Das Kapital Chapter 1 Video (Updated, much better)

[Broletariat]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWwFspFKPY

The differences begin at around 4:20

[KurtFF8]

What's wrong with David Harvey's class on Capital Volume 1 (http://davidharvey.org/reading-capital/) :confused:

[Broletariat]

What's wrong with David Harvey's class on Capital Volume 1 (http://davidharvey.org/reading-capital/) :confused:

Mine's 15 minutes, and talks about dildos along with using humorous Marxist puppetry.

As for actual criticisms, Harvey just seems boring and I honestly didn't understand Capital through listening to him at all, the way he talks about stuff just doesn't jive with me, so I imagine that's the case for other people too.

[Nikolay]

Mine's 15 minutes, and talks about dildos along with using humorous Marxist puppetry.

As for actual criticisms, Harvey just seems boring and I honestly didn't understand Capital through listening to him at all, the way he talks about stuff just doesn't jive with me, so I imagine that's the case for other people too.

I agree that the way he explains things is boring, but some of his clarifications/explanations have helped me a bit. I'd enjoy a humorous Marxist puppetry a lot more. :)

[Broletariat]

I agree that the way he explains things is boring, but some of his clarifications/explanations have helped me a bit. I'd enjoy a humorous Marxist puppetry a lot more. :)

You shall enjoy the next video on Fetishism greatly then, the first 2 minutes is the puppets, there's even a song by our friend moneybags.

[A Revolutionary Tool]

What's wrong with David Harvey's class on Capital Volume 1 (http://davidharvey.org/reading-capital/) :confused:
Doesn't he get bored of reading the same book to the class every single year for more than 30 years?

[TheGodlessUtopian]

Doesn't he get bored of reading the same book to the class every single year for more than 30 years?

You figure he would but this is the same dilemma I encounter with all educators: how don't they get bored? The thrill of never knowing when you will be fired because of uninvolved parents complaints? :confused:

[KurtFF8]

Doesn't he get bored of reading the same book to the class every single year for more than 30 years?

I think in one of those classes he said something along the lines of getting a new perspective each time (depending on the students as well)

[socialistjustin]

Absolute rubbish. Think you should fire the producer as the production value is shocking.


Really, it was pretty good and simple to understand. Thanks for making it.

[Savage]

Anyone investing blind faith in Harvey’s theory should take into account the Marxist criticisms of his work, such as this one (http://libcom.org/library/review-david-harveys-limits-capital-paul-mattick-jr).

[Broletariat]

Absolute rubbish. Think you should fire the producer as the production value is shocking.


Really, it was pretty good and simple to understand. Thanks for making it.

Yea, I was like :(

Then I was like :)