Log in

View Full Version : Germany: Die Linke MP joins the CWI



Sentinel
1st August 2013, 18:00
Heidrun Dittrich, a Die Linke (Left Party) member of the German parliament for the state of Lower Saxony, has joined Sozialistische Alternative (SAV), German section of the Committee for a Workers' International (CWI). With Joe Higgins already in the Dail, the parliament of Ireland, this brings the number of CWI MPs to two.

Besides them, the organisation also has a voice in the EU parliament through Paul Murphy. 'A strong SAV strengthens the left in Die Linke', says Dittrich. Read her statement from www.socialistworld.net below (inside spoilers):


Germany

DIE LINKE MP Heidrun Dittrich joins CWI

01/08/2013
“A strong SAV strengthens the left in DIE LINKE”

Statement by Heidrun Dittrich


DIE LINKE (Left Party) MP for Lower Saxony, Heidrun Dittrich, has joined Sozialistische Alternative (SAV), the CWI’s German section. This follows a period of intense cooperation inside the party and its left current, the “Anti-capitalist Left“. This is her statement:

Why I am joining the SAV

In view of the mass movements on almost all continents, the current lack of an alternative in the minds of many people and the disappointment with the neo-liberal parties, the building of strong socialist forces is decisive to show a way out of the crisis of capitalism. Otherwise pro-capitalist or even fascist groups can use the existing disappointment, progressive movements can turn into civil wars like in Syria or the military can take power like in Egypt. Such developments can only be prevented if the working class on an international scale and as an independent force fights for an alternative.

I decided to join Sozialistische Alternative (SAV), because I think that an international Marxist organisation which stands for such a perspective is needed.

For half of my life I have considered myself a marxist and I have been fighting together with colleagues, trade unionists and unemployed for an alternative to war, poverty and wage slavery. This is why I joined the trade union when I was 16 and became active in my workplace. Five years ago I joined DIE LINKE, because a strong socialist party which stands for an alternative to capitalism is necessary. In 2009 I was elected into the Bundestag for our party on its election list in the federal state of Lower Saxony. I am of the opinion that our work inside parliament should first and foremost be used, as Rosa Luxemburg wrote more than hundred years ago, to expose the hypocrisy of the bourgeois parties, to propagate our political alternative, spread the demands of extra-parliamentary movements and strengthen the resistance locally. I was always opposed to viewing parliamentary positions as an end in itself.

I am also active in the Anti-capitalist Left (AKL) to help build a rank-and-file left wing in the party which can win majorities for anti-capitalist and socialist policies. In the party and in the AKL I have met comrades from SAV, who are also members of DIE LINKE. Through working together for a period of months I could see that my ideas and the ideas of SAV about a combative, democratic and socialist LINKE are similar.

Just like the comrades from SAV I don’t think that the present crisis is just a crisis of the financial markets, but is a systemic crisis of capitalism. This crisis cannot be solved through a redistribution of wealth, because the driving force of capitalism is the maximisation of profit. Therefore a solution can only be found through the socialisation of the means of production and an ecological-social planning in a socialist society. Our task is, starting from the day-to-day problems of the people, to show a socialist way out and build a bridge to a socialist alternative.

The rulers always say there is no alternative to capitalism. But the worldwide destruction of the environment, wars and the dramatic worsening of living conditions for millions of people, means for me that no other conclusion can be drawn but the fight for a socialist society – otherwise capitalism will destroy the civilising necessities of life. We have to strive to formulate our proposals in a concrete not abstract way. Starting with the fights against low wages, lay-offs, social cuts, for a shorter working week without loss of pay and with the creation of new jobs, for state-financed investment programmes in education, health, social services etc. it is necessary to link this to anti-capitalist ideas and to make clear that lasting improvements are only possible on the basis of overcoming the capitalist profit economy.

