Log in

View Full Version : Internal Contradictions within relationships?



The Man
8th July 2011, 07:01
Please tell me if I am applying this in the wrong way because of my limited knowledge of Dialectical Materialism. Could D-M be applied to marriages at all?

Kronsteen
10th July 2011, 07:49
Well, first the disclaimer: I don't accept DM, because it's terms are so vague and elastic they can be made to apply to anything.

...which means yes, you could talk about marriage dialectically. It's a fusion of two people into a unit, and the unit's behavior and development is partly the result of the two independent wills in the unit moving, butting, compromising and trying to find ways to find fulfillment - both individually and as a duo. Good marriage are a harmonious blending, so I'm told.

The two are even 'opposites' in a sense, and the way the marriage develops (or falls apart) comes from internal movement - and if the movement/conflict stops, you've got only an empty shell.

But honestly, if you want to sit down and analyse your relationship in terms designed to describe the class struggle (in Marx), or the movement of atoms (Engels), or the march of science (Hegel)...then I suggest you need to put more space between your political life and your personal life.

Remember, even if dialectics works, it doesn't allow for the making of plans. It only explains things after they happen.

John Seneca
4th September 2011, 02:33
DM is an all-encompassing awesome worldview and could surely be applied to anything. Surely there are internal contradictions in relationships, as there are contradictions between the male and female sex, and though in an idael state there wouldbe none, we are products of our time and our culture and so on and so forth. Now tell us of your problem.