Log in

View Full Version : Jack Straw is not a trot.



Post-Something
6th July 2011, 03:30
Just found this fantastic letter from 1994, from Jack Straw to the Independent. Pretty funny if you ask me, thought I'd share..



Not a Trot

Dear Comrade Editor: In his report on President Arafat's funeral ceremony in Cairo (13 November), Robert Fisk uttered such a malicious libel against me that I am certain that even the late George Carman QC would have taken my case without fee.
Mr Fisk called me an "old Trot". There is a very long list of old Trots who really were Trots who will be as outraged as me by this calumny. (These types can usually now be found in the City, appearing on quiz shows or ranting in certain national newspapers.)
Whatever other frailties I may have (many), I have been consistent in my opposition to Trotskyism and the false consciousness it engenders. (I was first taught to spot a Trot at 50 yards in 1965 by Mr Bert Ramelson, Yorkshire industrial organiser of the Communist Party.)
Yours fraternally,
JACK STRAW
Foreign Secretary
House of Commons
PS. Further reading. Isaac Deutscher: Trotsky (3 vols). Left Wing Communism, an Infantile Disorder, V I Lenin 1919 (a prescient warning about Trotskyist adventurism).


http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/letters/bbc-fights-for-the-arts-celebrity-help-for-starving-people-and-others-533363.html

Proukunin
6th July 2011, 03:41
We can share the women, We can share the wine...


I'm sorry lol. Jack Straw is my favorite Grateful Dead song.

JustMovement
6th July 2011, 07:05
Is this the same Jack Straw that served under Blair? I cant imagine his name anywhere near a communist party.

Also, I love the grateful dead song as well.

Martin Blank
6th July 2011, 08:10
We can share the women, We can share the wine...


I'm sorry lol. Jack Straw is my favorite Grateful Dead song.

That's right where I went when I saw the title of this thread. :thumbup1:

Post-Something
6th July 2011, 12:24
Yeah this is the same one that was under Blair. I've never heard that grateful dead song though, I'll have to give it a listen..

bailey_187
6th July 2011, 12:39
lol seen before, funny stuff

i think a few of the New Labour people were trotskyists tho in their youth IIRC

Post-Something
6th July 2011, 13:41
lol seen before, funny stuff

i think a few of the New Labour people were trotskyists tho in their youth IIRC

Yeah, you know I have the feeling that Labour politicians got steadily more allowing and impartial to the idea of communism, while starting off as quite afraid of it. And then maybe in the middle being the most radical about it. They probably just view it now as quite a nice idea that just couldn't happen.

Lyev
6th July 2011, 15:09
Yeah, Tony Blair actually cited Issac Deutscher's biographies of Trotsky as some his favourite reading on desert island discs not too long ago. He said something like, you could not really avoid Trotskyism in the '60s and '70s political milieu and this was the text that first got him interested in politics. :rolleyes:

human strike
6th July 2011, 16:28
Is this the same Jack Straw that served under Blair? I cant imagine his name anywhere near a communist party.

Why not? Quite a few of them were. They're not really that different after all...

Sasha
6th July 2011, 16:36
Jack Straw is not a trot.
he is an dick though...


(albeit one with an sense of humor it seems)