Log in

View Full Version : Valid Argument Point



Johnny Kerosene
19th July 2011, 05:13
I'm watching a movie called "The Baader Meinhoff Complex" and I just heard a damn fine argument point for people to use if they're arguing about the vietnam war with someone for whatever reason.

Point 1: America had a right to defend itself by initiating a preventative war against Vietnam.

Counterpoint: By that logic Hitler had a right to attack Poland.

So much win. In this thread, awesome or useful counter points that are short, sweet and to the point to be used in common arguments. This should probably be somewhere other chit-chat (maybe I dunno) but I wasn't sure where a good place would be, so I figured if nothing else, it can't get moved to chit-chat.

praxis1966
19th July 2011, 05:46
Point 1: Marxist theory has too many holes in it.

Counterpoint: Have you ever read any Marx?

Note: This always works because the answer is always no.

Broletariat
19th July 2011, 05:46
Point 1: Marxist theory has too many holes in it.

Counterpoint: Have you ever read any Marx?

Note: This always works because the answer is always no.


In my case, the person usually lies.

praxis1966
19th July 2011, 05:53
In my case, the person usually lies.

That's when you ask them to characterize the differences between Marxist and Hegelian dialectic. That oughtta do them.

La Comédie Noire
19th July 2011, 06:09
" It looks good on paper, but..."

"Have you read the paper?"

"..."

Obs
19th July 2011, 07:01
That's when you ask them to characterize the differences between Marxist and Hegelian dialectic. That oughtta do them.

Rosa would've been all over this thread by now.

I miss her.

Broletariat
19th July 2011, 07:01
That's when you ask them to characterize the differences between Marxist and Hegelian dialectic. That oughtta do them.

Yea but I've read Marx and couldn't tell you that >_>

Manic Impressive
19th July 2011, 07:18
That's when you ask them to characterize the differences between Marxist and Hegelian dialectic. That oughtta do them.
That would do me too