synthesis
31st October 2013, 09:12
I've been meaning to make a thread like this for awhile and always forgot.
I notice that a number of people here use "bougie" as a synonym for "bourgeois," most likely because it sounds less "academic" and because it's seen as "cool" or whatever owing to the fact that it's slang.
"Bougie" doesn't mean "someone who controls the means of production" or really anything significantly close to that. It refers to someone who has lost touch with their neighborhood roots, who sees themselves as better than the people they grew up with because of cultural and financial factors, and to things and places associated with people who would be labelled as such. "Bougie" is also always an adjective, not a noun.
It is derived from "bourgeois," but they're not the same, and I think most of the people who use it not knowing what "bourgeois" means would be completely confused if you used it to mean "bourgeois" in a political context, so you'd wind up having to explain the concept and use the original term anyway, defeating the purpose.
I agree that it would be nice to have a solid substitute for it in more casual conversation or when discussing politics with people who might not be well-versed in Marxist theory; "working class" is a good substitute for "proletarian," but in my opinion "ruling class" isn't the best substitute for "bourgeois" because it can also refer to the aristocracy if you're a Marxist or the Illuminati if you're a nutjob or you listen to rap music. "Owning class" also leaves something to be desired, in my opinion. Suggestions are welcome.
That is all.
I notice that a number of people here use "bougie" as a synonym for "bourgeois," most likely because it sounds less "academic" and because it's seen as "cool" or whatever owing to the fact that it's slang.
"Bougie" doesn't mean "someone who controls the means of production" or really anything significantly close to that. It refers to someone who has lost touch with their neighborhood roots, who sees themselves as better than the people they grew up with because of cultural and financial factors, and to things and places associated with people who would be labelled as such. "Bougie" is also always an adjective, not a noun.
It is derived from "bourgeois," but they're not the same, and I think most of the people who use it not knowing what "bourgeois" means would be completely confused if you used it to mean "bourgeois" in a political context, so you'd wind up having to explain the concept and use the original term anyway, defeating the purpose.
I agree that it would be nice to have a solid substitute for it in more casual conversation or when discussing politics with people who might not be well-versed in Marxist theory; "working class" is a good substitute for "proletarian," but in my opinion "ruling class" isn't the best substitute for "bourgeois" because it can also refer to the aristocracy if you're a Marxist or the Illuminati if you're a nutjob or you listen to rap music. "Owning class" also leaves something to be desired, in my opinion. Suggestions are welcome.
That is all.