Log in

View Full Version : Personal chat with a modern maoist or other outside marxist-leninis form of communist



ashtonh
18th April 2014, 01:28
Hi I would wish to discuss theory with communist other than Marxist-leninist.

tuwix
18th April 2014, 05:54
Then decide what you want to discuss. For example, I think that Marxism-Leninism doesn't exist but Leninism and Marxism that don't have much to do with each other.

Brutus
18th April 2014, 09:01
Marxism-Leninism exists whether you like it or not. It's a significant force on the left, and it's not going to disappear by ignoring it- it has to be combatted.

tuwix
18th April 2014, 12:01
Marxism-Leninism exists whether you like it or not.

Only by disinformation done by Stalinist propaganda. In true understanding it doesn't.

Hrafn
18th April 2014, 12:42
You're asking for a chat with, among others, a Maoist. Who often consider themselves Marxist-Leninists of some sort?

Brutus
18th April 2014, 12:43
Only by disinformation done by Stalinist propaganda. In true understanding it doesn't.

It's bullshit and misrepresentations, but it still exists as an actual material force. We can't sweep it under the rug and forget about it.

The Jay
18th April 2014, 13:02
I'm here. What do you want to talk about exactly? I'm not a maoist.

tuwix
18th April 2014, 13:04
It's bullshit and misrepresentations, but it still exists as an actual material force. We can't sweep it under the rug and forget about it.

Give me a one difference between so-called 'marxism-leninism' and Leninism.

IMO all this 'marxism-leninism' is just manipulation to empower a Leninism that is intellectually poor...

reb
18th April 2014, 13:21
Give me a one difference between so-called 'marxism-leninism' and Leninism.

IMO all this 'marxism-leninism' is just manipulation to empower a Leninism that is intellectually poor...

They're two different words to describe the same thing, the official ideology of the USSR.

reb
18th April 2014, 13:23
It's bullshit and misrepresentations, but it still exists as an actual material force. We can't sweep it under the rug and forget about it.

It only exists as a material force as a bulwark against revolution, as the left wing of capital. Stalinists are pretty impotent without a state to back up their out right bullshit.

ashtonh
18th April 2014, 14:25
By marxist-leninists I meant those who ascribe only to the Marxist and leninist ideals without the thought and works of other revolutionaries.

Remus Bleys
18th April 2014, 17:09
By marxist-leninists I meant those who ascribe only to the Marxist and leninist ideals without the thought and works of other revolutionaries.
Marxism-Leninism is the "official" word for stalinist. I understand and get that you are new, but I do not understand why exactly "newbies" are so resistant to learning this...
Your user status says "trotskyist" and your tendency is set to "orthodox maoism," but this is a fundamentally confused position. Trotksyists and Maoists don't agree with eachother. Trotskyists view Mao as a "bureaucrat" or a "state capitalist dictator" depending on what type of trotskyist you are asking.
The idea that Marxist-Leninist "ideals" is Marxists are easily and quickly dispelled by Goldner here (http://home.earthlink.net/~lrgoldner/renaissance.html) and the idea that it is Leninist is dispelled here (http://www.international-communist-party.org/BasicTexts/WhatDist.htm).

ashtonh
18th April 2014, 22:13
Ok so the reason my tendency is orthodox maoist and one says trotskyist is because I have had little time other than quick post checks and replies as of late.

ashtonh
19th April 2014, 05:34
Time is much better now.

o well this is ok I guess
19th April 2014, 08:18
and it's not going to disappear by ignoring it- it has to be combatted. RAAN like a motherfucker

Stalinists are pretty impotent without a state to back up their out right bullshit. the reason maoism is still a force today is cuz it's the only marxist-leninism that can survive on a shoestring budget

ashtonh
20th April 2014, 00:57
RAAN like a motherfucker
the reason maoism is still a force today is cuz it's the only marxist-leninism that can survive on a shoestring budget
lol wow That is messed up but I can not agree. Maoism is a poor revolution because of its farmer based army. Maoism influenced many including Che why else would one start with peasents. :grin::laugh::laugh:

Q
20th April 2014, 01:10
I think the question of what you wanted to discuss was never answered.

Moving this from /theory to /learning.

ashtonh
21st April 2014, 05:08
Ok I will ask once more lol for a maoist, guevarist,castroist,ho chi mihnist, kim il sungist, dont matter wat doctrine to PM me

Yet_Another_Boring_Marxist
21st April 2014, 05:12
feel free to message me with questions if you feel like it

consuming negativity
21st April 2014, 05:51
guevarist,castroist,ho chi mihnist, kim il sungist, dont matter wat doctrine to PM me

I, too, would like to see a unicorn.

Let me know if you come across any.