Log in

View Full Version : French Socialist Insurrection 2012



Tim Cornelis
18th March 2012, 20:27
French candidate calls for insurrection and a socialist republic.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/mar/18/jean-luc-melenchon-french-presidential-poll?newsfeed=true


Far-left firebrand Jean-Luc Mélenchon calls for a 'civic insurrection' in France

Leader of Leftist Front makes gains in French presidential race but François Hollande and Nicolas Sarkozy still likely to top polls

Jean-Luc Mélenchon, the charismatic far-left firebrand whose anti-capitalist stance has seen him rise sharply in the French presidential polls, on Sunday told a vast Paris street rally that France should rise up in a "civic insurrection".

Mélenchon's symbolic open-air rally at the Place de la Bastille, emblem of the French revolution, attracted tens of thousands in an important show of force for France's "Left of the Left", buoyed by the financial crisis and disillusionment with the main political parties.

The MEP – who is famous for his scathing, banker-bashing rhetoric – is running for president representing a coalition of leftists which includes the once-powerful Communist party.

A one-time Trotskyist and former teacher, he spent 30 years in the Socialist party, where he served as a minister and senator, before leaving to form his own Front de Gauche or Leftist Front.

He recently surged above the 10% mark in the polls, a sharp rise which has eaten into the score of the Socialist frontrunner François Hollande and delighted the rightwing president Nicolas Sarkozy, who is seeking to exploit differences on the left in his difficult battle for re-election.

Sarkozy has praised Mélenchon's charisma against what he has called the blandness of Hollande.

Mélenchon claims he is winning the ideological battle of the French presidential election, saying his anti-fat cat stance had been mimicked by both Hollande's proposed 75% tax on income over €1m (£830,000) and Sarkozy's promised crackdown on tax exiles.

Hollande and Sarkozy are currently tipped to take the top two places in the 22 April first round and face each other in a 6 May runoff.

Other candidates in the race are the National Front's Marine Le Pen and the centrist François Bayrou.

Mélenchon is locked in a vicious battle with Le Pen for the protest and working class vote. A favourite on TV debate shows for his explosive performances, he directs his most virulent jibes at Le Pen, whom he has called "a bat", "half-demented" and a "dark presence". Last autumn he also accused Hollande of being a "pedal boat captain".

The French left still labours under the shadow of April 2002, when the Socialist candidate was knocked out of the election by the far-right Jean-Marie Le Pen after several leftist candidates fragmented the vote. Pollsters say an upset of that kind is unlikely this year.

But Hollande has recently stressed the importance of voting in the first round for the person most likely to win against Sarkozy, ie himself.

Mélenchon is expected to rally behind Hollande in the second-round runoff. Polls show Hollande would easily win the final vote. Mélenchon could then possibly be considered for a ministerial seat in a future leftwing government.

His manifesto promises include a return to retirement at 60 (from the proposed 62) and capping maximum annual salaries at €340,000, with any earnings above that to be confiscated by the state.

Part of Mélenchon's high showing in the polls comes from the low profile of other far-left and Trotskyist candidates in this election.

The latest poll by Ifop for Le Journal du Dimanche put Sarkozy on 27.5%, Hollande on 27% and Le Pen on 17% in the first round. If the poll is correct, Hollande would beat Sarkozy in the second round by 54% to 46%.

A BBC-requested poll showed 43 percent of the French population opposes capitalism.

I'm afraid he is not too radical...

Vladimir Innit Lenin
18th March 2012, 20:33
His greatest use could be in splitting the 'working class vote'...i.e. shifting out the fascists. If Hollande is going to take most of the 'left' vote, then Melenchon may hopefully at least detract votes from the far-right, and also get some air-time for genuine left ideas. After all, that's all bourgeois elections of this kind are good for, right?

Tim Cornelis
18th March 2012, 20:35
His greatest use could be in splitting the 'working class vote'...i.e. shifting out the fascists. If Hollande is going to take most of the 'left' vote, then Melenchon may hopefully at least detract votes from the far-right, and also get some air-time for genuine left ideas. After all, that's all bourgeois elections of this kind are good for, right?

The most significant about this is that it shows the French people are becoming more disillusioned with capitalism, not the 'call' itself.

NoPasaran1936
19th March 2012, 17:14
The most significant about this is that it shows the French people are becoming more disillusioned with capitalism, not the 'call' itself.
A stepping stone at the very least however, atleast with anti-capitalist candidates, it raises socialism, communism, marxism etc's profile. More and more people would look into the alternatives, and see there's a few. And who knows, in a few years time the French may just get fed up with authority and say a big fuck you, and anarchism rises through...


