Log in

View Full Version : Spanish military takes over airspace, following controller walkout



Havet
4th December 2010, 15:09
Spain’s military was forced to take control of the country’s national airspace Friday after a mass industrial action that left some 330,000 travellers stranded and was expected to cause a national emergency Saturday if continued.

AP - Spain’s military took control of the nation’s airspace Friday night after air traffic controllers staged a massive sickout that stranded at least 330,000 travelers on the eve of a long holiday weekend, forcing the government to shut down Madrid’s big international hub and seven other airports.

About six hours after the nation descended into total travel chaos, Deputy Prime Minister Alfredo Perez Rubalcaba announced that the Defense Ministry had “taken control of air traffic in all the national territory.” He said the army would make all decisions on air traffic control, organization, planning and supervision.

If enough controllers do not show up for work Saturday to restore normal flight operations, Prime Minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero plans to declare a national emergency that would force them to do so, Rubalcaba said. No-show controllers will face unspecified criminal charges punishable by “serious prison time,” he said.

Spanish flagship carrier Iberia SA said all of its flights in and out of Madrid were suspended until at least 11 a.m. Saturday, but other airlines did not give guidance for when flights might resume.

The controllers abandoned their posts amid a lengthy dispute over working conditions and after Zapatero and his ministers on Friday approved a package of austerity measures - including a move to partially privatize airports and hand over management of the Madrid and Barcelona airports to the private sector.

Angry passengers waited in huge lines for hours until giving up when it became clear their flights would not depart. Air traffic controllers meeting to plot strategy at a hotel near Madrid’s airport were heckled and filmed by stranded passengers as the controllers entered.

“To the unemployment line with you all!” one man yelled at the controllers, in footage shown by Spanish National Television.

Handfuls of passengers made it out of Madrid to destinations like Barcelona and Lisbon, Portugal, on buses provided by airlines. But the vast majority were forced to go home or to hotels with no information on when they might make their canceled flights. Some slept in the airports.

“It’s a disgrace, how can a group of people be so selfish as to wreck the plans of so many people?” said dentist Marcela Vega, 35, unable to travel from Madrid to Chile with her husband, 5-year-old son and baby boy.

Spain’s airport authority, known as Aena, said authorities were in contact with Europe’s air traffic agency, Eurocontrol, and the United State’s FAA about how best to deal with arriving international flights.

Aena chief Juan Ignacio Lema called the sickout “intolerable” and warned controllers to return to work, or face disciplinary action or criminal charges.

“We’re asking the controllers to stop blackmailing the Spanish people,” Lema said.

Spain’s air traffic controllers have been in bitter negotiations for a year with state-owned Aena over wages, working conditions and privileges. The dispute intensified in February after the government restricted overtime, cutting the average annual pay of controllers from about ¤350,000 ($463,610) to around ¤200,000 ($264,920).

The sickout also closed four airports in the Canary islands off Africa’s coast, a favorite winter destination for sun-seeking Europeans, and airports in prime Mediterranean tourism spots of Ibiza, Palma de Mallorca and Menorca.

Spanish Development Minister Jose Blanco convened an emergency meeting and his ministry announced that “controllers have begun to communicate their incapacity to continue offering their services, abandoning their places of work.” Blanco later told reporters that authorities were forced to close airspace around Madrid for safety reasons.

“We won’t permit this blackmail that they are using to turn citizens into hostages,” Blanco said

The controllers’ union has complained for weeks that many members have already worked their maximum hours for all of 2010, and that all 2,000 are overworked and understaffed. Friday’s sickout was not expected, but the union had warned it could mount one over the Christmas holiday. Spanish air traffic controllers are prohibited by law from going on strike.

Aena said most controllers had left their workstations or never showed up, and that only 10 controllers remained on duty in Madrid to handle emergencies.

Some controllers began to return to work late Friday, including about half of the normal staff in Barcelona, where several flights took off by early Saturday. But Rubalcaba said the number of returning controllers was spotty, and that some who showed up refused to perform their duties.

Madrid’s sprawling Barajas airport was empty after midnight. It had 1,300 flights scheduled for Friday, but it wasn’t clear how many had taken off and landed before the sickout.

More than 5,000 flights were scheduled for the nation Friday, and about 3,000 departed or landed before the sickout began in the late afternoon.

Monday is a national holiday marking the Day of the Spanish Constitution, and Wednesday is a religious holiday. Many Spaniards take advantage of them for a five-day weekend or a week of vacation, and about 4 million people had flights booked for the period in the nation of 46 million.

Many of Spain’s famed football players were forced to head on trains and buses with their teams so they could make it to weekend games.

Source (http://www.france24.com/en/20101204-spain-military-control-airspace-strike-stranded-passangers-national-emergency)

Unlike common strikes, where one goes to inform the government of the date when workers want to make a strike, airspace controllers made what is usually called a "savage strike", a strike without warning (a proper strike, no?), and simply did not show up to work. Government military, after taking over, warns that if they don't show up soon, they will be in violation of the Penal Code, and might be put to jail

YPpOYLm2ODk

For those who understand spanish (or have google chrome as a web browser with automatic translation), you might want to read this (http://www.notife.com/noticia/articulo/1017993/zona/1/Zapatero_militarizo_los_aeropuertos_de_Espana.html ) too as another news source.

Impulse97
4th December 2010, 16:01
Very interesting.

I hope their strike succeeds!

What do you think?:hammersickle::hammersickle::hammersickle:

Jazzratt
4th December 2010, 16:06
Whenever they're threatened by effective workers actions it doesn't take long for the bourgeois bastards to call on their lackeys and goons to make threats does it?

RGacky3
4th December 2010, 16:09
Whether or not the strike succedes depends on public support, public sector strikes are a very different beast than private sector strikes, they depend a lot more on the political dynamic.

BTW, was this a wild cat strike? Because that would be interesting.

Havet
4th December 2010, 16:11
BTW, was this a wild cat strike? Because that would be interesting.

I think so

RGacky3
4th December 2010, 16:16
Well that changes things, because then you can't really attack the union, that makes it MUCH harder for the state to deal with.

Havet
4th December 2010, 17:38
Well that changes things, because then you can't really attack the union, that makes it MUCH harder for the state to deal with.

Does it really? The state is already saying that if they don't show up to work they will be arrested. I'm not sure this will be very effective...

ckaihatsu
4th December 2010, 17:52
Very interesting.

I hope their strike succeeds!

What do you think?:hammersickle::hammersickle::hammersickle:


With the normalization of the means of mass communication -- the Internet -- there is less and less justification for formal matters to have to take place in person, as through traveling. This means that *air* travel, in particular, becomes more of a *luxury* item, and so should be subject to democratic proletarian control, *not* directed by fiat from the government and its military.

RGacky3
4th December 2010, 17:55
Does it really? The state is already saying that if they don't show up to work they will be arrested. I'm not sure this will be very effective...

Direct visable violence against its own people is always the last resort of the ruling class.

If it was union action the state could pay off the officials, demonize the union in the press, pay off some workers as scabs and so on.

Now the state has to do this, its embarrasing and can have a huge backlash, the union leaders don't have the control and you can't pay of the workers because they are the ones doing it themselves.

The government won't arrest these people, I would be suprised it that went through.

Bud Struggle
4th December 2010, 17:55
Well back in the day when the US Air Traffic Controllers went on strike President Ronald Reagan used it as a keystone to break the back of not only the ATC union--but of a lot of other American unions, too.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Air_Traffic_Controllers_Organization_ (1968)

Let's hope history doesn't repeat itself.

Ele'ill
4th December 2010, 18:06
Well back in the day when the US Air Traffic Controllers went on strike President Ronald Reagan used it as a keystone to break the back of not only the ATC union--but of a lot of other American unions, too.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Air_Traffic_Controllers_Organization_ (1968) (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Air_Traffic_Controllers_Organization_ %281968%29)

Let's hope history doesn't repeat itself.


Or perhaps in this era it will highlight the notion that workers can organize and move farther forward in this manner than if they had played around inside of that allowed power structure. Don't engage in struggle by the suggested methods given to you by your enemy. It's a lot more work but that heavy workload is what's needed anyways- the timing and incentive seem appropriate now.

What does this situation look like in regards to solidarity actions of equal importance like strikes, sit-ins or walkouts in other countries? Any news on movement building surrounding this?

DDR
4th December 2010, 18:35
The military and the civil guard (military police so to speak) have enter the control towers of the main airports, armed, to make the cotrolers work.

If they refuse to work they might be charged with sedition.

This strike have been called after the anouncement of new messures of the budged that in other things privatized the main airports (and takes away the welfare pension of 426 € to lng time unemployeds)

Ele'ill
4th December 2010, 18:57
The military and the civil guard (military police so to speak) have enter the control towers of the main airports, armed, to make the cotrolers work.

If they refuse to work they might be charged with sedition.

This strike have been called after the anouncement of new messures of the budged that in other things privatized the main airports (and takes away the welfare pension of 426 € to lng time unemployeds)


Do you have an accurate number of how many people are involved in the strike?

Bud Struggle
4th December 2010, 19:00
The military and the civil guard (military police so to speak) have enter the control towers of the main airports, armed, to make the cotrolers work.

If they refuse to work they might be charged with sedition.

This strike have been called after the anouncement of new messures of the budged that in other things privatized the main airports (and takes away the welfare pension of 426 € to lng time unemployeds)

Just a note: it's pretty nice that RevLeft has a man/woman on the spot to give us updated information. :)

Thanks.

DDR
4th December 2010, 19:09
@Mari3l:

No clue, the strike is called by the controllers only.

@Bud Struggle:

Thanks man, but i'm far away from home, sorry all that I know is by the press and the RTVE.

BTW: The vicepresident is speaking right now bout te issue.

Bud Struggle
4th December 2010, 19:12
Bad struggle!!!!! :d :d :d

RGacky3
4th December 2010, 19:17
The military and the civil guard (military police so to speak) have enter the control towers of the main airports, armed, to make the cotrolers work.

If they refuse to work they might be charged with sedition.

This strike have been called after the anouncement of new messures of the budged that in other things privatized the main airports (and takes away the welfare pension of 426 € to lng time unemployeds)

HUGE opportunity here, if the state brings out the guns you'll have a huge problem, thats when the workeres have to stand strong.

Ele'ill
4th December 2010, 19:17
I'm really interested in the number of people striking- if anyone comes across this info post it here- it will be a worthwhile post

I'm also interested in how it was organized and if the government knows who did the main organizing as they're likely the ones who are going to face the 'serious prison time'. Now would be the time for further strikes to act as leverage and prison prevention.

Ele'ill
4th December 2010, 19:21
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-11918008



But the threat of prosecution appeared to have been enough to persuade the controllers to return to work, our correspondent adds.
By late afternoon, officials said 283 of 296 controllers had turned up for their shifts, with just 13 absent.

DDR
4th December 2010, 19:25
Well regarding the second question:

Yesterday at 16:00 hours the 90% of the controllers have leave their jobs because a medical problem. At 21:30 the goverment goes on TV and sayis that if in an hour none is working the will put the controllers under military command and law. The controllers don't show. The military takes over the air space at 01:00, some of the conrollers go to work but they don't perform any task. he gov sends more military. At 03:00 the airpors beging to work.

As regarding what the VP said:

*No more of these strikes will occur or they will use this tactic again.
*The state of alarm will be for 15 days, more thay can be added if the parlament decides so.
*90% of the controllers are working right now.
*They will be legal actions against the strikers

Havet
4th December 2010, 19:25
I'm really interested in the number of people striking- if anyone comes across this info post it here- it will be a worthwhile post

I'm also interested in how it was organized and if the government knows who did the main organizing as they're likely the ones who are going to face the 'serious prison time'. Now would be the time for further strikes to act as leverage and prison prevention.

According to TeleCinco (http://www.gente5.telecinco.es/sondeos/031210noria/031210noria.html), only 3 out of 10 workers went to their job today

I've also read elsewhere that these workers are rather wealthy, though I cannot confirm this. But yeah, pretty much every spanish is cursing at them right now. Not a favourable thing.

DDR
4th December 2010, 19:27
Yeah the earn a lot of money and every big holiday or weekend they make this things, so none will say anithing in favor of the controllers.

Havet
4th December 2010, 19:28
Also in, they have pretty much surrendered, planes are starting to get off the ground.

They say they were facing between 8 to 10 years in prison, with guns pointed at them, so they had no choice

Source (in spanish though) (http://www.elmundo.es/elmundo/2010/12/04/espana/1291451590.html)

Bud Struggle
4th December 2010, 19:33
Also in, they have pretty much surrendered, planes are starting to get off the ground.

They say they were facing between 8 to 10 years in prison, with guns pointed at them, so they had no choice

Source (in spanish though) (http://www.elmundo.es/elmundo/2010/12/04/espana/1291451590.html)

You can see where the government is comming from. This area is a bit to VITAL for strikes to occur in any meaningful fashion.

They will KILL strikers if they get in the way. Time to move on.

Ele'ill
4th December 2010, 19:33
Also in, they have pretty much surrendered, planes are starting to get off the ground.

They say they were facing between 8 to 10 years in prison, with guns pointed at them, so they had no choice

Source (in spanish though) (http://www.elmundo.es/elmundo/2010/12/04/espana/1291451590.html)


I haven't read the specifics regarding their complaints of working conditions and the management shift to the private sector but what did they expect was going to happen? It sort of seems as though they were unprepared for what I would consider to be common consequences of such action.

DDR
4th December 2010, 19:37
Not really, they think that it would be like always. They strike, 2 days with the air chaos, then the goverment surrenders and they win something. This is the first time that they didn't succed

Ele'ill
4th December 2010, 19:41
You can see where the government is comming from.

If it's bad enough that you have to strike to receive decent pay, benefits, hours and work environment it's a perfect occupation to strike from as your absence makes an immediate impact.

What is the class status of the 250,000 people that were stranded?



They will KILL strikers if they get in the way. Time to move on.

They will always be willing to order the killing of strikers.

Havet
4th December 2010, 19:42
I haven't read the specifics regarding their complaints of working conditions and the management shift to the private sector but what did they expect was going to happen? It sort of seems as though they were unprepared for what I would consider to be common consequences of such action.

I dunno. if you want more specifics, i think ive found some.

They basically complain about the controllers, the ministery and AENA not coming together in agreement, creating delays in eight months that have made airplane companies report losses around 154 million euros. They are also complaining about the parcial privatization of the industry. Apparently they were aiming this strike for the 9th of december, with representatives of the CC OO, UGT and USO reporting that they would meet with the state sindical coordinater to agree on timelines.

But apparently, all of that went to the dustbin and they just went on with it anyway.

Bud Struggle
4th December 2010, 19:44
Not really, they think that it would be like always. They strike, 2 days with the air chaos, then the goverment surrenders and they win something. This is the first time that they didn't succed

This was a badly run strike--and not how I'd plan it. I'd ORANIZE. You start with the olive grower union and go to the hotel workers union and then to the ATF. (With a couple of steps in between.)

A couple of union strikes correctly planned could look like a NATIONWIDE strike. This looks like some outlaws on the make.

Ele'ill
4th December 2010, 19:47
Involving multiple industries.

Bud Struggle
4th December 2010, 19:54
Involving multiple industries.

Yea. Hire me on (for a slight fee) and I'll topple multiple governments. :)

And all I would need would be a wild haired radical vixen by my side. Sigh. ;)

Ele'ill
4th December 2010, 20:04
Yea. Hire me on (for a slight fee) and I'll topple multiple governments. :)

Why bother when the actual workers affected can do it for free- gain experience- and organize others?




And all I would need would be a wild haired radical vixen by my side. Sigh. ;)


Anything you can do I can do better.

Bud Struggle
4th December 2010, 20:06
Anything you can do I can do better.

Evita? ;)

mossy noonmann
4th December 2010, 21:03
Are the figures for their salaries in the original article correct?

seems like a fuck of a lot of money to me!

Ele'ill
4th December 2010, 21:24
I wouldn't use a high wage or salary as an excuse not to fight against the negative shift of working conditions as it's a hop and skip away from cuts and layoffs and one step away from lowering pay. I would be extremely hesitant to give up ground.

ckaihatsu
4th December 2010, 23:39
The real implications of the [European Stability Mechanism], which is supported by the International Monetary Fund, were revealed in a comment by one of the experts who worked on developing it. Andre Sapir, a leading member of a Brussels think-tank, declared: “If you had asked me a year ago, I would have said such an idea was impossible…One is now accepting an idea which itself is an incredible leap—that a euro area country’s debt may be restructured. That was unthinkable, it was something just for emerging countries. In that sense, this is a real revolution.”

The “revolution” Sapir is referring to is the power of the European Union to deploy the type of “shock therapy” policies implemented by the IMF in a series of countries in the past. Following an intervention by the IMF in Argentina in the 1990s, the country’s economy shrunk by 27 percent and over half of the population was plunged into poverty.

http://wsws.org/articles/2010/dec2010/euro-d02.shtml

RGacky3
5th December 2010, 10:16
You can see where the government is comming from. This area is a bit to VITAL for strikes to occur in any meaningful fashion.

They will KILL strikers if they get in the way. Time to move on.

Bud you barely know the background and your already saying move on. The government won't kill the strikers, the government probably won't arrest tehm either.

Your just against it because its unions.

Where the government is comming from? They wanted to privatize it, they should have anticipated a strike, this is'nt America, workers fight back.


This was a badly run strike--and not how I'd plan it. I'd ORANIZE. You start with the olive grower union and go to the hotel workers union and then to the ATF. (With a couple of steps in between.)

A couple of union strikes correctly planned could look like a NATIONWIDE strike. This looks like some outlaws on the make.

I've done union organizing in the past, and threatened strike. You don't start off weak and see how it goes, you've got to ask small but threaten high.

This looks like some outlaws on the make to you, but to everyone else, it looks like people looking out for their pensions. In a place like spain where austerity measures are hurting everyone I'm betting there will be a lot of support for this strike.

The Socialist party is in a strange position here, they won in 2008 (the executive at least), as a backlash againts the right wing and the Iraq war, however I think they're gonna loose the left in Spain, and I'm guessing the already popular anarchist groups are going to get more popular, along with the communists.

Right now for the state its loose loose, if the government uses force against the strikers, and if its visible, there will be a huge backlash and further strikes, but if they give up, it might hurt their austerity measures because people will fight back. But the Socialist government is acting somewhat like the british labor party, they want socialism, but as long as they don't piss off the capitalists, the banksters and the rich too much, but when push comes to shove, your gonna have to piss off someone.

If I were the Socialist party I would actually be the socialist party rather than piss my pants when the IMF, the EU and the banksters say boo, its easy to be a socialist when you don't have to pick sides (at least in Europe it is), but the real socialists are the ones that are on the workers side.

La Comédie Noire
5th December 2010, 10:24
The fact they couldn't resolve it without threat of physical violence and prison time says a lot about our society.

Bud Struggle
5th December 2010, 18:45
Gack. I don't know. It seems the strike is over. The planes are flying and now the Spanish government is going to initiate action to punish these guys--maybe severly.

And you think they won? To me it looks like they get their asses handed to them.

RGacky3
5th December 2010, 19:11
I did'nt say I think they won, I'm saying its an opportunity and a hard situation for the government. But your right, looks like the government beat the strike.

Its a shame, if the strikers held strong, they probably would have won. I believe that based on history.

ckaihatsu
8th December 2010, 05:11
The stench of a police state once again hangs over Spain. The 2,200 air traffic controllers were forced back to work Friday and Saturday at gunpoint. Armed soldiers now stand guard in the airport towers as the workers direct air traffic under the threat of immediate arrest should they stop work.

http://wsws.org/articles/2010/dec2010/pers-d06.shtml

RGacky3
8th December 2010, 10:42
Its really a shame, if they held strong I would have bet that they would have own. Now they lost and they arn't gonna be able to get the fight back.