To change social relations in a fundamental way we need to win the majority in society. This is only possible through stimulating self-activity as through this more and more people will come into conflict with the system. This will not be achieved through parliamentary coalitions with bourgeois parties like SPD and Greens.

SAV members fight inside DIE LINKE against an adaptation towards SPD and Greens. A strong SAV strengthens the left in DIE LINKE and helps to prevent a further shift to the right along the lines of the “Democratic Socialist Forum” (FDS, a right-wing current in the party). SAV comrades combine daily activities to develop resistance and countervailing power through building DIE LINKE, the party’s youth wing and trade unions with the idea of a socialist transformation of society. In the coming general election campaign I will together with other SAV members and the whole party fight for a strongest possible re-entry of DIE LINKE into the Bundestag. Strengthening SAV and building DIE LINKE are no contradiction.

I was particularly impressed of the activities of SAV members at the Charité hospital in building the trade union group there, where exemplary trade union campaigns have been developed. I had the opportunity to meet members of the Committee for a Workers’ International (CWI) at an international gathering and see a real international and socialist association. Especially the role of the comrades from the Democratic Socialist Movement (DSM) in the miners’ strikes and the building of a new workers’ party in South Africa and the battle of Xekinima for the unity of the Greek left on a clear socialist basis, are examples of how the socialist left should approach its tasks.

As an MP I have always donated high amounts for the extra-parliamentary movements. The SAV proposes that all MP’s should only take an average skilled workers’ wage in order to make sure that no one becomes an MP out of selfish interests and because it is important not to be privileged in comparison to the people you represent. Therefore I decided to take 2,400 Euros from my monthly income as an MP for my subsistence, orientated at my wage which I received before I became an MP, and donate everything above for social movements and political projects.

Heidrun Dittrich
http://www.socialistworld.net/doc/6412

Leo
1st August 2013, 18:10
The transfer of the year, congratulations. The CWI is now a parliamentary politician nearer to taking power.

ind_com
1st August 2013, 18:49
How are the CWI MPs combating capitalism in practice?

Sentinel
1st August 2013, 19:30
Well, we believe that parliamentary positions provide a platform for revolutionary ideas, and pushes the general discourse to the left, affecting consciousness. This is the main reason; indeed we do not believe in a parliamentary road to power, and make this clear all the time which is very important.

But also practicewise, Joe Higgins, Paul Murphy and other CWI members have been very active besides their own countries also around the world, supporting and participating in workers struggles. And no, I'm not talking about guerilla warfare or armed insurrections, but working to build the forces of the workers movement.

Our work in South Africa is a good example, also around Campaign Kazachstan, etc. I do understand and respect that not everyone here believes in the same tactics as we do, but that is more of a theoretical rather than news issue debate perhaps.

n0b0dy
1st August 2013, 23:01
I'm a member of the youth organisation of DIE LINKE and was politicized strongly by SAV. Meanwhile I tend more to the positions of the 'emancipatory left' (Ema.Li). The Ema.Li stands for a radical democratic, social liberal and emancipatory policy. For example for the unconditional basic income, and supported the alternative lenin-critic demonstration to remember Luxemburg and Liebknecht because the old demonstration is overrun Lenin, Trotsky and even Stalin pictures.
The SAV in my city does good work in DIE LINKE and organize interesting events. And indeed like Heidrun Dittrich said the SAV is a good counterweight against some people in the FDS. Too bad the're still stuck in their old leninist theories...

L.J.Solidarity
2nd August 2013, 02:08
Meanwhile I tend more to the positions of the 'emancipatory left' (Ema.Li). The Ema.Li stands for a radical democratic, social liberal and emancipatory policy.
And it stands for coalitions with the SPD, doesn't it?

