Log in

View Full Version : Chinese University Students Embracing Maoism



ВАЛТЕР
9th August 2013, 10:57
http://www.systemiccapital.com/chinese-university-students-embracing-maoism-in-backlash-against-social-inequality/


Chinese university students embracing Maoism in backlash against social inequality

August 7, 2013
By admin (http://www.systemiccapital.com/author/admin/)
http://media.miamiherald.com/smedia/2013/08/06/16/48/431-GPNlN.Em.91.jpeg

SHANGHAI On the campus of Beijing Normal University, professors say theyve noticed a trend that worries them: students embracing radical leftism. They advocate a return to the socialist state that Communist Party founder Mao Zedong favored and that Chinese leaders for the last generation have tried to put behind them.
The students wear pins with pictures of Mao and carry bags with the former Communist leaders famous quotations, such as serve the people.

[...]


How big a movement the new left represents is unknown, but in a country where political thought is strictly controlled, social inequality and government corruption are epidemic and the job market for recent college graduates is considered poor, academics who are closest to the phenomenon admit to fears that it represents a dangerous split in society.
They are either extreme leftists or extreme rightists, one professor at the university said of her students, requesting anonymity out of concern that speaking about politics might result in retribution from the government. When they have differences, there is no dialogue between them. This is a worrisome phenomenon and also some reflection of the split in society.
In general, there are more rightists than leftists, she said, but the leftists are very left.
There is widespread discontent among students with inequality and corruption, plus frustrations in their own lives, said Yang Dali, the faculty director at the University of Chicagos Beijing center. It is highly understandable that there would be a leftist sentiment.
The rise of a new left comes against a backdrop of decades of Chinas ruling class allowing more economic freedom. But advocates of the new left say that 30 years of an export-oriented economy thats brought hundreds of millions of people from rural areas to cities to fill low-wage jobs in assembly plants has led to extreme inequality and corruption.
We emphasize that reform and opening to the outside world does not benefit the common people, said Cui Zhiyuan, a professor at Tsinghua Universitys school of public policy and management whos known as one of the founders of Chinas new left movement.
The movement has had a tenuous relationship with the government. The ouster last year of Bo Xilai, the party boss in Chongqing, whose government had instituted policies to support the citys poor, an audacious anti-corruption campaign and the resurrection of the singing of Mao-era red songs in public squares, was seen as a blow to leftists, who considered Bo a champion for their cause. Today, leftist websites such as Utopia, which strongly supports Bo remain shuttered.


[...]

On social media, theres an increase of pro-Maoist commentary as well as vitriolic criticism of liberal scholars who advocate further market-oriented reforms, democracy, free speech and human rights. Last autumn, during anti-Japanese protests that erupted over a territorial dispute between the countries, many young people carried portraits of Mao. The new leftists and the neo-liberals, they hate each other, said Lu Xinyu, a left-leaning professor in Fudan Universitys journalism school. There are a lot of lies told by neo-liberals. A very significant characteristic of them is to always see America as a kind of utopia and that China should meet that standard, but America is facing a serious crisis.

[...]



But many are unwilling to have their identities known. A member of a Maoist student group called Centimeter Sunshine, at the Harbin Institute of Technology in northern China, recalls that the group had only about a dozen members when it was established in 2009. Now there are hundreds, he said, asking, however, that he not be identified because he feared retribution.The group reads books on Marxism and travels to rural areas to study social injustice. Sometimes they sing red songs. Many support Bos Chongqing model. We get together and discuss issues in China, like government ethics, and lack of fairness and justice, the student said. I dont think Americas culture or thoughts have any advanced parts. We still need to rely on the Communist Party of China and the system to come back to the core of serving the people.
The group has faced opposition. In June, other students drafted a petition asking the university to ban the group. Centimeter Sunshine tells members that China has been hijacked by pro-capitalist rightists, the letter said. They have openly showed support for Bo Xilai, and they hugely poison the minds of modern college students.


[...]


What worries me, he added, is that I have heard many similar groups are at other universities.
MORE


http://www.miamiherald.com/2013/08/06/3546268/among-chinas-students-some-hope.html

Die Neue Zeit
9th August 2013, 15:45
Chinese Trotskyists need to understand that, despite all the history of class collaboration, the figure of Mao Zedong is to the Chinese workers and the Chinese "new left" what the figure of Ferdinand Lassalle was to the European worker-class movement from the 1890s to the 1900s.

Sixiang
16th August 2013, 01:05
Thanks for posting this.

There was a similar euphoria among Chinese students around the time of the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests. It seems to me that this Chinese left is mostly limited to intellectual circles and internet forums. Many Chinese farmers and workers talk favorably of the Maoist era when they had their "iron rice bowl" - that is, guaranteed health care, food access, and other amenities. I don't think there is much of an organized left of sorts in China, however, except for a leftist minority of the CCP ever since the market reforms started. They criticize how the reforms have left China's masses behind. Occasionally someone iconic like Bo Xilai comes along in the party leadership and attempts to shake things up, but usually the party either purges or marginalizes them.

