Log in

View Full Version : What is the People's democratic dictatorship



orihara
21st April 2014, 17:02
Could anyone please explain to me what the People's democratic dictatorship is, and how it would work in practice?

Ahab Strange
21st April 2014, 18:16
Are you referring to the "Dictatorship of the Proletariat"?

Or is this something specific you've heard about in a specific context?

ArisVelouxiotis
21st April 2014, 18:19
How can you have a democratic dictatorship

motion denied
21st April 2014, 18:37
How can you have a democratic dictatorship

Every "democracy", as any form of political power, is a dictatorship of some kind... Or class. A 'democratic dictatorship' is when the majority, the proletariat, rules over its exploiters towards its own extinction.

Brutus
21st April 2014, 19:00
Dictatorship means the imposition of a rule on others who do not consent to it; democracy means the rule of the majority. Any rule is a dictatorship unless all decisions are unanimous, as even a democracy is a dictatorship over the minority.

No communist will support a "people's dictatorship" as that would be in the interests of society as a whole (i.e. all classes). We're not utilitarians- we want a dictatorship of the working class which works towards the abolition of all classes and of all the various symptoms of class society.

Slavic
21st April 2014, 21:56
Every "democracy", as any form of political power, is a dictatorship of some kind... Or class. A 'democratic dictatorship' is when the majority, the proletariat, rules over its exploiters towards its own extinction.

Not to mention a consensus democracy is not feasible. There will always be those who oppose the ruling political power.

Fourth Internationalist
21st April 2014, 22:14
Could anyone please explain to me what the People's democratic dictatorship is, and how it would work in practice?

Do you mean like Lenin's "Democratic Dictatorship of the Proletariat and the Peasantry"? I'm only familiar with Stalinists using the term "People's" in terms of describing some sort of nominally socialist state. Otherwise, there's no such concept as this that I'm aware about.

Edit: The term was used by the Chinese Stalinists (Maoists). Is that what you mean?

Brutus
21st April 2014, 22:41
Do you mean like Lenin's "Democratic Dictatorship of the Proletariat and the Peasantry"?
Thankfully Lenin dropped that and went over to Trotsky's (and others like Rizanov's) position of a workers' government.

In the sense of the Maoists it was used to describe their class-collaborationist theories.

ArisVelouxiotis
21st April 2014, 23:13
Well he didn't say class dictatorship.
Dictatorship of political power(like all the ones we know)can't be democratic.
Except if by the people's he meant the dotp.

JPSartre12
21st April 2014, 23:25
From what my Maoist friends have told me, the "peoples' democratic dictatorship" is the application of Lenin's state-capitalist principles to Chinese material conditions, as means of a revolutionary party-controlled State using the organs of the State political apparatus to induce industrialization so as to lay the economic preconditions for socialism.

As others mentioned above, a Marxian "dictatorship" is simply one class asserting its economic hegemony over another. It has nothing to do with dictatorships in the liberal democratic sense of the word.

I'd recommend looking at Maoist literature, or talking to Maoists about it. They would probably know more about it than I would. If you're curious, though, you can take quick look at Mao's On the Peoples' Democratic Dictatorship at the Marxist Internet Archive here:

http://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-4/mswv4_65.htm