Log in

View Full Version : Nadezhda Krupskaya: How did she really die?



Unclebananahead
7th March 2011, 21:13
According to wikipedia:

According to Communist Party of the Soviet Union who referred to NKVD archives, she was poisoned by anti communist powers with a cake he sent as a present on her seventieth Julian birthday [22]

So, I'm a bit confused by that.

In 1939, Trotsky wrote the following:


Stalin always lived in fear of a protest on her part. She knew far too much. She knew the history of the party. She knew the place that Stalin occupied in this history. All of the latter day historiography which assigned to Stalin a place alongside of Lenin could not but appear revolting and insulting to her. Stalin feared Krupskaya just as he feared Gorky. Krupskaya was surrounded by an iron ring of the GPU. Her old friends disappeared one by one; those who delayed in dying were murdered either openly or secretly. Every step she took was supervised. Her articles appeared in the press only after interminable, insufferable and degrading negotiations between the censors and the author. She was forced to adopt emendations in her text, either to exalt Stalin or to rehabilitate the GPU. It is obvious that a whole number of vilest insertions of this type was made against Krupskaya’s will, and even without her knowledge. What recourse was there for the unfortunate crushed woman? Completely isolated, a heavy stone weighing upon her heart, uncertain what to do, in the toils of sickness, she dragged on her burdensome existence.

To all appearances, Stalin has lost the inclination to stage sensational trials which have already succeeded in exposing him before the whole world as the dirtiest, the most criminal and most repulsive figure in history. Nevertheless, it is by no means excluded that some sort of new trial will be staged, wherein new defendants will relate how Kremlin physicians under the leadership of Yagoda and Beria took measures to expedite Krupskaya’s demise.

But with or without the aid of physicians, the regime that Stalin had created for her undoubtedly cut short her life.

Thoughts?

Zhu Bailan
7th March 2011, 22:03
The wiki-source is Yuri Felshtinsky (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuri_Felshtinsky):

Felshtinsky has published a number of books on history of the Communist movement. In one of those books, Leaders the mobsters,[2] he described the Bolshevik party as a mafia-like organization where "almost no one died by a natural cause", based on hundreds of primary and secondary sources. This includes the poisoning of Vladimir Lenin, Felix Dzerzhinsky, and Maksim Gorky by Genrikh Yagoda on the orders from Joseph Stalin, the murders of Mikhail Frunze, Vyacheslav Menzhinsky, and Leon Trotsky, the poisoning of Stalin by Lavrenty Beria, and other similar episodes.

A left-wing german newspaper Junge Welt (http://www.anarchie.de/main-72751.html) wrote on 27 Feb. 2009:


She died unexpectedly on 27 February 1939 in Moscow. There were rumors that she had been poisoned by Stalin. The biography, published in the GDR is silent about the circumstances of her death, and published in English, Soviet biography of 1969 makes 23 February appear to be their death. That she died in agony from a late-diagnosed appendicitis, today to read in Russian Internet contributions.