Back to topic: Heidrun Dittrich will only be an MP until the election on September 23, as Die Linke in Lower Saxony moved to the right a bit and she was not elected as a candidate this time.

n0b0dy
2nd August 2013, 12:42
And it stands for coalitions with the SPD, doesn't it?
Yes, but there is nothing wrong with it if the SPD returns to social democratic policy. Like Katja Kipping (party leader and member of Ema.Li) said, DIE LINKE would immediately join a coalition of SPD & the Greens if they would introduce a minnimum wage, ban weapon exports, abolish welfare sanctions etc. Its the direction thats important and if real improvements for the daily live of the people are possible - why not?
I don't think the SAV strategy to never form any government with pro-capitalist partys will get the Left out of marginality. However, the SAV and Ema.Li have the emphasis on social movements and non-parliamentary struggles in common.

Q
2nd August 2013, 13:08
Yes, but there is nothing wrong with it if the SPD returns to social democratic policy. Like Katja Kipping (party leader and member of Ema.Li) said, DIE LINKE would immediately join a coalition of SPD & the Greens if they would introduce a minnimum wage, ban weapon exports, abolish welfare sanctions etc. Its the direction thats important and if real improvements for the daily live of the people are possible - why not?
I don't think the SAV strategy to never form any government with pro-capitalist partys will get the Left out of marginality. However, the SAV and Ema.Li have the emphasis on social movements and non-parliamentary struggles in common.
The "we need to be realistic and come out of marginality" card has been played many times. In reality any coalition government with a pro-capitalist party, like the SPD, would bind us to that policy. It would in result cripple the movement as it would be anti-proletarian (a natural consequence of being pro-capitalist). You could then break the coalition of course, but it's better to not enter it in the first place. We need a principled opposition: We can only accept our programme to be fully implemented; that is, we can only accept a dismantling of the existing state and a rise to power of our class, through its own institutions.

L.J.Solidarity
2nd August 2013, 13:41
Besides the fact that the SPD and the Greens are deeply rooted in neoliberalism now and would never actually ban weapon exports and abolish welfare sanctions (except maybe if they enlarged the German armed forces enough to buy all the weapons made in Germany themselves and cut welfare so much that basically everybody would be on sanctions all the time ;)), I'm pretty sure participation in government doesn't bring the left out of marginality. Examples from across Europe in the past few decades have either thrown the party joining a "social democratic" government into permanent and final marginality (PRC in Italy) or effectively brought the party out of the left (several parties in Scandinavian countries).
I guess Die Linke would follow the Scandinavian model, the PDS was on the way towards that before the fusion with the WASG and now many eastern state organisations of the united party (particularly the "ruling" one in Brandenburg, of course) are only prevented from breaking with any form of socialism by the federal party. Probably such a break will occur on the national level after 2014 - when a new system of delegate allocation will give the eastern state parties a built-in majority at federal party congress - as soon as an SPD-led government becomes mathematically possible through a Bundestag election.

Redmau5
2nd August 2013, 21:26
The transfer of the year, congratulations. The CWI is now a parliamentary politician nearer to taking power.

Just like the ICC. ;)

Coggeh
3rd August 2013, 03:20
In reality, talk of when the CWI or any revolutionary socialist organisation would enter government is redundant. Despite what trolls believe, the CWI doesn't have any faith in elections to change society, we use them as a platform to raise workers struggles and have done from the very outset. Our track record speaks volumes in this context.

We have always taken the position against entering any 'broad left' or any pro capitalist government on the basis that a revolutionary socialist transformation of society is not borne out of election seats but mobilising the working class on a socialist programme to overthrow capitalism.

Yes we will enter political left mass workers groupings but will fight for a socialist programme, such as the ULA in Ireland which we were criticised for being 'ultra left' for calling for a socialist programme by the SWP. We were told we would 'scare' away working class people and the working class weren't ready for the word "socialism".

Leo:

The transfer of the year, congratulations. The CWI is now a parliamentary politician nearer to taking power.

The working class endorse a socialist programme and you scoff. I know this is a transfer and not an election but its obvious to you that any organisation that has a seat is automatically not a revolutionary organisation.