Log in

View Full Version : The Religion of Evil (article by Boris Kagarlitsky on conspiracy theories)



Die Neue Zeit
11th August 2011, 01:57
This article by the Russian Marxist can be found in Moscow Times. I found it most interesting because it tied directly to my old thread discussing new agitational methods:

One Born Every Minute: Blog on Agitation and Demagogues (http://www.revleft.com/vb/one-born-every-t144497/index.html) (original post)
(Comments) (http://www.revleft.com/vb/one-born-every-t144497/index.html?p=1916694)

The Religion of Evil (http://www.themoscowtimes.com/opinion/article/the-religion-of-evil/441231.html)

By Boris Kagarlitsky

While the left argues with the right and nationalists argue with pro-Westerners, a new ideology has arisen in society that has the potential to win supremacy over the minds of the masses.

People do not have faith in free-market forces, much less in the government. In place of all the failed ideologies of recent decades, people are believing more in conspiracy theories.

But this is not to say these people believe that conspiracies are behind specific events or phenomena. The conspiracy theories have more to do with a new global vision, a worldview contending that every social event of any significance is being guided by some external and inexorable evil force.

According to this theory, an anonymous elite uses the political process to manipulate and control people’s behaviors: The financial and political elite stage revolutions, organize economic crises and finance social discontent. In short, they control the global chaos.

To Russian adherents of this type of conspiracy theory, the United States is the main conspirator, regardless of which president is in the White House. These adherents exploit the cultural baggage accumulated during the Soviet era for their own purposes.

The difference is that Soviet propaganda critical of the United States was focused on exposing the evils of capitalism, whereas the current criticisms serve as an excuse and a cover for Russia’s own corrupt form of state capitalism.

There is no talk of the universal shortcomings of capitalism that affect Russia and the West equally, but only of the ill will of the Americans who, for some reason, have supposedly sent economic and political crises to Russia.

Believers in modern conspiracy theories assert that even floods, tsunamis and earthquakes are the handiwork of evil plotters.

We are thus confronted by the appearance of a new and pagan religion. The world is not guided by the will of a single, benevolent higher power, but by a vast number of conflicting dark forces.

What’s more, adherents of this belief hold that the only way to counter this threat is not to oppose evil with good but to oppose it with even more powerful evil.

What is the secret behind the stunning success of this religion of evil? It frees the common man of any responsibility for his life and actions. It does not promise him the ability to influence the course of history or even to be the master of his own behavior. Rather than promote the idea that people are nothing but cattle, this belief system is the natural outcome of people who agree with this assessment.

This belief in an all-embracing conspiracy not only reinforces people’s tendency to view themselves as little more than cattle, but also makes them smugly self-satisfied in rejecting enlightenment and reason. Even worse, they consider any grassroots attempt to change society from below, including social protest, as pointless.

The people’s reflexive tendency to pacify themselves and to rationalize their own passivity is what finally transforms people completely into cattle.

As the joke about the psychologist says: “The treatment was a success: The patient continues to wet his bed, but now he is proud of it.”

ÑóẊîöʼn
11th August 2011, 05:19
Good article, although I would dispute that people have a "reflexive tendency to pacify themselves" - I think we have seen more than enough evidence in recent times that this is not the case.

Die Neue Zeit
11th August 2011, 13:22
My older point was that, for the most backward sections of the working class, the left should not be above resorting to conspiracy theories for agitation, since sloganeering has become stale. Note the second link in my OP above, "Comments."

Jose Gracchus
11th August 2011, 16:04
The most putrid, stupefyingly elitist lesson you could possibly have gotten from the article.

Die Neue Zeit
14th August 2011, 05:08
The most putrid, stupefyingly elitist lesson you could possibly have gotten from the article.

So you're discounting the recent scientific findings in April on the physical brain structures of more conservative people vs. those of more progressive people, especially the former being based on fear?

RED DAVE
11th September 2011, 00:25
So you're discounting the recent scientific findings in April on the physical brain structures of more conservative people vs. those of more progressive people, especially the former being based on fear?(Since you've linked to this thread, I'm answering you belatedly.)

The Left, for very good reasons, has always had at the core of its agitation, propaganda, art work, etc., a appeal to reason. Even when the strongest emotions are evoked, the purpose of the evocation is understanding leading to conscious action. The conspiracy theories and other bilge of the Right, have a very different purpose: to paralyze the will, to obscure reality, to teach reliance on authoritarian methods and leaders for guidance.

Once again, DNZ, a fundamentally conservative outlook towards the working class comes out. (This attitude mirrors that of the pre-WWI German SPD, which you love so much.)

Maybe if you ever were in the working class, agitating, propagandizing and teaching, you might have a different attitude.

RED DAVE

Die Neue Zeit
11th September 2011, 00:42
At the core of its education and propaganda, yes indeed there are appeals to reason. However, that falls flat when it comes to agitation, yet I also implied the limitations of conspiracy theories and other sensationalist agitation: only for the most backward sections of the working class.


Maybe if you ever were in the working class, agitating, propagandizing and teaching, you might have a different attitude.

I am, though (except for the agitating part).

Hit The North
11th September 2011, 01:23
At the core of its education and propaganda, yes indeed there are appeals to reason. However, that falls flat when it comes to agitation


You reckon?


I am, though (except for the agitating part).

Ah, well, there you go.

RED DAVE
11th September 2011, 01:28
At the core of its education and propaganda, yes indeed there are appeals to reason. However, that falls flat when it comes to agitation, yet I also implied the limitations of conspiracy theories and other sensationalist agitation: for the most backward sections of the working class.This is gibberish. If you had ever been engaged in agitation, you would know this.


Maybe if you ever were in the working class, agitating, propagandizing and teaching, you might have a different attitude.
I am, though (except for the agitating part).I see no signs in your writing, either in content or style, that you have any sense whatsover as to how to work within the working class as a revolutionary.

RED DAVE

teflon_john
11th September 2011, 01:44
My older point was that, for the most backward sections of the working class, the left should not be above resorting to conspiracy theories for agitation, since sloganeering has become stale. Note the second link in my OP above, "Comments."



dude, you're kinda weird.

Die Neue Zeit
30th September 2011, 05:56
It's thinking outside the box on agitational methods.