malcom
16th September 2011, 06:12
Is there any group actively trying to replace capitalism in the US or west?
But with an economic system that prices everything in labor time, where production is decided by consumer spending (as opposed to a command economy), pays all workers an equal income with perhaps some variation for difficult jobs (as opposed to having a labor market which determines worker pay) and has a democratic check on the top layer of management of the economy?
The only things I have been able to find are:
Leftist Movements
They don't seem to be selling the public on an alternative economic system. They advocate improvements to the current system.
Parecon
This seems almost identical to capitalism where a worker's standard of living is based on their ability to sell themselves in the labor market and based on the profitability of the company they work for and will lead to the same income inequality that plaques the system today.
Resource Based Economy
This is something promoted by Jacque Fresco's The Venus Project and the Zeitgeist Movement. Although their goal of creating a society where everyone has a high standard of living using the latest technology is in line with what I think an economy should be, their economic system for reaching that goal is to make everything free and not pay people to work.
Not using some kind of money to ration goods and pay people for working will never work and is complete fantasy. Plus they do not want any democracy. It is a shame because they have become somewhat popular.
Technocracy
This was a group in the US that may have been the most popular anti-capitalist movement in US history. Jacque Fresco was a member so it is similar to the RBE above. They wanted to replace government and business with a scientific plan. However, they wanted to use energy units as money and this simply cannot work either.
.
So does anyone know of any organized effort to sell the public on an alternative economic system that uses labor vouchers?
Paul Cockshott advocates this. But he is one person, not an organized movement. And I don't think he is trying to build any kind of movement.
But with an economic system that prices everything in labor time, where production is decided by consumer spending (as opposed to a command economy), pays all workers an equal income with perhaps some variation for difficult jobs (as opposed to having a labor market which determines worker pay) and has a democratic check on the top layer of management of the economy?
The only things I have been able to find are:
Leftist Movements
They don't seem to be selling the public on an alternative economic system. They advocate improvements to the current system.
Parecon
This seems almost identical to capitalism where a worker's standard of living is based on their ability to sell themselves in the labor market and based on the profitability of the company they work for and will lead to the same income inequality that plaques the system today.
Resource Based Economy
This is something promoted by Jacque Fresco's The Venus Project and the Zeitgeist Movement. Although their goal of creating a society where everyone has a high standard of living using the latest technology is in line with what I think an economy should be, their economic system for reaching that goal is to make everything free and not pay people to work.
Not using some kind of money to ration goods and pay people for working will never work and is complete fantasy. Plus they do not want any democracy. It is a shame because they have become somewhat popular.
Technocracy
This was a group in the US that may have been the most popular anti-capitalist movement in US history. Jacque Fresco was a member so it is similar to the RBE above. They wanted to replace government and business with a scientific plan. However, they wanted to use energy units as money and this simply cannot work either.
.
So does anyone know of any organized effort to sell the public on an alternative economic system that uses labor vouchers?
Paul Cockshott advocates this. But he is one person, not an organized movement. And I don't think he is trying to build any kind of movement.