Log in

View Full Version : mitchell abidor (webmaster of MIA) is a certified lame



HEAD ICE
3rd October 2011, 21:08
Mitchell Abidor is not a marxist (not an insult, he will tell you he hates marxism) and also a collosal idiot. His moronic "translator's note" on Bordiga's "Auschwitz, the Great Alibi" is embarrassing enough, but now he outdoes himself by giving an incredibly romantic history of Kemal Ataturk and Kemalism.

http://www.marxists.org/history/turkey/kemalism/history.htm


Yes western ways, dress, and music were better than the Turkish, but as his linguistic and historical theories demonstrated, in imitating them the Turks were doing nothing but adopting ways that would always have been theirs had they not been led astray by Arabs, Persians, and Islam. Turkey, for Atatürk, was a western country that didn’t know it was one. Kemalism made Turkey what it should have been. What it still is.

ZeroNowhere
4th October 2011, 23:10
God, I must have skipped that 'translator's note' when I had read it, since I don't recall having seen it before. I'm fairly sure that a translator's note is supposed to be about, you know, the act of translating the article, not a polemic about why it's the paragon of evil. That really is quite woeful. This isn't much of an improvement.