Strikes are frequent in China and you can certainly find leftist Chinese websites which advocate socialist policies out there, but I don't see any real organization of a leftist program that has much chance of success per say. It is interesting that those Maoist students are organizing at Harbin, though.

Fourth Internationalist
16th August 2013, 01:09
Though I'm not a Maoist, I think this is an incredibly good sign. A communist movement, Maoist or not, is needed in China. I hope one is built and can re-create some of the benefits that workers and peasants once had and can move towards socialism.

Brutus
16th August 2013, 01:38
I'm not to optimistic, considering what went down with another Maoist group of students in the early 70s

SonofRage
16th August 2013, 01:45
Chinese Trotskyists need to understand that, despite all the history of class collaboration, the figure of Mao Zedong is to the Chinese workers and the Chinese "new left" what the figure of Ferdinand Lassalle was to the European worker-class movement from the 1890s to the 1900s.

Are there many Trots in China?

This is a fascinating story.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 4

G4b3n
16th August 2013, 01:50
This is certainly a good thing. Mao would turn in his grave if he could see what his revolution has led to.

nizan
16th August 2013, 01:52
Capitalist China is capitalist China, multitude of Mao citations aside.

Paul Pott
16th August 2013, 02:17
Interesting that there is a growing student movement on the Chinese left.

Obviously, there won't be a new Maoist era in China. At best, there will be a Chinese equivalent of the New Deal accompanied by a shakeup where people like Bo Xilai are rehabilitated into the party under popular pressure, and nationalists and populists who reject the policy of the last few decades rise to the highest levels of power and force out the reformist old guard. A palace coup like that would be driven by the people on the streets, probably led by student movements like this.

This kind of thing is especially likely to happen when the next wave of capital's global crisis strikes and exports to the west can no longer sustain China's economic prosperity, forcing the Chinese ruling class to other solutions like a military build up to keep the economy humming and to keep down unrest from mass unemployment.

The alternative is the downfall of the CCP and even the PRC altogether, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, and it doesn't rule out the things I mentioned.

Trap Queen Voxxy
16th August 2013, 02:33
See, I find this to be an incredibly interesting turn of events considering if it were to spread and spread and spread to even others aside from students, this could really be something neat. Perhaps where one giant fell through (USSR), the other (PRC) will auto-correct itself into something even more interesting. I can't wait to see this develop (hopefully) I thought I read something about this on Kasama somewhat recently.

audiored
16th August 2013, 04:01
Occasionally someone iconic like Bo Xilai comes along in the party leadership and attempts to shake things up, but usually the party either purges or marginalizes them.


Where is a good source to read more about Bo Xilai? I've only read a handful of articles from capitalist sources which were just kind of press releases from the Chinese government.

Teacher
16th August 2013, 04:54
Where is a good source to read more about Bo Xilai? I've only read a handful of articles from capitalist sources which were just kind of press releases from the Chinese government.

http://monthlyreview.org/2012/10/01/the-struggle-for-socialism-in-china

http://www.cui-zy.cn/Recommended/Chongqing/CuiChongqingModernChina.pdf

Fourth Internationalist
16th August 2013, 05:07
Are there many Trots in China?

This is a fascinating story.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 4

There were. Most of them came to oppose Mao and were expelled from the party.

*Here is the MIA archive of Chinese Trotskyism: http://www.marxists.org/history/etol/document/china.htm*

Chen Bilan wrote has some interesting stuff on it, link in my signature or here: http://www.marxists.org/archive/chen/index.htm

Here is something about Chen Duxiu, famous Chinese Trotskyist, from MIA: http://www.marxists.org/history/etol/document/china/zheng.htm

Here's a book called "Tragedy of the Chinese Revolution" regarding Chinese Trotskyism: http://www.marxists.org/history/etol/writers/isaacs/1938/tcr/

Comrade Jacob
16th August 2013, 12:43
I'm sure Mao would be happy that his country's youth still listen to him. This is great news.

Tim Cornelis
16th August 2013, 13:43
Many support Bo’s Chongqing model.

This should have been bold/highlighted though. The Congqing model is to the left of China, but the right of most (or all) of Europe. It's red rhetoric and sloganeering, and they don't even deny it.

Sasha
16th August 2013, 14:11
its only an complete biased assumption but couldnt it be that left students
"wear pins with pictures of Mao and carry bags with the former Communist leader’s famous quotations, such as “serve the people.” do this because in the still officially maoist country its the only legal way to spread discontent and social agitation?
probably expressing anarchist, trot or even radical social-dem opinions could get you expelled and otherwise in trouble, while no one can object to quoting mao and wearing his image. I wouldn't be suprised if it was for some/many more a act of subversion than actual maoist adherence.