We can only hope.

A Marxist Historian
21st March 2012, 00:44
French candidate calls for insurrection and a socialist republic.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/mar/18/jean-luc-melenchon-french-presidential-poll?newsfeed=true



A BBC-requested poll showed 43 percent of the French population opposes capitalism.

I'm afraid he is not too radical...

As explained in the Guardian story, the guy is "expected" to vote for the SP candidate in the second round, and then hopefully get to be a minister in her cabinet.

His populistic anti-banker rap doesn't mean a damn thing, especially in France, where almost half the population thinks capitalism is a bad idea. He's just another bourgeois candidate in the marketplace of ideas, cheaper by the dozen. The best radical that money can buy.

-M.H.-

Dire Helix
21st March 2012, 02:40
From Guardian:


Far-left firebrand Jean-Luc Mélenchon calls for a 'civic insurrection' in FranceAny so-called "ultra-leftism" is just a form of liberalism masked by vague anti-capitalist rhetoric. Ultra-leftists are all without fail opportunists and counter-revolutionaries and Melenchon is no exception. French workers should see past the lies of Hollande, Melenchon and other bourgeois politicians, organize and seek a truly revolutionary alternative.

bcbm
21st March 2012, 02:53
i don't think someone seeking elected office is an 'ultra leftist'

DaringMehring
21st March 2012, 03:08
Melenchon is reformist -- he's attached himself to the reformist PCF, and will attach himself to the PS for a minister's portfolio. His revolutionary sounding words are just the usual window-dressing that reformists put on to get credibility among militants.

Lutte Ouvriere has explained how Melenchon divides workers by playing to French chauvinism ("the Germans are your problem!" rather than "the capitalists are your problem!") his message being basically the same as the likes of Le Pen. http://www.lutte-ouvriere-journal.org/?act=artl&num=2276&id=17

Generally he represents "the reformist movement in the labor movement" "with, moreover, the illusion of being distinguished from Holland and what he represents." http://www.nathalie-arthaud.info/-L-importance-du-vote-pour-la-.html

TheGodlessUtopian
22nd March 2012, 04:56
I am surprised that with so much of the French population supporting anti-capitalism the left there hasn't been able to gain a larger powerbase; I figure that the revolutionary candidates would have more of a sway.

Ostrinski
22nd March 2012, 05:13
High levels of anti-capitalist sentiment don't mean anything unless the working class can organize itself properly.

TheGodlessUtopian
22nd March 2012, 05:15
High levels of anti-capitalist sentiment don't mean anything unless the working class can organize itself properly.

Which you figure the socialist organizers would have taken advantage of, hence why I am confused.

Grenzer
22nd March 2012, 05:24
The most significant about this is that it shows the French people are becoming more disillusioned with capitalism, not the 'call' itself.

But are they? I mean I hate to be the pessimist here, but it seems a bit hasty to conclude that "Yay, the French are giving up capitalism!" If you look at the actual data, communism(up to the present moment, in fact) has been becoming less and less popular in France. I forget where I read that, but it was a graph and I saw it within the past few days.. don't feel like trying to find it again. The French have a long tradition of social-democracy, and I'm not at all convinced that recent activity in France suggests anything beyond that. If anything, it's the far-right, not the far-left that is gaining.

It seems to me that this is a reflection of a fundamentally incorrect strategy on the part of the left, if you actually look at the facts, the working class has been stagnating and deteriorating for the past three decades. Logically, this should lead workers to embrace communism; but in fact, we're seeing the exact opposite. Seems to be reflective of the extreme fragmentation and dysfunction of the left imo.

Ostrinski
22nd March 2012, 05:30
Grenzer hit the nail on the head.

It is in fact the far right that has been gaining ground in the past few years, mainly because they have been much more adaptive in their political strategy. The traditional center-left progressive parties have been losing ground as the nationalists become the only ones actually trying to reach the working class. The leftist parties have an inability to reach anyone beyond their own constituency of middle class radicals because they just regurgitate the same rhetoric they've been using since the 1920's.

Vladimir Innit Lenin
22nd March 2012, 08:05
Ultra-leftists are all without fail opportunists and counter-revolutionaries

Any proof for this idiotically misplaced vitriol? :rolleyes: