Log in

View Full Version : The Transition to Communism



jmpeer
27th February 2011, 18:55
How do you envision the transition to communism?
Do you think it will be inevitable, incidental, or planned?
Do you think it needs to be revolutionary, reformist, or a combination?
Do you think it will be a domino effect, regions at a time, or needs to be all at once global?
Are there any necessary conditions or actions needed in the market or by communists?
Do you think communism is clear or organized enough to actually become a popular movement in the near future?


EDIT: Let me reword these questions.

Do you think the current model of capitalism will inevitably collapse, capitalism will change its model until it becomes communism, or communism must be a organized and planned revolution?

What are some of the conditions and actions you think will cause this?

Do you think some countries can use reformist measures and if so what kind and what portion of countries will do so?

Do you think communism needs to be globally popular before it starts, or can it be regional and win popularity by example and competition?

Do you think communists and communist ideology is organized enough to start making a come back in the near future?

In these questions and generally, how will the role of developed countries differ from developing countries?

Omsk
27th February 2011, 19:55
How do you envision the transition to communism?
Bloody but rewarding.(if the true communism emerges.)

Do you think it will be inevitable, incidental, or planned?
Planed,and inevitable.

Do you think it needs to be revolutionary, reformist, or a combination?
Combination,depends on the state.

Do you think it will be a domino effect, regions at a time, or needs to be all at once global?
Domino effect,like these Arab revolutions.

Do you think communism is clear or organized enough to actually become a popular movement in the near future?
Not yet,alot of people carrie the wounds of fake communist's and dictator who liked to be called communist,some time will have to pass.
In truth,there are so much variables,that this topic can be re-argued for milenia.

Magón
27th February 2011, 21:29
Do you think the current model of capitalism will inevitably collapse, capitalism will change its model until it becomes communism, or communism must be a organized and planned revolution?

I think the current model of Capitalism, and if any other form of Capitalism we haven't seen arise yet, comes to be, it will inevitably collapse on itself. I don't think it will collapse into Communism, that's just wishful thinking. Communism has to be organized and planned, sort of like a one of those Survivalists you hear about every so often who's got his bomb shelter, stacks of food and water, etc. ready for when the time comes. (By my little example, I just mean we have to be prepared two steps ahead of what's happening, and prepare for what's to come.)


What are some of the conditions and actions you think will cause this?

Over spending of mysterious money, economic collapse, rioting (like we see now), depending on whenever it happens, shortage of resources (at least in the US, UK/EU.)


Do you think some countries can use reformist measures and if so what kind and what portion of countries will do so?

Depends on what type of reformist measures are taken. If they're like the ones now, probably not, and you'll just see a regression in political idiocy, which isn't smarts, it's just more idiocy.


Do you think communism needs to be globally popular before it starts, or can it be regional and win popularity by example and competition?

Well if Communism can take off like the riots in North Africa and the Middle East. I don't see why it couldn't start regional, and win popularity with the rest of the world, wherever it may start. Just look at Tunisia. Their rioting started over food, and now Egypt's followed, Libya, Iran, Iraq, etc.


Do you think communists and communist ideology is organized enough to start making a come back in the near future?

No.

red cat
27th February 2011, 21:46
How do you envision the transition to communism?
Do you think it will be inevitable, incidental, or planned?
Do you think it needs to be revolutionary, reformist, or a combination?
Do you think it will be a domino effect, regions at a time, or needs to be all at once global?
Are there any necessary conditions or actions needed in the market or by communists?
Do you think communism is clear or organized enough to actually become a popular movement in the near future?


EDIT: Let me reword these questions.

Do you think the current model of capitalism will inevitably collapse, capitalism will change its model until it becomes communism, or communism must be a organized and planned revolution?

What are some of the conditions and actions you think will cause this?

Do you think some countries can use reformist measures and if so what kind and what portion of countries will do so?

Do you think communism needs to be globally popular before it starts, or can it be regional and win popularity by example and competition?

What Erich said, except that I don't think that what is happening in the Arabian countries is an example of the domino-effect.


Do you think communists and communist ideology is organized enough to start making a come back in the near future?

Yes, communism might emerge as a powerful global force within the next fifteen years or so.


In these questions and generally, how will the role of developed countries differ from developing countries?

Many developing countries will have their revolutions much before developed countries. While these happen, the developed countries will witness more and more violent and larger movements by the working class, and by the time most third world revolutions have taken place, insurrections will start in the imperialist countries.