Comrade Jacob
16th August 2013, 14:27
its only an complete biased assumption but couldnt it be that left students do this because in the still officially maoist country its the only legal way to spread discontent and social agitation?
probably expressing anarchist, trot or even radical social-dem opinions could get you expelled and otherwise in trouble, while no one can object to quoting mao and wearing his image. I wouldn't be suprised if it was for some/many more a act of subversion than actual maoist adherence.

I may be wrong but isn't their state ideology "Marxism-Leninism" and "Socialism with Chinese characteristics" not Maoism? (Of course they are capitalists now but I mean officially).

goalkeeper
16th August 2013, 14:40
Such a shame for young minds to poison themselves with such a reactionary ideology

Paul Pott
16th August 2013, 14:56
Psycho might not be aware that the Chinese state routinely suppresses left wing movements of all kinds, including those that hold Mao pictures.

The rise of Maoist and semi-Maoist student movements has been followed by Kasama iirc and others for a long time, so it's pretty legit, they're not faking it.

SonofRage
16th August 2013, 16:21
There were. Most of them came to oppose Mao and were expelled from the party.

*Here is the MIA archive of Chinese Trotskyism: http://www.marxists.org/history/etol/document/china.htm*

Chen Bilan wrote has some interesting stuff on it, link in my signature or here: http://www.marxists.org/archive/chen/index.htm

Here is something about Chen Duxiu, famous Chinese Trotskyist, from MIA: http://www.marxists.org/history/etol/document/china/zheng.htm

Here's a book called "Tragedy of the Chinese Revolution" regarding Chinese Trotskyism: http://www.marxists.org/history/etol/writers/isaacs/1938/tcr/

Interesting. I honestly know very little about the Chinese revolution. I feel like I'd need to read more about it before evaluating some of the critiques there. Very interesting though.

Sixiang
16th August 2013, 19:28
Are there many Trots in China?

As far as I know, the only seriously organized Chinese Trotskyists are located in Hong Kong, and they are a very small group.


I may be wrong but isn't their state ideology "Marxism-Leninism" and "Socialism with Chinese characteristics" not Maoism? (Of course they are capitalists now but I mean officially).
I think the official lineup in the party's constitution is: "Marxism-Leninism, Mao Zedong Thought, Deng Xiaoping Theory and the important thought of Three Represents." Each major party chairman has come up with some driving "theory" for the party. Most recently, Xi Jinping has come up with the "Chinese dream" just this year. I remember last fall China watchers were harping about how Xi was going to break the mold and not come up with a bogus theory, and then he did it earlier this year. Jiang Zemin came up with "Three Represents," and Hu Jintao came up with the "Scientific development concept." All are still affirmed by the party to varying degrees.

RedHal
16th August 2013, 21:25
Just because "Mao Zedong Thought" (PRC does not recognise Maoism) is still "officially" part of the State ideology, Maoists are far from safe from state repression. Just look at the case of the Zhengzhou Four in 2004, Maoists jailed for handing out pamplets denouncing the capitalists reforms.

http://monthlyreview.org/commentary/on-december-24-2004-maoists-in-china-get-three-year-prison-sentences-for-leafleting

of course this gets no coverage as the opening of the article puts it
"When liberal writers Liu Xiaobo and Yu Jie were recently (and briefly) detained by Chinese police, there was a world wide chorus of denunciation. The liberal writers endorsement of the U.S. aggression in Iraq made them even more heroic in the eyes of the Murdoch-dominated press. Not surprisingly, there has been no coverage whatsoever of a more egregious case of crackdown on dissentbecause it is dissent from the left."

Unlike what the press wants you to believe, China isn't much different from the "free" world, they'll tolerate dissent as long as it doesn't gain too much momentum.

Sixiang
16th August 2013, 22:41
Just because "Mao Zedong Thought" (PRC does not recognise Maoism) is still "officially" part of the State ideology, Maoists are far from safe from state repression.

Unlike what the press wants you to believe, China isn't much different from the "free" world, they'll tolerate dissent as long as it doesn't gain too much momentum.

Agreed. The CCP's extolling of Mao Zedong Thought as a principle is limited. When the party re-evaluated Mao's legacy in the late '70s-early '80s, they abandoned everything Mao did after 1957 as "ultra-left deviationism." Instead they say Mao's "contributions" to the Chinese revolution were leading the CCP to victory, leading the national unification, and extolling the "Sinification of Marxism." All of these are used to downplay Maoist dialectical materialism or class struggle and to support Deng Xiaoping's "theories" of "Socialism with Chinese characteristics." Mao is no longer seen as a great theorist but instead as the leader of a popular nationalist movement that led to the current regime.

Sasha
16th August 2013, 22:53
Oh certainly, yet but all that aside you are probably still safer making a statement with a touristy tshirt quoting Mao than a self made one saying "down with the regime".
I don't doubt China goes down hard on organized Maoist groups, but the article seems to be more about students making a small stand, I can imagine its for them more about the message it comunicates than about being ideaologically a full blown Maoist.