Log in

View Full Version : Underrated figures



ed miliband
6th January 2011, 21:56
I'll start: CLR James.

At least on this board he doesn't seem to be mentioned very much, but James is very popular (or was, I think) with the British left, from Labour leftists to anarchists. He has a library named after him in Hackney, and The Black Jacobins is widely considered a classic, yet everyone knows James simply as a Trotskyist, despite him rejecting Trotskyism quite sharply. His work with the 'Correspondence Publishing Committee' can be seen as a forerunner of autonomist Marxism (Harry Cleaver and a number of others argue it is), and his book with Cornelius Castoriadis, Facing Reality, is an excellent (if dated) account of the Hungarian Revolution.

He wasn't perfect politically but he was an interesting character nevertheless, and he had a great mind; he wrote on Shakespeare, Herman Melville, ancient Greece, existentialism, cricket...! He argued with Stokely Carmichael about the phrase 'Black Power', had meetings with Trotsky, and wrote a play that had Paul Robeson in its lead role.

It's funny though, despite James being a staunch Leninist until his death, I was introduced to him by a libertarian socialist, who also introduced me to my other cool but underrated figure:

Maurice Brinton

I don't really have much to say about him except that I like his work and that Solidarity seemed like an awesome organisation. Like James, Brinton was a rejected Trotskyism and had links with Cornelius Castoriadis. Unlike James Brinton was a highly respected doctor as well as revolutionary socialist.

For Workers' Power is great and on Google Books http://books.google.com/books?id=_ztHKlN_ObwC&lpg=PP1&dq=maurice%20brinton&pg=PP1#v=onepage&q&f=false

So yeah, who do you think is deserving of more attention than they are given? They don't have to be particularly obscure even.

Honorary shoutouts go to Ricardo Magon Flores and Lucy Parsons (better than Emma Goldman imo).

manic expression
6th January 2011, 22:26
The International Brigades are absolutely chock full of them...out of the American volunteers: Oliver Law, Herman Bottcher, Hyman Katz, Salaria Kee, Irving Fajans, Milton Wolff, William Aalto, Edward A Carter and many others are just a few out even more.

A few notable figures from the Canadian volunteers: in the service of the Spanish Republic Norman Bethune developed the first mobile blood transfusion; after the Spanish Civil War went to China to serve with Communist forces in their struggle against the Japanese invasion, an effort that took his life in 1939. Bert Ramelson, another Canadian volunteer who fought in Spain, joined the Royal Tank Corps in WWII, was captured in Italy, then escaped a POW camp and joined antifascist Italian partisans, and after the war was a leading figure in British unions.

The German volunteers, including Hans Beimler most notably, must be recognized as well. There are almost too many to name. In many ways I feel The International Brigades represent the very best our movement/movements have to offer.

FreeFocus
6th January 2011, 22:34
I think Murray Bookchin is very, very underappreciated, obviously in the wider world, but also on here and in Leftist circles generally. His stance on Palestine was wrong but besides that he has some valuable insights.

ed miliband
7th January 2011, 08:00
I think Murray Bookchin is very, very underappreciated, obviously in the wider world, but also on here and in Leftist circles generally. His stance on Palestine was wrong but besides that he has some valuable insights.

The Third Revolution is very underrated imo.

blake 3:17
7th January 2011, 18:54
A quick list. Most have been celebrated at points but are underappreciated now --

Raymond Williams, activist, author and critic; Sheila Rowbotham, socialist feminist historian; Norman Bethune, communist doctor and internationalist; Walter Benjamin, weird anarcho-Communist literary critic and philosopher; Ho Chi Minh, leader of the Vietnamese revolution; Nikolai Bukharin, principled Bolshevik; Emma Goldman, anarchist supreme; Lev Vygotsky, Marxist psychologist and theorist of child development; Felix Guattari, anarchist psychoanalyst and Farrell Dobbs, Trotskyist Teamster, master tactician and developer of pattern bargaining.