Log in

View Full Version : MacShane urges 'all working class' MP shortlists



Dennis the 'Bloody Peasant'
26th July 2012, 09:00
Yeah...or you could just have all working class and erase the current political class for good and forever. Just saying.

Only people on the minimum wage should be allowed to stand for Parliament in 10% of seats to make politics more representative, a Labour MP has said.
Denis MacShane said the backgrounds of MPs from all the main parties at Westminster had become far too narrow.
Party leaders were keen to talk about recruiting more working class or ethnic minority candidates, he argued.
But it would take something as drastic - and potentially unpopular - as all-women shortlists to make it happen.
"The country desperately needs new political ideas, but the intellectual reservoir from which we draw our political leaders has become a paddling pool, when what we actually need is a raging torrent to get the country going again," he told BBC News.
Mr MacShane, an Oxford university graduate who worked as a journalist before becoming MP for Rotherham in 1994, said there needed to be fewer candidates with his kind of background in the future.

(more at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-18969789)

Lynx
26th July 2012, 11:21
Random selection would make sure that parliament was comprised of people from all layers of society.

ed miliband
26th July 2012, 12:39
Random selection would make sure that parliament was comprised of people from all layers of society.

and why would we want that?

Tim Finnegan
31st July 2012, 22:49
Even if this proposal had any value- and it doesn't- it wouldn't amount to anything more than a PR exercise. People on minimum wage simply aren't MP material, the structure is built so that they(/we) couldn't possibly be, so all we'd see is them throwing a few poor bastards into unwinnable races in Tory safe-seats, and maybe, maybe, a token few back-benchers with strict orders to keep their mouths shut, just so they can pretend that, no, they're taking it seriously, honest!

Vladimir Innit Lenin
1st August 2012, 23:31
Ah, the co-opting of a few members of the working class. I see where this proposal is headed...

Rooted in the labourism of the late 19th Century in Britain. :rolleyes:

Die Neue Zeit
4th August 2012, 04:34
Why isn't this thread in the Politics forum?


Rooted in the labourism of the late 19th Century in Britain. :rolleyes:

So says a defender of the British Labour model over more Continental alternatives.

Yuppie Grinder
4th August 2012, 05:50
The idea of working class people working within the bourgeois state seems completely impossible to me.

cynicles
4th August 2012, 06:45
The idea of working class people working within the bourgeois state seems completely impossible to me.

Not to mention a complete waste of time and potentially damaging to the cause of socialism, 'let's go on a wild goose chase!'

brigadista
4th August 2012, 09:34
what difference will it make if they will just follow the usual party line of the tories or labour or lib dems? will be pure class tokenism

Vladimir Innit Lenin
4th August 2012, 15:34
So says a defender of the British Labour model over more Continental alternatives.

Comrade, have you read my intellectual paper entitled "re: for a post-labouristy monetary politico-policy as a eulogy of neologys?" :confused: