of the challenges that is faced, that the act of rebellion strengthens normative domination, in that it provides a situation in which the norm can be mutually deployed and re-enforced by the onlookers.

MarcusJuniusBrutus
8th May 2014, 04:10
Very true, I'm afraid.

Admiral Swagmeister G-Funk
8th May 2014, 10:19
cool stuff. didn't know that the guy in that lacan video was well known either. he's the best thing about that video - a breath of fresh air!

Lynx
8th May 2014, 10:30
30 minutes... means no laws were broken.

Doctor Hilarius
8th May 2014, 14:35
cool stuff. didn't know that the guy in that lacan video was well known either. he's the best thing about that video - a breath of fresh air!

He was connected to the Situationist International (obvious by his speech), and he apparently interrupted several people in France, including some that were on live television.